Al Mayadeen English

  • Ar
  • Es
  • x
Al Mayadeen English

Slogan

  • News
    • Politics
    • Economy
    • Sports
    • Arts&Culture
    • Health
    • Miscellaneous
    • Technology
    • Environment
  • Articles
    • Opinion
    • Analysis
    • Blog
    • Features
  • Videos
    • NewsFeed
    • Video Features
    • Explainers
    • TV
    • Digital Series
  • Infographs
  • In Pictures
  • • LIVE
News
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Sports
  • Arts&Culture
  • Health
  • Miscellaneous
  • Technology
  • Environment
Articles
  • Opinion
  • Analysis
  • Blog
  • Features
Videos
  • NewsFeed
  • Video Features
  • Explainers
  • TV
  • Digital Series
Infographs
In Pictures
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Asia-Pacific
  • Europe
  • Latin America
  • MENA
  • Palestine
  • US & Canada
BREAKING
Al Mayadeen's correspondent: Israeli occupation forces blew up Noura Al-Kaabi Hospital, designated for kidney dialysis patients, in the northern Gaza Strip
Al Mayadeen's correspondent: Israeli drone targets a car on the Ayta al-Shaab-Debel road in southern Lebanon
Yemeni Armed Forces Spokesperson Yahya Saree: The remaining airlines that have not yet complied with the ban are urged to take this into serious consideration to ensure the safety of their aircraft and passengers
Yemeni Armed Forces Spokesperson Yahya Saree: The YAF, after successfully imposing a partial ban on air traffic at Lydd Airport, are now working to impose a full ban on air traffic at the aforementioned airport in the coming period
Yemeni Armed Forces Spokesperson Yahya Saree: YAF's UAV Unit carried out three military operations targeting three vital Israeli sites in the occupied Palestinian areas of Yafa, Isdud, and Umm al-Rashrash, using three drones
Yemeni Armed Forces Spokesperson Yahya Saree: The operation successfully achieved its objective, causing millions of Zionist settlers to flee to shelters and bringing airport operations to a halt
Yemeni Armed Forces Spokesperson Yahya Saree: YAF targeted Lydd Airport in the occupied Yafa area (Tel Aviv) with a hypersonic ballistic missile
Israeli media: Ben Gurion Airport airspace sut down following missile launch from Yemen
Israeli media: Air raid sirens sound in the central region and Hashfala following the detection of a missile launch from Yemen
SDF announces the killing of three of its members as a result of ISIS cells detonating a landmine targeting a vehicle of a security patrol on the Hasaka-Raqqa road

From “Fundamentalists” to “Islamists”: Is there a problem of Islamophobia on the “left”?

  • David Miller David Miller
  • Source: Al Mayadeen English
  • 25 Oct 2022 16:31
  • 3 Shares
9 Min Read

Since the outbreak of the “protests” in Iran, I have increasingly come across socialist or “left-wing” people of various stripes using language that is common ground with hard-core Islamophobes. How are we to make sense of this?

  • x
  • From “Fundamentalists” to “Islamists”: Is there a problem of Islamophobia on the “left”?

Last week, I was invited to speak at the British Left-wing meeting on the protests in Iran. Much could be said about this meeting, but I want to focus on one theme, which I fear is too prevalent on the left and is not really recognized as an issue. The theme is Islamophobia. This appears to affect even those leftists who are solid on almost all other issues including Zionism and Palestine and sometimes even Ukraine.

The Iranian “opposition”

The Islamophobia of monarchist opposition to the Islamic Republic is clear enough. In alliance with supporters of the terror group the Mujidheen-e-Khalq, in late September, they attacked worshippers at the Islamic Centre of England, the main mosque of London's Shia Iranian community. Windows were reportedly smashed, and alcohol was thrown. 

Of “Fundamentalists”, “Islamists”, and “Mullahs”

Last week at the meeting, among the terms on display were “Mullahs”, “Islamist”, and “loony Islamic cult." The speakers' names are public so I will mention them by name, but I will spare the blushes of others who spoke or participated. The two other speakers apart from me were two Iranian women. The first is Nasrin Parvaz; the author of a book on her experience in prison in Iran, and the second is Yassamine Mather; a long-time campaigner with various groups associated with the Communist Party of Great Britain.

