'Israel's' white phosphorus attacks on Lebanon expose legal loopholes
Human Rights Watch documents 23 verified incidents in southern Lebanon and warns that the weapons can cause severe burns and lifelong physical, psychological, and socioeconomic harm.
-
A white phosphorus shell from Israeli artillery explodes over a road leading to Chamaa village as it is seen from Tyre city, south Lebanon, March 27, 2026 (AP)
Recent use of white phosphorus munitions by Israeli occupation forces in Lebanon highlights the need for new international rules governing the use of the highly destructive weapons, Human Rights Watch and the International Human Rights Clinic at Harvard Law School said in a report released Wednesday.
The organizations called on countries to address the issue during the United Nations General Assembly’s monthlong disarmament meeting in New York in October 2026.
The 45-page report, “Uncontrolled Burn: The Inhumane Effects of White Phosphorus Munitions and the Need for Stronger Law,” records 23 verified incidents involving Israeli use of white phosphorus in southern Lebanon between March and May 2026. It also examines the severe injuries and other harm caused by the munitions in wars in recent years.
White phosphorus causes lifelong harm
White phosphorus weapons generate fire when their payload comes into contact with oxygen and are not currently subject to a treaty specifically regulating their use.
“White phosphorus munitions can inflict excruciating burns and cause lifelong physical, psychological, and socioeconomic harm,” said Bonnie Docherty, senior arms advisor at Human Rights Watch and lecturer at the International Human Rights Clinic at Harvard Law School. “Countries should condemn ongoing use of white phosphorus munitions, call for further international talks on the matter, and ensure that international law adequately addresses the weapons’ unacceptable human costs.”
The report’s findings draw on legal analysis, open-source investigations, 16 in-person and remote interviews, monitoring of diplomatic procedures, and desk research.
Reported use across multiple wars
Human Rights Watch said additional instances of white phosphorus use have been reported since 2000.
Those cases include Israeli use in Gaza in 2008-2009 and 2023; US-led coalition forces’ use in Iraq and Syria in 2017; Saudi Arabia-led coalition forces’ use in Yemen in 2016; Ethiopian forces’ use in Somalia in 2007; NATO forces, primarily from the United States, and anti-government forces’ use in Afghanistan between 2005-2011; and US use in Iraq in 2004.
The organizations said white phosphorus munitions fired over populated areas are indiscriminate because they cannot distinguish between civilians and combatants, making such use a violation of general international humanitarian law.
However, despite their incendiary effects, the weapons are not covered by Protocol III to the 1980 Convention on Conventional Weapons (CCW), which specifically addresses incendiary weapons.
Legal loophole under Protocol III
Protocol III defines incendiary weapons as those “primarily designed” to start fires and burn people. Under that definition, weapons created for other purposes remain outside its scope even when they produce comparable incendiary effects.
The report said white phosphorus munitions are excluded because they are primarily intended to obscure or illuminate military operations.
Human Rights Watch and the Harvard clinic examined the weapons under the Martens Clause, a principle of international humanitarian law stating that where no specific treaty applies, civilians and combatants remain protected by the principles of humanity and the dictates of public conscience.
White phosphorus can burn through flesh to the bone
The groups said white phosphorus munitions fall under the clause because of the nature of the injuries they inflict and the difficulty of treating them. White phosphorus can burn through flesh to the bone, while particles remaining inside wounds can reignite when exposed to oxygen, including when bandages are removed.
The report said opposition from countries, international organizations, civil society groups, medical professionals, and financial institutions demonstrates that the weapons conflict with the dictates of public conscience.
Human Rights Watch and the Harvard clinic therefore called for stronger and more specific international law to address their use.
“Diplomats, doctors, UN investigators, and others have expressed outrage at the cruel injuries caused by white phosphorus munitions,” Docherty said. “Countries have adopted treaties on poison gas and blinding lasers because they were inhumane and contrary to public conscience. They should do the same for white phosphorus munitions.”
Debate remains stalled at international level
White phosphorus munitions are not classified as chemical weapons because they are intended to burn rather than cause harm through toxicity. As a result, they are not covered by the Chemical Weapons Convention.
Much of the international debate surrounding white phosphorus has taken place within the framework of the Convention on Conventional Weapons. Dozens of countries have condemned the injuries caused by the weapons and called for dedicated discussions on the issue.
However, CCW meetings are conducted by consensus. Countries opposed to stronger legal measures have blocked proposals to allocate time for discussions on the humanitarian consequences of incendiary weapons and weapons with incendiary effects, as well as the shortcomings of Protocol III.
Despite those obstacles, Human Rights Watch and the Harvard clinic said countries supporting action on white phosphorus should continue raising the issue at the CCW’s five-year Review Conference, scheduled to take place November 16-20 at the UN in Geneva.
“The ultimate goal should be the adoption of strong international law that closes current legal loopholes and stigmatizes the use of white phosphorus munitions,” Docherty said. “A complete ban on production, transfer, and use of these weapons would have the greatest humanitarian benefits.”