Staff accuses CPJ of dropping 'impunity index' to shield 'Israel'
Former and current staff say CPJ replaced its widely cited ranking with a brief statement after disputes over methodology and accountability for journalist killings.
-
Mourners carry the body of Abd Shaat, one of the three Palestinian journalists who were killed in an Israeli strike on an Egyptian committee's vehicle, during his funeral in Khan Younis, southern Gaza Strip, Jan. 22, 2026. (AP)
Whistleblowers reveal that the Committee to Protect Journalists discontinued its long-running “Impunity Index” after internal calculations indicated that "Israel" would rank at the top of the list, The Electronic Intifada reported.
The revelations surfaced shortly after Omar Shakir resigned from a senior position at Human Rights Watch, citing the organization’s handling of a report that characterized "Israel’s" denial of Palestinian refugees’ right of return as a “crime against humanity.”
“I have lost my faith in the integrity of how we do our work and our commitment to principled reporting on the facts and application of the law,” Shakir wrote in his resignation letter after serving a decade as HRW’s director in occupied Palestine.
Now, current and former CPJ staff members, writing collectively to The Electronic Intifada, say a comparable episode has unfolded within their organization.
They stress that CPJ chief executive Jodie Ginsberg “did the exact same thing last August, albeit in a smarter, more concealed way to manage the anger of staff.”
The impunity index and its methodology
According to the whistleblowers, Ginsberg “decided to cancel [CPJ’s] Impunity Index simply because the math showed Israel is number one.”
First published in 2008, the annual index was designed to identify countries where the killers of journalists evade accountability. It calculates the number of unsolved journalist murders as a percentage of each country’s population over a rolling 10-year period.
“It’s a very concrete measure of accountability,” the whistleblowers said. “The data in it is deeply trusted and cited by the UN Human Rights Office and UNESCO.”
The ranking has frequently been referenced in United Nations reporting.
'Israel’s' position in recent rankings
The most recent Impunity Index, released in 2024 and covering events through 2023, placed "Israel" second behind Haiti, ranking it among the areas where journalists face the highest risk of being killed without consequence.
Because the index spans a decade, whistleblowers argue that "Israel" would likely have remained near the top, or moved into first place, for years to come.
“Since the Impunity Index usually covers a timeframe of 10 years, Israel would have been ranked near the top, if not number one, for many years to come,” they wrote.
They further stress that Ginsberg “simply couldn’t afford the heat she would get every year from the board, the pro-Israel donors and from Israel itself and its allies.”
Had a 2025 edition been released, covering 2024, described by critics as the first full year of "Israel’s" genocide in Gaza, whistleblowers assure that "Israel" would have ranked first.
According to CPJ’s own database, "Israel" deliberately killed 64 journalists in 2023, 76 in 2024, another 51 in 2025, and three so far in 2026.
The Gaza Government Media Office has reported that 260 media workers have been killed since the start of the war, a toll it says surpasses journalist deaths in multiple past wars combined.
Funding and governance questions
The Electronic Intifada reported that CPJ receives funding from outlets owned by Rupert Murdoch, known for his right-leaning and pro-"Israel" editorial positions.
CPJ’s board includes several figures linked to major mainstream media institutions, including at least five individuals associated with The New York Times.
Another donor identified in the report is Ariel Investments, a Chicago-based firm that holds investments in Check Point Technologies, an Israeli cybersecurity company led by Nadav Zafrir, founder of "Israel’s" military “Cyber Command” and a former commander of Unit 8200.
In response to inquiries from The Electronic Intifada, CPJ denied that donor considerations influenced its decisions regarding Israel or any other country.
Internal justification for dropping the index
In an August email to staff, reviewed by The Electronic Intifada, Ginsberg wrote that “we are proposing dropping this year’s Impunity Index.”
She argued that “it has become abundantly clear over recent years that the index has many flaws that mean it does not accurately reflect the level of failure in achieving justice in the killings of journalists.”
The email did not specify the alleged methodological flaws, but Ginsberg suggested that the index “did not take into account accountability for journalists killed but where CPJ has been unable to determine with certainty that they were murdered (killings of journalists by Israel was cited as an example).”
The Impunity Index includes only cases where CPJ concludes a journalist was intentionally killed, excluding deaths in dangerous combat circumstances. Critics note that this already omits many Palestinian journalists killed during the war.
Rather than revising or expanding the methodology, Ginsberg opted to discontinue the index.
She proposed replacing it with “a lighter lift statement/short analysis that highlights lack of accountability and justice generally, potentially using five key cases (e.g., Gerry Ortega, Shireen Abu Akleh, etc.).”
“This would allow us to focus on the countries with high numbers of killed journalists (Israel, Mexico) without having the intense focus involved in getting rights of reply on dozens of journalists,” she added.
Staff reaction and organizational response
In a statement to The Electronic Intifada, CPJ said its decision “was not motivated by concerns that Israel would rank at the top but a recognition that we need to radically change how to do this work to hold the worst perpetrators of crimes against journalists to account.”
The organization added, “To that end, the organization made the decision to prioritize efforts to pursue accountability and this work is ongoing.”
However, CPJ did not detail how eliminating a widely cited and transparent ranking would strengthen accountability efforts.
The statement released in December in place of the Impunity Index highlighted “five emblematic cases to underscore how elusive the path to justice is for journalists.” Among them were Shireen Abu Akleh, killed in 2022, and Filipino journalist Gerry Ortega, alongside cases from Slovakia, Cameroon, and Mexico.
Critics argue that this approach assigns equal weight to disparate contexts, unlike the ranking system that would have reflected comparative scale.
The Impunity Index, whistleblowers noted, “produces a huge amount of media coverage.” They added, “This flimsy statement produced none.”
They described widespread “deep disappointment, anger and resentment” among staff following the decision.