Hands off the People of Iran

Mather wrote a piece in the Communist Party paper the Weekly Worker on the protests in which she referred to the “loony Islamic cult, Mojahedin-e-Khalq”. The MeK is a terror group with a base in Albania, a NATO member, where it maintains a troll farm among other infrastructure.  It was removed from the US register of terrorist groups in 2012 following an effective lobbying campaign with Neocon support. There are many things to be said politically about the MEK, but condemning it as “Islamic” is straightforward racism. We should not be surprised.  Mather is a founder of Hands off the People of Iran, a CP-related group that refused affiliation with Stop the War Coalition in 2007 on the grounds of being too close to the imperialist countries in its support for regime change in Iran.

Related News

Why I hate Zionism and its backers more than ever!

Why is the British anti-racist movement weak on Zionism?

Islamist – useful analytical term or racist smear?

The other speaker Nasrin referred to the Islamic Republic as “Islamist”, a term that – she claimed – is used by the Republic itself. This is of course untrue. Of course, Parvaz is not the only one to use the term, for the other speaker at the event Yassamine Mather, as well as other "left-wing" commentators, used it too. They use it in much the same way it is used by neoconservatives and Zionists. The terms Islamism and Islamist have a history. 

In a valuable contribution, Asim Qureshi of the civil rights group Cage has excavated the colonial origins of the idea of pan-Islamism. His historical account takes in the nineteenth century with the narrative stopping in 1906.  Since then, of course, there has been a significant development, not least since the beginning of the 1980s – occasioned by the Islamic revolution in Iran, the rise of the “Afghan rebels”, and events in Egypt associated with the struggle against the Muslim Brotherhood. These events have concentrated minds in Washington, London, Paris, and "Tel Aviv". It is as a result of the imperialist countries' response to these events that the term “Islamist” emerged only in the late 1970s at which time, also, the term Islamism was redefined.  An early sign of this was a famous 1976 essay by the British Zionist historian Bernard Lewis titled “The Return of Islam”. He was followed by French intellectuals hostile to the liberation movements of North Africa.  Later, the term was promoted via a journal called Central Asian Survey, which we now know appears to have been a US propaganda operation.

As Andreas Krieg, an academic at King’s College London writes, the use of the term places ISIS “on the same political spectrum as groups like … the Popular Mobilisation Forces in Iraq, who sacrificed everything in order to halt” ISIS. He also notes “it was only after 1979 that the concept experienced a revival that would link Islamism to ‘extremism’ and ‘violence’ in a supposedly conspirative effort by Muslims to create a pan-Islamist entity to rule the world.”

The emergence of “Islamic terrorism”

And it is this linkage that has also created the similarly bankrupt notion of “Islamic terrorism”. This again appears to be connected to Bernard Lewis who chaired a panel at the Jonathan Institute Second Conference on International Terrorism in Washington DC in 1984 on “Terrorism and the Islamic World”. The panel included three prominent Islamophobic Professors Eli Kedourie, J.B. Kelly, and P.J. Vatikiotis. The event was organized by Benjamin Netanyahu, the then-Ambassador of “Israel” to the UN. It marked the initiation of the idea that there was something intrinsic to Islam that linked it to terrorism, an idea that has since been capitalized on by the Zionist movement and its allies. 

Women Against Fundamentalism

Another key term in left Islamophobia is “fundamentalism” In the UK, a certain current of feminists created a group called Women Against Fundamentalism back in the late 1980s.  It's not as if they had a discriminating conception of “fundamentalism” pointing only at a small subset of those in religious movements.  No, they specifically stated (1994, p. 7) that they were referring to movements that “use religion as a basis” for political strategies. That is practically all Muslim political movements with the exception of a handful of Westernised secular groups, which are almost without exception funded by state-related interests, some of which we will mention below. The definition would also include Christian liberation theology and even the Quakers, the well-known liberal Christian group.

It’s extraordinary that it was thought appropriate for this Islamophobic term to be used in the name of an organization claiming to be progressive, but there it is. One of the key activists was Julia Bard, a member of the Jewish Socialists’ Group – putting one of a number of question marks over that organization. Others involved included Nira Yuval-Davis who describes herself as “an anti-Zionist diasporic Israeli Jew;” a term which appears to endorse the false Zionist conception that Jews outside Israel are a diaspora and give political legitimacy to the concept of “Israel”. Perhaps the most well-known figurehead of the WAF was Gita Sahgal, best known for attacking the civil rights group Cage as “Jihadi”, on which I have previously written at length. The use of the term “Jihadi” is yet another Islamophobic term for Muslims active in political life.

