Record number of US Democrats back probe into West Bank violence
A record 46 Senate Democrats backed a resolution seeking a US report on Israeli settler violence and human rights violations in the occupied West Bank.
-
An American flag waves in front of the Supreme Court building on Capitol Hill in Washington, on Nov. 2, 2020. (AP Photo/Patrick Semansky)
A record 46 Senate Democrats backed a resolution seeking to force the US State Department to report on violence against American citizens and broader human rights violations in the occupied West Bank, but the measure was blocked in a 47-51 vote.
The resolution, introduced by Democratic Senator Chris Van Hollen and backed by independent Senator Bernie Sanders and other Democrats, would have required the State Department to report on investigations into the killings of US citizens by Israeli settlers or Israeli occupation forces, as well as the human rights situation in the West Bank, including the detention of Palestinian children.
Every Senate Democrat except Senator John Fetterman (D-Pa.) supported the measure. Republican Senator Rand Paul (R-Ky.) was the only Republican to cross party lines and vote in favor.
The vote marks a sharp change from January 2024, when a similar measure introduced by Sanders failed 72-11. The latest vote therefore reflects a substantially larger number of senators willing to scrutinize "Israel's" conduct in the occupied West Bank.
Read more: Hegseth set to cut US generals, admirals by 20%
A growing challenge to Washington's 'Israel' policy
The resolution did not seek to cut US military assistance to "Israel". Instead, it would have required the State Department to provide Congress with information on human rights violations and the deaths of American citizens.
Under Section 502B of the Foreign Assistance Act, the resolution sought information on the circumstances surrounding the deaths of nine US citizens in the West Bank since January 2022, as well as investigations into those deaths.
The nine Americans identified in the resolution include Palestinian-American journalist Shireen Abu Akleh, who was killed by the IOF while reporting in Jenin in 2022, and Aysenur Ezgi Eygi, who was killed by an Israeli soldier in 2024. It also names Americans killed by Israeli settlers, including Sayfollah Kamel Musallet, who was killed in 2025.
Sanders addressed the Senate ahead of the vote, arguing that Washington could no longer ignore violence in the occupied territory.
“While the world’s attention has been on Gaza, this same government has been carrying out a slower, but no less brutal campaign in the West Bank. As of last month, the United Nations has documented more than 1400 incidents of settler violence this year alone,” Sanders said.
“The Trump administration, rather than confronting this violence, has lifted sanctions on violent settlers. This violence does not even spare American citizens (...) Enough is enough. The United States cannot continue to bankroll this violence and look the other way,” he added.
The Trump administration has reversed sanctions imposed on certain Israeli settlers by the previous administration, a policy that has drawn criticism from Democrats and rights advocates. Senators backing the resolution said the US government should establish what action, if any, has been taken in cases involving American victims.
West Bank violence puts Democrats under pressure
The measure's unusually broad Democratic support comes amid increasing disagreements within the party over Washington's relationship with Tel Aviv and US support for "Israel".
The shift is particularly visible on issues concerning the occupied West Bank, where settlement expansion and settler attacks have increasingly become subjects of scrutiny among Democratic lawmakers.
The latest vote follows a separate push by Senators Elizabeth Warren, Chris Coons, Ron Wyden and Ruben Gallego to impose targeted sanctions on individuals, companies and entities involved in the development of Israeli settlements in the West Bank. The legislation was introduced on September 29.
The E1 project has drawn international criticism because of its impact on the territorial continuity of the occupied West Bank. Israeli authorities have advanced the project while explicitly stating it serves to end the prospects of a Palestinian State.
At the same time, violence by Israeli settlers has continued to generate international attention. On September 29, more than 100 settlers attacked the Palestinian village of Jalud, setting homes and vehicles on fire and confronting Israeli occupation personnel who were attempting to escort a displaced Palestinian family back to its home.
Read more: Netanyahu frames election as choice between right and Palestine