Historians blast Hegseth over D-Day ‘invasion’ comparison
Human rights advocates, historians, and political commentators criticized the US Secretary of War’s Normandy anniversary remarks.
-
US War Secretary Pete Hegseth, center, attends a ceremony at the US cemetery to commemorate the 82nd anniversary of the D-Day landings, in Colleville-sur-Mer, Normandy, France, June 6, 2026 (AP)
US War Secretary Pete Hegseth has come under fire from historians and human rights advocates after linking immigration to the anniversary of D-Day, suggesting that Europe now faces a different kind of “invasion” along its coastlines, The Guardian reported.
Speaking in northwestern France on Saturday during ceremonies marking the 82nd anniversary of the Normandy landings, Hegseth used the occasion commemorating Europe’s liberation during World War II to renew the US administration’s criticism of European immigration policies.
“Sadly, today, different European beaches are stormed by different, dangerous ideologies,” Hegseth told attendees gathered at the American military cemetery in Colleville-sur-Mer.
“Beaches in Spain, Italy, Greece and Bulgaria, boats and men arrive. When will European capitals do something about that invasion, or is it too late? I pray not, and I believe not,” he stressed.
“The men who fought and died here restored freedom to Europe,” added Hegseth. “That freedom must be maintained by this generation of leaders and war fighters, or what they fought for was merely temporary.”
Historians and commentators respond
The comments quickly sparked backlash online. English historian, author, and broadcaster Simon Schama described the speech as a “special kind of loathsomeness: a blend of historical deafness, grotesque stupidity and comically ludicrous self-importance."
Schama added, “As if the little people’s rage against immigration somehow is superior to the war against the 3rd Reich and entitles this comic book nobody to lecture the actual heroes.”
Criticism from former Atlantic Council fellow
Swedish economist Anders Åslund, a former senior fellow at Atlantic Council, contrasted Hegseth’s comments with his subsequent statements about supporting allies.
“So much nonsense,” he wrote on social media. “‘We stand by our allies!’ No you don’t. You just attacked them. Immigration policies are internal matters.”
Åslund also argued that the remarks were particularly “clueless” given Hegseth’s recent absence from a key NATO meeting and President Donald Trump’s pledges to reduce the US military presence in Europe.
“Doesn’t Hegseth know that the most unreliable ‘ally’ by far is the US?” he emphasized.
Systematic US approach
Hegseth’s emphasis on migration in Europe mirrors statements made by other US officials, including Trump, who have repeatedly criticized the effects of migration across the continent, despite the United States having a larger share of foreign-born residents than the European Union.
Hours before Hegseth’s address, US Vice President JD Vance also entered the debate through a social media post in which he blamed immigration for the death of British student Henry Nowak, 18, who was fatally stabbed in the United Kingdom.
However, Nowak’s attacker, a British-born Sikh, was convicted of murder and sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 21 years.
UK Minister pushes back
On Sunday, UK Justice Secretary and Deputy Prime Minister David Lammy said he had an “agreeable” discussion with Vance in which he sought to correct the record.
“This has got nothing to do with mass migration. This young man was a Brit,” Lammy told Sky News. “Let’s be clear about that. And I said: ‘Look, Mr Vice-president, you’re wrong about this.’”
Before Hegseth’s trip to France, the visit had already generated controversy, with a local residents’ organization calling for it to be canceled.
“This individual promotes values that go against democracy, human rights and peace,” the Langrune en Commun association, which advocates environmental protection and community solidarity, said in a statement released last week.
Activists denounce Trump administration policies
Speaking to BFMTV, association member Chantal Richard argued against treating the situation as routine.
“What’s happening with the Trump administration isn’t business as usual. The fact that Pete Hegseth is challenging all the international organisations that emerged from the Second World War isn’t business as usual,” Richard stressed.
“The words must be spoken, he must be called out for who he is, for the values he represents: colonial, warmongering, racist, far-right values,” she added. “Silence seems to us to be the worst thing we can do on these issues.”
Read more: UK PM says Musk is 'trying to whip up division' over student's murder