Al Mayadeen English

  • Ar
  • Es
  • x
Al Mayadeen English

Slogan

  • News
    • Politics
    • Economy
    • Sports
    • Arts&Culture
    • Health
    • Miscellaneous
    • Technology
    • Environment
  • Articles
    • Opinion
    • Analysis
    • Blog
    • Features
  • Videos
    • NewsFeed
    • Video Features
    • Explainers
    • TV
    • Digital Series
  • Infographs
  • In Pictures
  • • LIVE
News
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Sports
  • Arts&Culture
  • Health
  • Miscellaneous
  • Technology
  • Environment
Articles
  • Opinion
  • Analysis
  • Blog
  • Features
Videos
  • NewsFeed
  • Video Features
  • Explainers
  • TV
  • Digital Series
Infographs
In Pictures
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Asia-Pacific
  • Europe
  • Latin America
  • MENA
  • Palestine
  • US & Canada
BREAKING
TASS: Car explosion east of Moscow, ambulances rush to scene.
Al Mayadeen's correspondent: Over 10 martyrs and several wounded as Israeli forces opened fire on aid seekers on al-Tina Street, southwest of Khan Younis
A vehicle exploded in Washington, DC, the United States.
The Israeli occupation forces are carrying out extensive air raids on eastern and northeastern Gaza.
Israeli media: One Israeli soldier killed in a "security incident" in Khan Younis, south of the Gaza Strip
Israeli media: Intense exchange of fire in Khan Younis
Israeli media platform reports on a tough incident in Gaza still under media censorship
Iran's judiciary says 71 killed in Israeli strike on Evin Prison
Trump: Make the deal, get the hostages back
Al Mayadeen's correspondent: 67 Palestinians were martyred in 24 hours in the Israeli aggression on the Gaza Strip

Scotland’s first black professor accuses academics of racism

  • By Al Mayadeen Net
  • Source: Agencies
  • 22 Jan 2022 14:19
4 Min Read

Sir Geoff Palmer has been urged to resign as chair of two panels investigating Edinburgh's involvement in the slave trade.

  • x
  • Scotland’s first black professor accuses academics of racism in slavery row
    Scotland’s first black professor accuses academics of racism in slavery row.

Scotland’s first black professor has accused fellow academics of discrimination after an explosive row over Edinburgh’s links with slavery prompted calls for him to quit as chair of two groups re-examining the city’s history.

Our History/Our Slavery: Here is another example where my biased attacker Sir Tom Devine, omitted our history, apologised then said that slavery made Scotland rich. This is similar to him saying Dundas delayed abolition and was thanked by slavers, but later, don’t blame Dundas... pic.twitter.com/6kO1dNvkyl

— Sir Geoff Palmer (@SirGeoffPalmer) January 22, 2022

Sir Geoff Palmer, who is leading two separate reviews into the city and university's involvement in the slave trade, denounced Jonathan Hearn and Sir Tom Devine, current and emeritus professors at Edinburgh University, as members of an "academic racist gang" after Hearn published an article in The Spectator suggesting the city council review risked being "historically superficial" and Devine stepped in to defend him.

Palmer chastised Hearn and Divine in a series of tweets, focusing on their views on Sir Henry Dundas, a controversial figure whose monument in Edinburgh was vandalized during a Black Lives Matter protest in June 2020.

Leader of Edinburgh council hits out at 'racists' as slavery review ends https://t.co/a0hHav1419

— Sir Geoff Palmer (@SirGeoffPalmer) January 20, 2022

He and others believe Dundas, Scotland's leading Whig politician in the late 18th century, has been unfairly credited with fighting slavery in Scotland when he delayed abolition for a generation in parliament, and a revised plaque explaining this background was erected at the monument last year.

However, Hearn argued in a recent article that historians were still debating whether Dundas delayed abolition and that there was "plenty of evidence to suggest that Dundas's gradualist approach to abolition was the only approach which would be politically successful at the time."

Following Palmer's tweets, Devine demanded that he be removed from the review groups, accusing him of "appalling slurs of racism against those whose only fault was to have a different view than his own."

Jonathan Hearn and Sir Tom Devine, current and emeritus professors at @EdinburghUni: members of “an academic racist gang” #slaveryarchive #twitterstorians https://t.co/5yUcjQ9p5I

— Ana Lucia Araujo, PhD (@analuciaraujo_) January 21, 2022

"I have been making the same arguments for a long time," Palmer told The Guardian, "but I think this timing has to do with this project, the fact that this work is gaining significance but some historians are unhappy that they are not involved." 

