Recipe for disaster: Close calls expose US recklessness over Caribbean
Multiple close calls involving US military aircraft in Caribbean airspace have raised alarms over flight safety, secrecy, and the risk of deadly accidents involving civilian planes.
-
A US F35 fighter jet performs during the opening day of the Dubai Air Show, United Arab Emirates, Monday, Nov. 13, 2023. (AP)
As the United States acknowledges responsibility for a deadly military aviation accident at home, new incidents abroad are raising concerns over the conduct of US military operations in already tense airspace.
On Wednesday, US authorities admitted fault in a January 29 crash over the Potomac River, in which a military Black Hawk helicopter collided with a civilian passenger plane, killing all aboard. Investigators said the pilot’s failure to maintain proper vigilance was a “proximate cause” of the disaster.
That admission comes as reports emerge of multiple near-collisions involving US military aircraft and civilian planes in the Caribbean, a region witnessing heightened geopolitical and military activity. Within a 48-hour period between Dec. 12 and 13, two close calls were reported.
In one incident on Dec. 12, a JetBlue Airways flight departing Curaçao narrowly avoided a US Air Force tanker aircraft. The following day, a private jet traveling from Aruba to Miami nearly collided with another US military tanker.
According to the JetBlue pilot, the military aircraft involved in the Curacao incident was flying without its transponder activated, a practice sometimes used during reconnaissance or military missions. However, the aircraft was operating in civilian airspace over a country with which the United States is not at war.
“They passed directly in our flight path,” the pilot said, describing the encounter as “outrageous".
“We had to stop our climb.”
The incidents come amid what analysts describe as the largest US military buildup in Latin America in decades, including the deployment of F-35 fighter jets and MQ-9 Reaper drones. US forces have also been conducting ongoing maritime operations in the Caribbean, including strikes on vessels.
'Recipe for disaster'
Experts warn that the near misses reflect a growing recklessness that could result in a catastrophic accident, potentially triggering wider military or political escalation.
Alan McPherson, a professor at Temple University specializing in US–Latin America relations, told Responsible Statecraft that “these incidents are the result of an unusual and dramatic increase in military activity in the Caribbean, an airspace heavily trafficked by civilian aircraft.”
“Mix that with secrecy, and you have a recipe for disaster,” McPherson stressed.
He added that a fatal collision involving civilians or regional actors could sharply inflame tensions. “If these kill Americans or Venezuelans, they could inflame tensions on both sides and even precipitate a war.”
Others see the incidents as emblematic of deeper problems in US military conduct.
“The near mid-air collision between a JetBlue Airways pilot and a US military aircraft taking off from Curacao and heading toward Venezuelan airspace is a perfect metaphor for the lack of discipline and the recklessness in the execution of US foreign policy,” said John Mearsheimer, a non-resident fellow at the Quincy Institute, speaking on his YouTube channel.
“The military aircraft headed for Venezuelan airspace, the zone of tension, was operating so dangerously that it nearly caused a civilian air disaster,” he said, adding that the episode reflects “a lack of control in executing military operations backed by the Trump administration’s strategic ambiguity.”
Read next: Venezuela demands $35bln in reparations from US, cites oil theft