Democrats push to rebuild support as anti-Trump anger grows
Democrats may reclaim the House and possibly the Senate as opposition to Trump grows, but party candidates remain divided on how to capitalize on the moment.
-
Privacy booths are seen on the morning of the South Carolina Republican primary election at a church in Cayce, S.C., Feb. 24, 2024. (AP)
From local community events and neighborhood canvassing efforts to gatherings in small towns across the country, Democratic primary candidates say voters are expressing a similar sentiment: growing frustration with both major political parties and a belief that their concerns are being ignored, according to The Guardian.
The feature revealed that discussions with candidates, lawmakers, and political operatives suggest the Democratic Party is still searching for its identity 19 months after Donald Trump’s victory over Kamala Harris, with another pivotal round of US elections just five months away.
The Democratic Party continues to grapple with the fallout from its defeat in the 2024 presidential election. A contentious review process conducted by the Democratic National Committee, along with delays surrounding the release of its post-election assessment, fueled renewed debate about the party's future direction.
Yet candidates say voters rarely raise concerns about internal party reviews or questions surrounding the Democratic brand. Instead, they are focused on issues affecting their daily lives. Many want elected officials who will challenge Donald Trump, improve access to healthcare and housing, reduce living costs, strengthen schools, address immigration enforcement concerns, keep the United States out of foreign wars, lower fuel prices, safeguard jobs from artificial intelligence, tackle climate change, and limit the expansion of data centers in their communities.
Even so, many voters remain unconvinced that Democrats can effectively deliver on those priorities.
“It’s less about the bickering amongst Democrats and more about folks feeling like there are fewer people who give a shit in politics,” said Francesca Hong, a Democratic candidate for governor in Wisconsin.
Current political trends suggest Democrats have a strong opportunity to regain control of the House of Representatives and potentially compete for the Senate in November. However, there is little agreement among Democratic candidates about the strategy needed to capitalize on those opportunities.
Competing visions for the party's future
While some candidates are pursuing a centrist approach, others have embraced a more populist message from the left. Although many contenders are not preoccupied with discussions about the party's image, they acknowledge that voter perceptions continue to influence electoral outcomes and confidence in Democratic leadership.
Ken Martin, chair of the Democratic National Committee, conceded after releasing the party's election review that the Democratic brand “is in trouble”. He pointed to the success of policy initiatives associated with Democratic priorities even in areas where Democratic candidates struggle to win elections.
“We have to restore confidence in our party and show we can really deliver on our campaign promises to the American people,” he wrote.
Party leaders also argue that Democrats must expand their reach beyond traditional battleground states and rebuild support in rural and Republican-leaning regions that have received less attention in recent election cycles. In many areas, success may initially mean narrowing electoral margins rather than securing outright victories.
Reaching voters who feel left behind
Mallory McMorrow, a Michigan state legislator running for the US Senate, recently convened a discussion with Trump supporters in a competitive county to better understand both their motivations in 2024 and their current views.
According to McMorrow, one participant explained that he supported Trump because he promised to dismantle the existing political system, bring manufacturing jobs back to the United States, and end overseas wars.
While Trump has not fulfilled many of those promises, McMorrow said the voter remained convinced that leaders in Washington fail to understand the economic pressures facing people like him.
Primary battles reflect broader questions
Primary contests are increasingly serving as forums for Democrats to debate the party's identity and priorities.
Chris Rabb, a Pennsylvania state lawmaker representing one of the country's most reliably Democratic districts, said voters are also questioning the role of establishment politics within the party. He believes many want reassurance that Democrats are focused on helping the “people closest to the pain” rather than responding primarily to major donors.
“Most incumbents are never seriously challenged, so that’s how you build that entrenchment, that complacency, sometimes hubris,” Rabb said. “If you never have to worry about losing, who’s holding you to account?”
Criticism of the DNC’s election review
Martin secured the DNC chairmanship in February 2025 after pledging to conduct and publish an examination of the party’s presidential loss. Months passed without a report, however, and Martin eventually described it as not “ready for primetime,” opting against releasing it immediately.
In the meantime, numerous organizations across the ideological spectrum produced their own analyses of what went wrong in 2024.
When the report was finally released, Martin acknowledged the controversy.
“Ironically, in doing so, I ended up creating an even bigger distraction.”
Critics noted that the report lacked detailed analysis and omitted several major issues. It did not address Joe Biden’s age, widely viewed as a significant weakness during his reelection effort before he stepped aside in July 2024. It also failed to discuss the war on Gaza, a major source of division among Democratic voters.
The result, some argued, was a perception that Democrats had not fully confronted the causes of their defeat, making it more difficult for some voters to view the party as their political home.