“This is a public debate and if some people are demanding my dismissal without providing any evidence for it then that is discrimination. If they can provide evidence that I am incompetent and biased then I will step down.”

Devine is said to be seeking legal counsel, but another prominent academic figure in the city, the UK's first professor of black male studies, Tommy J Curry, said the row exemplified a naivety in Scottish culture regarding race discussions.

Hearn stated that, while he stood by his Spectator article, he harbored "no ill will" toward Palmer and would be "happy to engage in civil, face-to-face public discussions about our disagreements... My main concern in this is that inquiries into public history be conducted openly and respectfully, with regard for differing points of view."

Read more: Kyle Rittenhouse: The White-Only American Dream (Part I)

Rightwing sabotage 

As the public consultation on the city review comes to a close this week, council leader Adam McVey revealed that it had elicited thousands of "blatantly racist" responses from supporters of rightwing organizations seeking to sabotage the process, saying, "The personal targeting of Geoff that I've seen is appalling."

"I've seen groups with nothing to do with Edinburgh hurl abuse and scaremonger about a process they clearly don't understand."

He went on to say that the review group, led by Palmer, would now digest the thousands of responses to the consultation in a "considered and mature response," with the goal of "telling our city's history more honestly."

Curry, an Edinburgh University professor, said Palmer's response revealed "a naivety of Scottish culture that wants to have the debate but is not used to having arguments about race where black people themselves have the power to name racism in society."

“This isn’t a difference of opinion,” he said, “it’s about whether history should change based on fact. We’ve acknowledged that Dundas didn’t abolish slavery and did participate in the trade.”

Reassessments like this one have been happening for decades, according to Curry, "but there is also a well-established pattern of UK scholars with no knowledge of black or brown scholars' work in a global context, so everything reads like a political threat, with their only lens of understanding being the woke culture of BLM."

Read more: Kyle Rittenhouse: The White-Only American Dream (Part II)

  • Sir Geoff Palmer
  • Scotland
  • Slavery

Most Read

Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian attends a protest following the US attacks on nuclear sites in Iran, in Tehran, Iran, Sunday, June 22, 2025. (AP)

Iran declares victory as ceasefire forces Israeli retreat

  • Politics
  • 24 Jun 2025
Iran launches strikes on Israeli targets, despite alleged ceasefire

Iran victorious as ceasefire with 'Israel' takes effect

  • Politics
  • 24 Jun 2025
The site of a direct missile strike launched from Iran in Tel Aviv on Sunday, June 22, 2025. (AP)

Op. True Promise 3, wave 21: Multi-warhead missiles rain on 'Israel'

  • Politics
  • 23 Jun 2025
Iran says targeted US Qatar air base under Op. Annunciation of Victory

Iran says targeted US Qatar air base under Op. Annunciation of Victory

  • MENA
  • 23 Jun 2025

Coverage

All
The Ummah's Martyrs

Read Next

All
Women comfort each other by a vehicle that was burnt overnight by Israeli settlers in an attack that killed three Palestinians and burnt several vehicles and damaged homes, in Kafr Malik, east of Ramallah, Thursday, June 26, 2025 (AP)
Politics

Settlers shoot and assault Palestinians in Hizma, Masafer Yatta

Syria's interim leader, Ahmad al-Sharaa, walks in the presidential palace ahead of a meeting in Damascus, Dec. 28, 2024. (AP)
Politics

Syria open to Sharaa-Netanyahu meeting at UN assembly: Israeli media

Former Iranian parliament speaker Ali Larijani speaks with media at the Interior Ministry in Tehran, Iran, Friday, May 31, 2024 (AP)
Politics

'Israel' failed to topple Iran, lost 12-day war, Larijani says

Smoke rises to the sky following an Israeli strike in the Gaza Strip as seen from southern Israel, Wednesday, June 11, 2025. (AP)
Politics

War on Gaza failed to achieve objectives in Gaza: Israeli media

Al Mayadeen English

Al Mayadeen is an Arab Independent Media Satellite Channel.

All Rights Reserved

  • x
  • Privacy Policy
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Authors
Android
iOS