'Annus horribilis,' MBS’s 3 big bets collapse together: The Economist
Mohammed bin Salman’s bets on beating Sanaa, remaking the economy and trusting Trump have unraveled at once, The Economist writes.
-
Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman joins President Donald Trump to greet delegations at the Royal Palace in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, Tuesday, May 13, 2025. (AP)
Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman’s biggest wagers, from defeating the YAF to remaking the Saudi economy and counting on US President Donald Trump as a dependable ally, have collapsed at the same time, leaving him with overlapping crises and no ready way out, an analysis by The Economist argues.
The magazine described the past year as an “annus horribilis” for the crown prince, pointing to the cancellation of the Future Investment Initiative as the clearest sign of how far things have slipped.
Saudi Arabia has failed to defeat Ansar Allah, and Riyadh had hoped the 2022 ceasefire would hold. The truce unraveled once MBS bombed Sanaa International Airport, leading to retaliatory strikes on KSA by the Yemeni Armed Forces.
People close to the crown prince told The Economist that every option before him is a bad one. He can send ground troops into a bloody war, keep up an air campaign that looks unlikely to succeed, or strike a deal that would further entrench Ansar Allah’s rule in Yemen.
An economic program already under strain
A prolonged war would damage Mohammed bin Salman’s economic program, which was faltering before 2026, the magazine said. Major projects have been put on hold as public finances come under pressure, and wages have not kept pace with rising inflation.
Annual foreign direct investment stands at no more than a third of the crown prince’s $100 billion target. The International Monetary Fund forecast a year ago that the Saudi economy would grow 4% in 2026, and it now expects a 3.3% contraction.
The Economist said any recovery in 2027 hinges on "peace" in West Asia, which depends heavily on Trump.
Riyadh believed it had leverage over the US president and courted him with promises of “implausible sums” in investments in the United States. It also struck deals with his family, paying a Trump-owned golf course to host Saudi-funded tournaments and investing $2 billion with his son-in-law Jared Kushner.
None of it stopped Trump from embarking on a “disastrous war.” “He’s not loyal to anyone for long,” a Saudi familiar with the situation told The Economist.
A crown prince out of sight
Mohammed bin Salman has largely stayed out of public view since October 10, when a Yemeni retaliatory strike on the Riyadh airport led to the death of 13 people.
Some Western commentators have begun asking whether this crisis-filled year threatens the crown prince’s rule. Diplomats in Riyadh consider that assessment exaggerated. “He was in a much tougher place seven or eight years ago,” one Western envoy said.
The Economist argued that the present moment is nonetheless harder. Most of the problems of his early years in power were self-inflicted and therefore easier to fix, and by 2021 he had already begun steering Saudi foreign policy in a more pragmatic direction. The magazine said he ended the blockade of Qatar and sought a deal with Sanaa, a shift that even the Biden administration grudgingly praised.
This year, the most consequential decision lies outside his control. Mohammed bin Salman has urged Trump not to escalate the war on Iran, and Saudi officials fear that if the president resumes bombing after November’s midterm elections, the kingdom could be hit from every direction if the current confrontation continues.
Foundations unchanged
The magazine claimed the crown prince made commendable progress in his first decade in power, yet the foundations of the Saudi state have barely changed. The economy still depends on oil revenue, the military is still structured to protect the ruling system rather than fight wars, and foreign policy still treats the United States as an indispensable ally.
The Economist pointed to the “Mecca Pact,” a mutual defense agreement with Pakistan and Turkey, as an attempt to find new allies who could replace an unreliable America, though it said such shifts will take time. In his second decade, it concluded, Mohammed bin Salman’s real test will be changing “the foundations, not just the façade.”