Concerns about leadership and policy priorities
Abbas Alawieh, a leader of the uncommitted movement that pushed Democrats to support a Gaza ceasefire, is now running for the Michigan state senate. He told the Guardian that foreign policy and war remain major concerns among voters from many backgrounds.
“The fact that the autopsy report did not grapple with that issue, I think it’s just a further indication that the party’s out of touch with where voters are,” said Alawieh.
Michigan Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed argued that voters’ frustration extends beyond the report itself. He said many people see a leadership vacuum within the party and connect it to issues ranging from healthcare costs to overseas military spending.
“These are the issues that keep people up at night, and they feel like the party is just completely absent from the playing field, trying to fight the last battle, and even then, fought it poorly,” El-Sayed told The Guardian. “So, I think people want a Democratic party that is willing to show up and fight on the issues that are the most important in their lives, and they’re just not seeing that.”
Rabb added that many ordinary voters are largely unaware of the DNC controversy altogether.
“They don’t even know what ‘DNC’ stands for,” Rabb stressed.
Colorado Democratic consultant Julius Hernandez likewise dismissed the internal disputes as unhelpful.
“Voters are looking at us like: ‘Hey, how are you going to stop Donald Trump?’” he said.
Expanding beyond traditional battlegrounds
For years, Democrats in rural and Republican-leaning regions have argued that the national party spends too much time and money on a limited number of battleground states.
Jane Kleeb, who chairs Nebraska’s Democratic Party, said national messaging often reflects coastal priorities rather than the concerns of voters in rural America.
Michigan Democratic Party Chair Curtis Hertel Jr. said his organization has revived two county parties that had been inactive for more than a decade. He also traveled extensively across the state and organized events in Republican strongholds.
While attending the Mesick mushroom festival in a heavily Republican area, Hertel said he was warned he might face hostility.
“They told me I was going to get yelled at and spit on,” he said. “People were actually excited that a Democrat was actually showing up to have a conversation.”
Using a quote from the film The American President — “If you don’t give people water, they’ll drink sand” — Hertel argued that Trump succeeds by exploiting division and assigning blame.
“We’ve got to give people water,” said Hertel. “If we’re not the party fighting for higher wages or lowering the cost of healthcare, if we’re not the party of making childcare more affordable or making it easier for a family to own a home, there won’t be a party in America that’s fighting for those things.”
Different strategies in different states
How Democrats communicate with voters often depends on local political realities.
In Arizona, Democratic consultant Stacy Pearson said statewide campaigns typically focus on persuading independents and moderate Republicans.
She argued that Democratic branding cannot be evaluated separately from developments within the Republican Party.
“It’s not fair to look at the Democratic brand in isolation, because the Republican party has gone absolutely batshit,” she said.
Pearson added that Democrats have often struggled to articulate what they stand for, though she believes they are improving.
“Folks are frustrated with this system, and the parties are the system,” Pearson said. “What we find is that, particularly Democrats in Arizona, who are a minority, just want sanity. They are against the extremes on both sides, and they just want government to function. They want to call when the streetlight’s out and have someone pick up the phone.”
Overcoming voter skepticism
Rabb said many voters in his Philadelphia district are frustrated not only with Trump but also with long-standing Democratic leadership.
A recurring concern, he said, centers on whether candidates will remain true to their campaign promises. Some voters compare that fear to their disappointment with Pennsylvania Senator John Fetterman, whom they believe moved to the right after campaigning with more progressive rhetoric.
“They felt betrayed by someone who was cosplaying as a populist,” Rabb said. “They want to know, how do we know you’re not going to break our heart?”
The ongoing debate over the Democratic brand
Rob Flaherty, who served as deputy campaign manager for both Biden’s and Harris’s 2024 campaigns, argued in his own post-election analysis that Democratic gains in Congress could mask deeper challenges.
“Our party still speaks the language of, and to the priorities of, people who care about our institutions and believe they basically work,” he said.
According to Flaherty, many working-class voters who once formed a key part of the Democratic coalition now want a party that is actively fighting on their behalf against systems they believe have failed them.
Candidates interviewed for the story said the party’s image still matters. Kleeb argued that people want to support a successful movement. McMorrow said volunteers who dedicate significant time to campaigning want to feel they are backing a party capable of winning.
“They want a banner to fight under,” El-Sayed said.
Hong emphasized that grassroots organizing remains active despite dysfunction at the national level. She pointed to growing opposition to Trump and argued that Democrats have an opportunity to reconnect with working-class voters who feel disappointed by the president.
“It’s amazing how many people will say: ‘Dems have to start saying not just who we’re fighting against, but what we’re fighting for,’” said Hong. “And then there’s an awkward pause, and I wait for someone to say something.
“And I wish we could say we’re fighting for the worker, we’re fighting for freedoms, we’re fighting to keep our rights and protect our neighbors, and I think we have to take that message to people," Hong concluded.