US pressure forces end of Cuba medical missions; patients suffer
Healthcare access is disrupted across Latin America and the Caribbean as several countries yield to US pressure and withdraw from medical agreements.
-
A Cuban doctor working in Venezuela asks questions to an inmate in handcuffs before she administers a quick COVID-19 test at a comprehensive diagnosis center that is set up to attend patients with the new coronavirus in Caracas, Venezuela, Aug 27, 2020 (AP)
Novlyn Ebanks, 73, had been scheduled to undergo a free eye surgery at St. Joseph’s Hospital in Kingston, but her treatment was cancelled after Jamaica decided in March to terminate its nearly three-decade-old agreement with Cuba for medical staff.
The hospital’s ophthalmology unit had largely depended on Cuban doctors, many of whom have since left the country.
“I’m really disturbed and concerned,” said Ebanks, who now expects to seek private care that could cost as much as 350,000 Jamaican dollars (around £1,600).
Her case reflects a wider pattern across Latin America and the Caribbean, where several governments have recently ended medical cooperation deals with Cuba amid pressure from the United States, The Guardian reported.
US pressure and Cuba’s rejection of allegations
Washington argues that Cuba’s overseas medical program amounts to “forced labour”, claiming that the Cuban state withholds a large portion of doctors’ salaries.
Cuba acknowledges it retains part of the earnings but rejects accusations of human rights abuses, stressing the claims are being used to justify broader US efforts to weaken its economy and push for political change, including through long-standing sanctions and restrictions on oil imports
Health workers, researchers, and humanitarian organizations warn that the abrupt withdrawal of Cuban doctors is hitting the most vulnerable hardest, particularly in remote and underserved regions where they were heavily deployed.
Expanding US diplomatic pressure
The United States has also reportedly pressured governments by restricting or revoking visas for officials, and in some cases their families, linked to Cuban medical programs.
Since the start of Donald Trump’s second term, countries including Jamaica, Guatemala, Guyana, Honduras, St Vincent and the Grenadines, the Bahamas, Antigua and Barbuda, and Paraguay have ended or begun phasing out agreements with Cuba.
Mexico remains the only major holdout. President Claudia Sheinbaum has defended the continued presence of roughly 3,000 Cuban doctors, calling them “of great help” in underserved rural areas.
Cuba’s international medical missions began in 1960, when doctors were sent to Chile following an earthquake. Since then, more than 600,000 Cuban health workers have served in over 160 countries.
While official figures are limited, analysts estimate that more than 20,000 Cuban medical professionals are currently working in about 50 countries.
Venezuela: The largest mission
The biggest deployment took place in Venezuela, beginning in 2004 under an oil-for-doctors arrangement. At its peak, nearly 30,000 Cuban medics were stationed there. Although reduced, more than 10,000 are still believed to be working in the country.
The program became a major source of income for Cuba, helping offset the impact of the US embargo. The US describes Cuba’s retention of wages, reportedly around 80%, as equivalent to “21st-century slavery”.
International bodies, including UN-linked organizations, have also received testimonies from former participants describing coercive conditions and have raised concerns about labour rights.
However, John Kirk, professor emeritus of Latin American studies at Dalhousie University in Canada, said his own interviews with 270 Cuban medical workers found no evidence of coercion.
“It’s not slave labour,” said Cuban doctor Yanili Magdariaga Menéndez, who worked in Venezuela for five years, describing the program as voluntary and economically motivated.
Brazil and competing narratives
Menendez said she did not view the salary arrangement as entirely fair, but understood it supported Cuba’s social services. She later worked in Brazil’s “More Doctors” program, which was ended in 2018 after political opposition from then-president Jair Bolsonaro.
Helen Yaffe of the University of Glasgow dismissed Washington’s allegations.
“How can they claim to care about human rights while blocking oil shipments to Cuba, which means that premature babies in incubators are left at risk during power cuts?” she said.
She also noted that US offers to replace Cuban doctors focus on infrastructure rather than training equivalent medical staff.
Guatemala warns of widening gaps
In Guatemala, where around 400 Cuban doctors are set to leave, NGOs say local systems will struggle to fill the gap, particularly in Indigenous communities.
“To abandon a programme like that is to strip healthcare access from some of the most disenfranchised and underserved populations in our part of the world,” said emergency physician Darren Cuthbert of the Emergency Project.
In Jamaica, Health Minister Christopher Tufton acknowledged that the departure of Cuban doctors has left “gaps”, especially in specialized services.
“Some of those gaps are challenging to fill because of the specialisation and the fact that we don’t have a local equivalent. So we have started by doubling up on the shifts … by local [doctors] to fill the void, particularly in eye care and oncology,” he stressed.
Tufton also suggested the shift could encourage investment in domestic medical training and the return of Jamaican doctors abroad.
For Ebanks, the policy shift has already had a direct impact. While she tries to find a way to afford treatment, she reflects on the doctors she has lost access to.
“These are the people that we really need to have around us to take care of us,” she stressed.