EU considers 100,000-strong standing army: Defense Commissioner
The EU Defense Commissioner calls for a 100,000-strong European army and the creation of a European Security Council to strengthen defense autonomy.
-
Lithuania's Andrius Kubilius, then-nominee for European Commissioner for Defense and Space, speaks during his confirmation hearing at the European Parliament in Brussels, Belgium, on November 6, 2024 (AP)
European Union Defense Commissioner Andrius Kubilius has called for the bloc to seriously consider creating a standing military force of 100,000 troops, alongside a major overhaul of the EU’s defense governance structures.
Speaking at a security conference in Sweden on Sunday, Kubilius argued that rising Russian aggression and the United States’ shifting strategic focus, including threats over Greenland, make it imperative for Europe to rethink its common defense. He described the need for a “big bang” approach to reimagining European security.
“Would the United States be militarily stronger if they had 50 armies on the state level instead of a single federal army?” Kubilius asked.
“If our answer is 'no,' then — what are we waiting for?” he explained.
A strategic defense in European defense
Kubilius outlined three pillars for European defense readiness: increased investment in production capacity, well-prepared institutions, and the political will to deter aggression or fight if necessary. He stressed that simply boosting current defense budgets would not suffice, citing Europe’s lack of unity.
"We need to invest our money in such a way that we would be able to fight as Europe, not just as a collection of 27 national ‘bonsai armies,’” he said, referencing former EU High Representative Josep Borrell.
The commissioner proposed the creation of a permanent “European military force” of 100,000 troops, an idea previously floated by leaders including Jean-Claude Juncker, Emmanuel Macron, and Angela Merkel.
To address political decision-making, Kubilius suggested the formation of a European Security Council, which would include key permanent members, several rotational members, the EU Commission and Council presidents, and the United Kingdom.
“In total around 10-12 members, tasked not only with discussing key defense issues but swiftly preparing important decisions,” he said.
Kubilius’ proposals signal a renewed push for European strategic autonomy at a time of heightened geopolitical uncertainty, reflecting a growing desire among EU leaders to reduce reliance on external powers for regional security. However, these aspirations are met with more traditionalist and nationalist currents and nuances relating to current defense and military industry structures in Europe.
Read more: EU defense chiefs demand legal reforms to boost military readiness: FT
Europe faces multiple paradigms in a renewed arms race
Despite growing support for a standing European military, the creation of an integrated EU army faces significant political, logistical, and legal obstacles. Even with record defense spending, projected to reach 5% of GDP in countries like Germany and Poland by late 2026, structural fragmentation remains a key impediment.
Political and sovereignty obstacles remain central to the impediment of such efforts. Defense continues to be viewed as a core national prerogative, and many member states are hesitant to cede control over troop deployments or strategic decisions to a supranational authority. Moreover, divergent threat perceptions complicate coordination on defense matters. While Eastern European nations prioritize Russia’s land threat, Southern states focus on Mediterranean stability and migration. Additionally, historically neutral countries such as Austria, Malta, and Ireland face constitutional restrictions that limit participation in a mandatory collective defense framework.
Priorities, logistics, competing industries
On the logistical and industrial front, the EU defense market remains highly fragmented, with roughly 78% of procurement spending still flowing to non-European suppliers, primarily in the United States. This dependence becomes particularly problematic as European leaders push for a unified defense posture, especially in scenarios where security guarantees from Washington might falter, or US actions could compromise European sovereignty.
The collapse of strategic defense initiatives, such as the joint French-German-Spanish Future Combat Air System (FCAS), underscores the difficulty of aligning European states on common defense projects. Conflicting priorities and industrial rivalries ultimately derailed FCAS, with Germany opting to direct funds to US-supplied F-35 fighters rather than co-develop an indigenous next-generation stealth aircraft.
Additionally, differences in equipment and technical standards hinder interoperability, despite multiple initiatives under the European Defence Industrial Strategy (EDIS) to pool 40% of equipment purchases by 2030. Military mobility is also constrained by administrative and infrastructure barriers, prompting proposals for a “Military Schengen” to streamline cross-border troop movements.
Duplicating NATO
Some member states, including Poland, Denmark, and the Netherlands, worry that an EU army could duplicate or undermine NATO structures. The EU currently lacks a permanent military headquarters capable of conducting large-scale operations; the Military Planning and Conduct Capability (MPCC) remains limited to small-scale missions outside EU territory. Meanwhile, Europe faces a “personnel retention crisis,” losing trained military staff faster than they can be replaced, raising concerns that any integrated force could be “hollow” on paper.
Finally, legal and financial hurdles complicate the picture, as existing treaties, particularly Article 42 of the Treaty on European Union (TEU), focus on crisis management rather than territorial defense, meaning a true European army would require major treaty changes or an alternative framework such as a “Coalition of the Willing”.
Read more: In the 3rd nuclear age, Europe struggles to keep up