'Breakthrough' in Ukraine talks after Russia-US consultations: Vance
US Vice President JD Vance claims a "breakthrough" in Ukraine negotiations after Russia–US talks in Miami, while warning that deep disputes remain over multiple issues.
-
United States Vice President JD Vance speaks to reporters before boarding Air Force Two at Joint Base Andrews in Maryland, on December 16, 2025. (The New York Times via AP, Pool)
United States Vice President JD Vance announced what he described as a “breakthrough” in negotiations on Ukraine following consultations between Russian and American officials held in Miami, while acknowledging that major obstacles continue to block a comprehensive settlement.
In remarks to the UnHerd news portal on Monday, Vance said recent discussions had succeeded in bringing all contentious issues into the open, even if they remain unresolved.
"There are challenges with all three groups," Vance said. "I mean, I actually got an update from our negotiators this morning," he explained, adding, "So the breakthrough that I do feel that we’ve made is that all of the issues are actually out in the open."
Despite this assessment, the US vice president cautioned against expectations of an imminent resolution, stressing that negotiations remain fragile. "I think that we’ve made progress, but sitting here today, I wouldn’t say with confidence that we’re going to get to a peaceful resolution," he stressed.
"I think there’s a good chance we will, I think there’s a good chance we won’t," Vance asserted.
According to Vance, the question of territorial control continues to significantly slow negotiations, indicating that Kiev has come to recognize the inevitability of losing control over remaining territory in the Donetsk People’s Republic (DPR), but said the formal ceding of territory remains a deeply contentious issue within the talks.
Territorial status has long been one of the most sensitive elements of any proposed settlement, with Moscow insisting on recognition of realities on the ground, while Ukrainian officials have repeatedly rejected concessions involving sovereignty over disputed regions.
Read more: Witkoff highlights shared vision for Ukraine ceasefire
Zaporozhye nuclear plant discussed
Vance also revealed that negotiations have touched on the future of the Zaporozhye Nuclear Power Plant (ZNPP), Europe’s largest nuclear facility, which has been under Russian control since early in the war, saying that "minor issues" emerged over the plant.
“Who controls the [Zaporizhzhia] nuclear facility? Can it be jointly controlled? Does it need to be controlled by one or more sides?” Vance told UnHerd.
The remarks suggest that potential arrangements involving joint or alternative control of the facility are being explored as part of broader settlement discussions, though no formal agreement has been announced, and the issue remains highly sensitive for all parties involved.
Under the original US plan distributed in November, point 19 discussed the fate of the ZNPP in a future deal. The US plan suggested that electricity produced in the plant will be distributed equally between Russia and Ukraine, and that the plan will be launched under the supervision of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA).
The Miami consultations mark another phase in ongoing diplomatic contacts between Washington and Moscow as the Trump administration seeks to advance a negotiated end to the conflict. However, Vance’s comments underscore that while dialogue has expanded, fundamental disagreements over territory, sovereignty, and strategic infrastructure continue to cast doubt over the prospects of a near-term peace agreement.
Additionally, Europe and Ukraine were initially sidelined from the discussions between the US and Russia that preceded the 28-point plan. Later talks involved heavy engagement with Kiev and Brussels, where concerns were raised on several points, while others were outright rejected.
Read more: Putin open to dialogue with Macron: Kremlin