EU considers appointing 'Putin negotiator' in US-led Ukraine talks
The European Union is considering appointing a dedicated negotiator to engage Russia on Ukraine, fearing that US-led talks could sideline Europe.
-
European Union foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas addresses the media after talks with Serbia's top officials in Belgrade, Serbia, on May 22, 2025. (AP)
European Union governments are weighing the creation of a dedicated negotiator role to represent the bloc’s interests in talks with Russia over Ukraine, amid growing concern that the United States could reach a separate agreement with Moscow that sidelines Europe.
According to diplomats and officials cited by Politico, several European capitals are pressing Brussels to appoint an envoy who would act as the EU’s point person in discussions linked to ending the four-year war. Supporters of the initiative include France and Italy, which have reportedly secured backing within the European Commission and from a small group of member states.
European concerns over exclusion from talks
Proponents argue that Europe can only safeguard its core positions, including Ukraine’s potential future membership in NATO and broader European security guarantees, if the EU has a direct channel into negotiations. The move would mark a significant shift in how the bloc approaches diplomacy surrounding the conflict, which has largely been dominated by bilateral contacts between Washington and Moscow under US President Donald Trump.
European officials fear that continued US–Russia engagement, including contacts involving Trump and his envoy Steve Witkoff, could result in understandings that fail to reflect European security concerns, effectively sidelining Europe. The EU and its member states have committed nearly $200 billion to Ukraine in financial, military, humanitarian aid, and refugee support since the war began. Additionally, the war in Ukraine has seen the EU openly vilify Russian authorities, pursuing aggressive smear campaigns against Moscow and effectively severing remaining diplomatic channels with Russia.
“There are some issues which cannot be discussed with [only] the US when they have direct implications on our security as Europeans,” a senior French official said, stressing that Brussels must send a clear message both to Washington and Moscow.
France and Italy push for engagement with Moscow
French President Emmanuel Macron and Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni have, in recent weeks, called for opening diplomatic channels with Russian President Vladimir Putin and his close circle, even as US-backed peace efforts have struggled to make progress.
A senior French official said the two leaders were not “naive” about the prospects of such engagement, but argued that there is growing support in some European capitals for dialogue rather than continued isolation.
“On the balance between not engaging and engaging, there’s a growing appreciation [of the merits of engaging],” the official said.
Divisions within the bloc
The proposal remains controversial. Critics within Europe caution that appointing an EU negotiator could be interpreted as signaling that Russia is prepared to negotiate in good faith, while pointing to Russia’s territorial demands as a key issue shaping reservations about the initiative.
Trump’s mediation efforts have so far failed to bridge key gaps on security and territory, with both sides refusing to retreat from their territorial claims. Some EU officials also caution that a role designed to liaise with Russia would be fundamentally different from earlier ideas focused solely on coordinating with Kiev and isolating Moscow.
European leaders first floated the idea of a special envoy at an EU summit last March, but despite broad discussion, the proposal was ultimately excluded from the final communique.
Kallas and the question of leadership
EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas has positioned herself as the central figure for any negotiations concerning Ukraine’s future. The former Estonian prime minister has been a staunch supporter of Kiev and has pushed for tougher sanctions on Russia, framing them as a means to pressure Moscow to end what Brussels describes as its war of aggression.
Whether the bloc moves forward with appointing a negotiator, and how such a role would coexist with existing EU foreign policy structures, remains unresolved, underscoring ongoing divisions over how Europe should engage in efforts to end the conflict.
Read more: Lavrov praises US efforts, says Europe is the main obstacle to peace