Pentagon review reignites debate over women in US ground combat
A six-month Pentagon assessment is set to reexamine combat standards, unit performance, and gender integration a decade after women were cleared for frontline roles.
-
In this Oct. 4, 2017, photo, a female US Army recruit practices building-clearing tactics with male recruits at Ft. Benning, Ga. (AP)
The Pentagon has launched a six-month review examining the presence of women in ground combat positions, focusing on what it describes as the military’s overall “effectiveness", according to a memo obtained by NPR. The assessment comes a decade after restrictions on women serving in combat roles were fully lifted.
In a memo circulated last month, Undersecretary of Defense for Personnel Anthony Tata said the review aims to assess the “operational effectiveness of ground combat units 10 years after the Department lifted all remaining restrictions on women serving in combat roles.”
Tata asked Army and Marine Corps leadership to submit data on unit readiness, training, performance, casualty rates, and command climate within ground combat formations. The request also covers individual service members’ readiness and deployability, including “physical, medical, and other measures of ability to deploy.”
The memo directs the services to provide points of contact to the Institute for Defense Analyses, a nonprofit organization that supports the government on national security matters, by Jan. 15. It also calls for the submission of internal, non-public research and studies related to “the integration of women in combat.”
Pentagon: Standards must remain ‘elite’
Pentagon Press Secretary Kingsley Wilson said in an email to NPR that the review is intended to ensure that combat standards remain uncompromised.
“The study is to ensure standards are met, and the United States maintains the most lethal military,” Wilson wrote.
“Our standards for combat arms positions will be elite uniform, and sex neutral because the weight of a rucksack or a human being doesn't care if you're a man or a woman. Under [Defense] Secretary [Pete] Hegseth, the Department of War's [sic] will not compromise standards to satisfy quotas or an ideological agenda—this is common sense," Wilson added.
Hegseth’s longstanding opposition
Hegseth, an Army National Guard veteran who served in Iraq and Afghanistan, has previously opposed women serving in ground combat units. While working as a Fox News host and author, he was explicit about his position.
“I’m straight up saying we should not have women in combat roles. It hasn't made us more effective. Hasn't made us more lethal. Has made fighting more complicated,” he said during a November 2024 podcast hosted by Shawn Ryan.
However, during his confirmation hearing last year, Hegseth softened his rhetoric, saying women could serve in combat roles if they met the same standards as men.
Return to ‘highest male standard’
Speaking to admirals and generals at Marine Corps Base Quantico, Virginia, in September, Hegseth said women would be required to meet what he described as the “highest male standard.”
“Any place where tried-and-true physical standards were altered, especially since 2015, when combat standards were changed to ensure females could qualify, must be returned to their original standard,” he said. He stopped short of announcing a ban on women in ground combat roles.
“When it comes to any job that requires physical power to perform in combat, those physical standards must be high and gender neutral,” Hegseth added. “If women can make it, excellent. If not, it is what it is. If that means no women qualify for some combat jobs, so be it. That is not the intent, but it could be the result.”
How many women serve in combat units
Women currently represent a small share of soldiers in Army ground combat roles. About 3,800 women serve in infantry, armor, and artillery units. More than 150 have completed Ranger School, widely considered one of the Army’s most demanding training programs, while roughly 10 have passed Green Beret training.
In the Marine Corps, approximately 700 women serve in comparable ground combat positions. Across all these roles, women are required to meet the same standards as men.
Critics see effort to push women out
Some analysts and former military officials argue the review is designed to justify removing women from combat roles.
Ellen Haring, a senior research fellow at Women in International Security, a West Point graduate, and a retired Army colonel with three decades of service, said the review aligns with Hegseth’s long-held views.
“It’s exactly what [Hegseth] said all along,” she said. “He’s against women in combat, and he’s going to get them out. It’s going to be an effort to prove women don’t belong.”
Past studies point to different conclusions
Others point to existing research that contradicts the premise of the review. Kris Fuhr, a West Point graduate who worked on gender integration at Army Forces Command at Fort Bragg, North Carolina, said an Army study conducted between 2018 and 2023 found women performed well in ground combat units and, in some cases, outperformed male soldiers.
She described the upcoming Pentagon review as “a solution for a problem that doesn't exist.”
In 2015, then–Secretary of Defense Ash Carter announced that women would be eligible for all ground combat positions, arguing that excluding them made little sense.
“As long as they qualify and meet the standards,” Carter said at the time, “women will now be able to contribute to our mission in ways they could not before.”
The move was controversial, particularly within the Marine Corps. Then–Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Gen. Joe Dunford did not attend the announcement and instead released a statement saying, “My responsibility is to ensure his decision is properly implemented.”
Marine Corps resistance and ongoing debate
Behind the scenes, Marine Corps leadership pushed back. A 2015 training exercise in the Mojave Desert concluded that mixed-gender units were slower, less lethal, and more prone to injury than all-male units. Marine officers also warned that integrating women could increase combat casualties.
Carter disputed those conclusions, arguing that the exercise focused on group performance rather than individual capability.
Supporters of women in combat roles have long maintained that the study failed to account for high-performing women and did not adequately measure individual achievement within combat units.
Record of opposition to diversity and inclusion policies
Hegesth has built a long record of criticizing initiatives aimed at expanding the inclusion of women, people of color, and other minorities across major sectors of society, including the US military, The Washington Post reported back in 2024.
He has argued that drafting women, among others, would pose serious national security risks, claiming such policies undermine military effectiveness. He has repeatedly asserted that these groups are allegedly incompetent and that efforts to accommodate them divert focus from national defense in favor of what he has described as a “woke” military culture.
In advancing his opposition to an integrated force, Hegseth has argued that men are “physically superior” to women, using this claim to justify his rejection of women serving in combat and other demanding military roles.
Hegseth has further claimed that diversity initiatives result in promotions based on race rather than merit, warning that inclusivity policies erode standards within the ranks.
“Strong, skilled, dedicated men come in all shapes, sizes and colors. Men don’t give a s--- what your skin color is, as long as you get the job done,” he wrote.
Read next: Trump's Pentagon chief nominee an avid Islamophobe, extremist