Enter Maryam Namazie

Sahgal has also been close to the Council of Ex-Muslims Britain (CEMB). She appeared, for example, for “evening drinks” at a meeting in 2013 along with Maryam Namazie, the spokesperson for the CEMB. CEMB is an anti-Muslim group that was founded in 2007. Namazie, who is Iranian, was prominent in the demonstrations in early October against the Iranian government in Trafalgar Square on behalf of the CEMB. Images of her topless protest were later removed by Instagram and Twitter.

She joined the Islamophobic monarchists and other anti-government factions that day. Namazie is of course a former leading member of the Worker-Communist Party of Iran, though she maintained (as of 2017) that she is still a “communist”. This has not stopped her from working with the far-right via her “anti-Shariah” campaign group (One Law for All). Among its supporters from Islamophobic networks are leading neoconservative networkers Ayaan Hirsi Ali and Caroline Fourest, as well as Zionists such as Alan Johnson, who works for the "Israel" lobby group BICOM. In addition, there is a range of UK anti-Muslim civil society groups including the Lawyers’ Secular Society, the National Secular Society, Women Against Fundamentalism (mentioned above), and British Muslims for Secular Democracy. One Law for All also worked closely with the well-known far-right figure Baroness Cox. Among other claims to fame, Cox was responsible for inviting the Dutch Islamophobe, Geert Wilders, to the UK.

This is not just a question of language, but a tendency on the left to see specifically Muslim involvement in politics as problematic unless it conforms to Western secularist tenets of belief, tenets which only really apply to – or at least emerged from – a critique of Christianity specifically. This is to say that it is not only the “pro-war” (secular) left with which there are problems but also parts of the “anti-war” (secular) left. If we are to foster an international realist anti-Imperialist movement, we will need to leave Islamophobic ideas and conceptions behind and develop a more thoroughgoing critique of Western culture and society.

_______________________________
David Miller is co-editor of the book What is Islamophobia? (Pluto 2017)

The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect Al Mayadeen’s editorial stance.
  • anti-Zionism
  • Zionism
  • Israel
  • Islamophobia
  • Iran
David Miller

David Miller

investigative researcher, broadcaster, and academic. He is the founder and co-director of the lobbying watchdog Spinwatch and editor of Powerbase.info.

Most Read

All
Although the background information does not indicate direct US involvement, considering the broader geopolitical context, it is plausible that the US would have an indirect impact. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Zeinab El-Hajj)

Did 'Israel', US fight a proxy war with China in South Asia during the India-Pakistan escalation?

  • Feature
  • 19 May 2025
The two countries need to sit down and resolve the crisis with maturity, to consider carefully that they could be being manipulated to be easily dominated. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Batoul Chamas)

Algeria and Mali, divided and almost conquered

  • Opinion
  • 25 May 2025
It may well be due to the longstanding relationship between MI6 and HTS, via Inter Mediate, that Britain was the first Western country to recognise their assumption of government in Syria. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Zeinab El-Hajj)

How MI6 helped HTS seize Syria

  • Opinion
  • 31 May 2025
Trump and Biden both pretended to be fighting Netanyahu

Trump and Biden both pretended to be fighting Netanyahu

  • Analysis
  • 28 May 2025

Coverage

All
The Ummah's Martyrs

More from this writer

All
"Israel" appears to be the only place in the world where there are actual demonstrations defending rapists as national heroes precisely because of their crimes. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Batoul Chamas)

'Israeli pride' - Celebrating rape in the Zionist entity

While Salams is intended to be for Muslims seeking marriage, the other companies owned by Match Group are seen as encouraging casual relationships like OK Cupid and Tinder. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Zeinab el-Hajj)

Selling Muslim marriage app Salams to the Zionist pornography complex

David Collier is the Zionist troll operative behind the intimidation of the BBC resulting in the removal of the Documentary How to Survive in a War Zone. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Batoul Chamas)

The pincer movement against the BBC

Palestine Solidarity Campaign shills for the Zionists

Palestine Solidarity Campaign shills for the Zionists

Al Mayadeen English

Al Mayadeen is an Arab Independent Media Satellite Channel.

All Rights Reserved

  • x
  • Privacy Policy
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Authors
Android
iOS