'It’s full of messages for Israel': Myanmar ruling may shape Gaza case
The ICJ has found Myanmar guilty of genocide against the Rohingya, a first for any state, and the ruling could shape the Gaza case against "Israel".
-
Exterior view of the International Criminal Court (ICC) in The Hague, Netherlands (AP)
By a margin of nine judges to six, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) has held Myanmar responsible for genocide, the first time any state has received such a finding. The decision brings justice to the Rohingya victims, but it also revitalizes the 1948 genocide convention as a tool for holding governments to account, a Julian Borger analysis in The Guardian contended.
The Hague-based bench used the case to lay out how the convention should be applied when a state is accused of targeting an entire population group, with particular attention to how intent is established.
Reaction from legal experts
Philippe Sands, a prominent human rights lawyer on the Gambia’s legal team, said, “I think it’s a judgment that brings the genocide convention alive. It gives the convention practical, real meaning. And if the alternative view had been taken, the convention would essentially become a dead letter.”
On her part, Agnès Callamard, Amnesty International’s secretary general, described the verdict as “a rare moment of justice for survivors, victims and their families,” while also seeing it as a defense of humanitarian law at a time of growing lawlessness.
In a similar vein, Dr Iva Vukušić, a war crimes expert and assistant professor of international history at Utrecht University, said, “This is a good day for international law. We needed it. It is really important, clarifying a lot of law, and that’s going to be very helpful going forward.”
Wider implications
The ruling is expected to influence the International Criminal Court (ICC), also based in The Hague, by offering a yardstick for when genocide charges might be brought against individuals.
"Israel", the only other entity currently facing a genocide accusation at the ICJ, is likely to have studied the lengthy judgment closely. So will Germany, which Nicaragua has taken to the court over reports that it enabled genocide in Gaza and failed to prevent it.
The Trump administration, which is instinctively hostile to international legal bodies, is also following developments warily. Before the verdict, the US ambassador to the UN urged the ICJ not to “lower the legal threshold for proving genocide,” warning that it could be “weaponized” against American and allied troops.
In fact, the court left the standard unchanged, and the Gambia, which brought the case, had not asked it to change it. Judges retained the existing test for genocidal intent, under which it must be the “only reasonable inference” from Myanmar’s conduct, and drew heavily on earlier case law. They did, however, give much fuller guidance on applying that test to atrocities committed by states.
How it compares with earlier cases
Serbia was previously the only state to face a genocide charge at the ICJ, in cases brought by Croatia and by Bosnia and Herzegovina. In the 2007 Bosnian ruling, Belgrade was found to have failed to prevent the 1995 Srebrenica genocide, but in both cases it was cleared of directly committing genocide.
This time, the court found the Myanmar military directly responsible for genocide against the Rohingya, a Muslim minority subjected to a brutal counterinsurgency campaign that peaked in 2017.
Scale of harm and the question of motive
To gauge the scale of the atrocities, judges looked beyond a death toll of roughly 10,000 and considered the entire Rohingya population targeted in northern Rakhine State, some 815,000 people. They also took account of the psychological harm suffered by survivors, especially victims of sexual violence, and of the damage to the community’s ability to reproduce.
The most significant aspect of the ruling was its interpretation of the Serbian precedents, under which genocide could be found only where no other plausible motive for mass killing existed. The court concluded that Myanmar may have had other aims, such as driving out or punishing the Rohingya, but that these could coexist with genocidal intent.
Judges held that genocidal intent was the “only reasonable inference” from the “totality” of the evidence.
Parallels with Gaza
In reaching that conclusion, the court highlighted several factors that international law specialists consider relevant to the Gaza case. That case is at the written pleadings stage and is expected to last at least three more years.
One shared element is the targeting of children, which the court said struck at the “foundation” of the Rohingya as a group. The ICJ recorded that as many as 2,109 Rohingya children under five were killed; in the war on Gaza, more than 5,000 Palestinian children under five were killed.
The court also cited “bulldozing and large-scale terrain clearance” following the destruction of villages, then “rapid construction” including security installations. That pattern has marked the Israeli army’s occupation of more than 60% of the Gaza Strip.
William Schabas, a genocide expert and professor of international law at Middlesex University, said, “It’s full of messages for Israel. There are obvious differences, of course, the evidence will be different, but if you exchanged the word Myanmar with Israel, you wouldn’t have to change much in the judgment.”