Hegseth slips the noose, but Democrats are waiting in January
A new House majority arrives in January, and veterans, analysts, and ex-officials say the Pentagon chief’s legal and political troubles are far from over.
-
US War Secretary Pete Hegseth listens as US President Donald Trump speaks during the swearing-in of Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin in the Oval Office of the White House, on March 24, 2026, in Washington (AP)
US War Secretary Pete Hegseth avoided a formal impeachment inquiry this week, but only barely, and the incoming Democratic House majority has made clear it intends to revisit the issue, The Guardian reported.
Kentucky Republican Thomas Massie, who is leaving Congress, brought eight articles of impeachment against the War Secretary, accusing him of “high crimes and misdemeanors.”
They covered the conduct of the war on Iran, lethal strikes on alleged drug-smuggling vessels off South America, the abduction of Venezuelan president Nicolas Maduro, and an effort to punish Democratic Senator Mark Kelly after he urged service members to refuse unlawful orders.
The House voted 211 to 204 not to send the articles to committee. Eleven Democrats were absent, some saying they were stuck in traffic, and their votes would have closed the gap.
With Democrats having won big in this month’s midterms, many expect the respite to be short. Hakeem Jeffries, the likely House speaker when the new Congress convenes in January, said in a veterans group’s video that Democrats would drive Hegseth out.
Veterans, analysts see impeachment as likely
Randy Manner, a retired National Guard major general with National Security Leaders for America, said Hegseth would not survive once the new Congress is seated and put the odds of him becoming the first war secretary ever impeached at 100%.
Joe Cirincione, an analyst and former House Armed Services Committee staffer, called Hegseth the worst war secretary in the country’s history. He expects Democrats to draft more carefully and build support before bringing a resolution forward, and thinks a smaller Republican caucus may be more willing to break ranks.
Senate is the harder hurdle
Removal requires a two-thirds vote to convict in a Senate trial. Democrats will hold at most 56 seats, with Alaska still uncalled, so that threshold looks out of reach.
Kevin Carroll, a former Army intelligence officer who worked in Donald Rumsfeld’s Pentagon office, disagrees.
He predicts several Republican senators would vote to convict, noting that many feel they were pressured by Trump at the peak of his power into confirming Hegseth. Those newly re-elected have six years before facing voters again, he said, by which time Trump will be well behind them.
What critics say
Opponents call Hegseth unqualified to run a Pentagon with a budget above a trillion dollars a year. They also accuse him of ordering boat strikes in the Caribbean and Pacific that have killed roughly 200 people, which they describe as extrajudicial killings.
Hegseth claims, without offering evidence, that the dead were "narco-terrorists". Carroll argued that attacking shipwreck survivors violates the laws of war, compared it to acts for which Nazis were hanged, and called impeachment a matter of life and death.
On Iran, critics say Hegseth contributed to civilian deaths by mocking “stupid” rules of engagement and demanding “no quarter,” language they believe invites war crimes. Manner also faulted him for cutting military lawyers and inspector general staff at Central Command, the people who investigate accidents and possible war crimes.
One case cited is the aggression on a girls’ school in Minab, in southern Iran, on the first day of the war last February. More than 165 people were killed, 120 of them children. Washington has not accepted responsibility, though independent investigations have concluded the US was behind it. Carroll called the deaths negligent homicide.
Hegseth’s response
Rattled enough by Massie’s move, Hegseth held his first Pentagon press briefing in six months. He called the effort a “political stunt” that benefited America’s adversaries.
Janessa Goldbeck, who leads the Vet Voice Foundation, said veterans broadly back impeachment. She said Hegseth is trying to frame the articles as an attack on President Trump and his Iran strategy, when they actually address conduct meeting the bar for high crimes and misdemeanors, and ask whether he used his office in ways that harm the constitutional system.