Grynspan warns against UN retreat as Trump pushes for cuts
Rebeca Grynspan calls for a more proactive UN, deeper institutional reform, and less bureaucracy as she seeks to succeed Antonio Guterres.
-
An undated photo of Rebeca Grynspan, the leading candidate to become the next United Nations secretary-general (©The Ibero-American General Secretariat)
Rebeca Grynspan, the leading candidate to become the next United Nations secretary-general, has called for a more assertive diplomatic approach, arguing that the organization must be willing to risk failure rather than retreat from difficult negotiations.
Speaking to Reuters on Thursday, the former Costa Rican vice president said the UN had become excessively cautious and needed leadership prepared to pursue diplomatic initiatives even when they face rejection.
“The UN has become too risk-averse,” Grynspan said. “You are the one that has to take the cost of rejection, the cost of failure, and try again. That's the job of the UN.”
Her remarks came ahead of a new Security Council straw poll scheduled for Friday to assess support for candidates seeking to succeed Antonio Guterres, whose second five-year term concludes on December 31.
Grynspan calls for a shift in UN priorities
Grynspan, 70, said the UN needed to reclaim a more active role in international diplomacy after being largely sidelined in wars in Ukraine and West Asia. The organization is also facing pressure from US President Donald Trump's administration to reduce spending and streamline its operations.
She argued that financial cuts alone would not resolve the UN's problems, warning that reductions without broader institutional reform could undermine its work further.
“Cost cutting is not enough,” she told Reuters. “If you don't reform, you will do everything worse than before. That's why I talk about refocusing.”
Grynspan cited her experience leading the UN Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), where she said she eliminated 20% of positions while redirecting the agency's priorities.
Waltz calls for stronger focus on peacekeeping
US Ambassador to the UN Mike Waltz has criticized bureaucratic expansion and overlapping responsibilities across UN agencies, calling for a stronger focus on peacekeeping.
Grynspan said she agreed that some parts of the organization required consolidation and a reassessment of their mandates. If appointed secretary-general, she said, she would designate an official within her office to ensure that UN bodies fulfilled their assigned responsibilities.
“Some consolidation and rethinking of how to carry a mandate is necessary in many of the fields that have been expanding in the UN,” she stressed.
Quiet diplomacy and conflict prevention
Drawing on her involvement in negotiations surrounding the 2022 Black Sea Grain Initiative, Grynspan said discreet engagement could help resolve disputes involving countries with permanent seats on the Security Council.
The agreement facilitated the movement of Ukrainian grain through the Black Sea before Russia withdrew from it in 2023, arguing that key elements of the arrangement had not been implemented.
Grynspan described the negotiations as an example of how the UN could work behind the scenes to advance agreements without relying on public pressure.
“We didn't go to the press ... It was quiet diplomacy that worked,” she said. “This is not about being able to have total harmony in international affairs ... it's about doing good.”
She maintained that the UN already possessed the expertise, information and field presence required to make a greater contribution to resolving conflicts. What was needed, she argued, was leadership capable of coordinating those resources more effectively.
Grynspan urges diplomacy in solving conflicts
Grynspan said peacemaking should become the organization's central priority, particularly as deadly wars between entities increase. She called for greater investment in mediation and preventive diplomacy to address disputes before they escalate.
She also advocated more flexible approaches to peacekeeping, arguing that the secretary-general should work with the five permanent Security Council members to explore alternatives when conventional UN peacekeeping operations are not feasible.
Citing the multinational support mission in Haiti, she questioned why peacekeeping responses should be restricted to operations led exclusively by the United Nations.
“Why should we be so defensive? Why should it be only a UN peacekeeping force? ... Let's try to make Haiti work and learn from the experience,” she said.
Security Council vote leaves race open
Grynspan has received the highest level of support in four of the five informal Security Council straw polls conducted so far. Diplomats familiar with the process said she secured nine votes in her favor in the latest poll, held last week.
To secure a recommendation from the 15-member council, a candidate must receive at least nine positive votes and avoid opposition from any of the five permanent members: the United States, China, Russia, France, and the United Kingdom.
Friday's poll will introduce color-coded ballots for the first time, making it possible to identify whether a permanent member opposes a candidate.
Grynspan said she was the only contender to have consistently reached nine favorable votes but acknowledged that a permanent member could still oppose her candidacy. She added that candidates in previous selection processes had overcome similar obstacles.
'The game is not over'
If elected, she would become the first woman to serve as UN secretary-general.
However, diplomats have indicated that other senior figures, including current and former foreign ministers and national leaders, are considering entering the race.
Grynspan said additional candidates could emerge following Friday's vote, making clear that the selection process remained open.
“The game is not over -- we will have to continue working,” she concluded.