Former Israeli security chief: Iran won; US and 'Israel' in a bind
Former Israeli NSC chief Giora Eiland says Iran secured a strategic victory in the war, as US-Iran talks advance toward a deal that leaves "Israel's" core demands unaddressed.
-
Retired Israeli Gen Giora Eiland speaks to occupation army officers before holding a press briefing at the Israeli regime's Ministry of War in Tel Aviv, occupied Palestine, on July 12, 2010 (AP Photo)
Giora Eiland, former head of "Israel's" National Security Council, said Saturday that the war's outcomes have become clear, admitting that Iran has won, and both Washington and Tel Aviv are finding themselves with far fewer options than when they started.
Speaking to Channel 12, the reserve major general said Tehran "can feel a great deal of satisfaction," describing Iran's victory as strategic rather than decisive, won through endurance rather than overwhelming force.
The United States, he said, is caught in "an obvious bind," and accordingly, "Israel is in an even greater one."
The Islamic Republic held firm, he said, and is now projecting strength toward Washington and its allies rather than signalling any willingness to yield.
The best Washington can hope for
On the diplomatic front, Eiland said that the best Washington can realistically hope for is a restoration of the pre-war status quo in the Strait of Hormuz, with no additional concessions to Iran, paired with a US move to lift the blockade. The nuclear file, he added, will not feature in the first stage; the immediate priority is simply stopping the fighting.
The deeper problem, Eiland argued, is that this path leads nowhere new. It returns the United States to exactly where it stood last January, where it was pushing for talks broad enough to cover nuclear capabilities, ballistic missiles, and Hezbollah, only to find Iran willing to discuss nothing beyond the nuclear dossier. That, he said, is "the best-case scenario right now."
Negotiations advancing, Israeli red lines sidelined
Israeli Channel 13 reported Saturday evening that US-Iran talks have reached an advanced stage, with both sides working toward a memorandum of understanding.
Senior Israeli officials, however, said the document, as currently formulated, leaves out matters they consider fundamental.
Chief among the occupation army's concerns is that the emerging framework includes no commitment to halt uranium enrichment, while Iran would be free to continue developing its ballistic missile programme, both of which the Israeli regime had long insisted were preconditions for any agreement.
Netanyahu pushes back, emergency meeting called
The trajectory of the talks has put Netanyahu in a difficult position. According to Axios, the prime minister is deeply troubled by the deal taking shape and has pressed Trump to carry out a fresh wave of strikes rather than lock in a diplomatic outcome.
His pushback comes as Israeli officials have noted a clear shift in mood among Trump's inner circle, with senior advisers increasingly inclined to give negotiations a chance.
Should the ceasefire be extended by 60 days, it would run directly counter to everything "Israel" has been pushing for in recent weeks, Israeli Channel 13 reported.
With the situation moving fast, Netanyahu called an emergency meeting Saturday night, gathering coalition party leaders and senior security officials.