Pope Leo XIV takes stronger stance against Trump over war on Iran
Pope Leo XIV’s criticism of Trump over the Iran war signals a shift toward a more vocal Vatican stance, as per The Atlantic.
-
Pope Leo XIV delivers his speech during his weekly general audience in St. Peter's Square, at the Vatican, Wednesday, April 8, 2026. (AP Photo/Gregorio Borgia)
Pope Leo XIV has taken a more assertive stance against US President Donald Trump over the US-Israeli war on Iran, marking a shift from his previously reserved approach, according to an opinion piece written in The Atlantic by Vatican pundit Francis Rocca.
Once viewed as a cautious and unassuming figure compared to his predecessor, Pope Francis, Pope Leo has increasingly adopted stronger language in condemning the war, while directly criticizing Trump’s rhetoric and policies.
According to Rocca, Pope Leo initially avoided confrontation with Trump, prioritizing unity within the politically diverse Catholic Church. However, the outbreak of the Iran war marked a turning point, prompting the pope to speak more forcefully.
He condemned the war in moral terms, rejecting claims that US military actions could be justified religiously, stating that invoking God to support war was unacceptable. His remarks drew criticism from figures on the American Christian right.
Evangelical leaders, including Franklin Graham and Tony Perkins, publicly disagreed with the pope’s position, arguing that war can be justified under certain circumstances.
Pope Leo’s criticism intensified after Trump warned that Iran’s “whole civilization will die tonight,” a statement the pope described as “not acceptable.”
While welcoming a subsequent two-week ceasefire, the pope reiterated calls for peace and organized a prayer vigil at the Vatican, echoing similar actions taken by Pope Francis during past wars.
Rocca's piece also points to reported friction between the Vatican and US officials; it said a senior Pentagon official raised concerns over a papal speech criticizing the erosion of international norms and the increasing use of force in global affairs.
Although both US and Vatican representatives later downplayed the exchange, it underscored underlying tensions over foreign policy positions.
Broader criticism of US policies
The pope had already been critical of the Trump administration before the Iran war, particularly on immigration, where he condemned the treatment of migrants in the United States.
He also criticized US actions abroad, including military operations and rhetoric toward allies, emphasizing respect for sovereignty and international law.
The pope’s recent statements have gained traction among US political figures, with lawmakers such as Bernie Sanders and Cory Booker praising his calls for peace and humanitarian concern.
According to The Atlantic piece, Pope Leo may not be the central political opponent some critics of Trump had hoped for, but he has clearly moved beyond his earlier role as a restrained observer, emerging as a more vocal moral critic of the war.
Read more: Pope Leo XIV emerges as powerful critic of Trump's war on Iran