UK reviews how US troops accused of crimes avoid British courts
The UK government and police are reviewing how US service members accused of serious crimes on British soil were transferred to the American military justice system instead of facing prosecution in UK courts.
-
The entrance to RAF Lakenheath, a US Air Force installation in Suffolk, England (AFP)
The British government and senior police officials have launched reviews into how American military personnel accused of serious offenses in the United Kingdom have been transferred out of the British legal system and prosecuted by US military authorities instead, The Guardian reported.
The examinations follow revelations that local police repeatedly relinquished control of investigations involving US service members, including cases concerning rape, sexual assault, and violence against British women.
Although British police ordinarily have priority over crimes committed off duty against civilians on UK territory, several forces allowed US military investigators and prosecutors to assume responsibility for the cases.
This meant that the accused faced court-martial proceedings under the US Uniform Code of Military Justice rather than prosecution before a British criminal court.
Critics argue that the military system offers victims fewer protections and applies a narrower legal definition of rape than the one used in England and Wales, potentially resulting in suspects being prosecuted for less serious offenses.
Fighter pilot tried at US base
Government concern intensified following the case of US Air Force Capt Jacob Wulfson, who was accused of raping and strangling British woman Sarah Steele after meeting her through a dating application.
Cambridgeshire police handed the investigation to US military authorities, and Wulfson was subsequently tried before an all-male panel of Air Force officers at a US base in Suffolk.
He was cleared of sexual assault but convicted of strangling an intimate partner. He received a six-month prison sentence, which he is serving at RAF Lakenheath.
Following reporting on the case, Downing Street described the circumstances as “very concerning”.
Seeking explanation from US
Home Office and Justice Ministry officials have since met Steele to discuss her experience and consider whether the procedures used by police and prosecutors require reform.
A government spokesperson said Steele had “shown incredible bravery in coming forward” and that ministers had “committed to identifying and learning any lessons from this case to ensure that victims are supported and treated with the seriousness, dignity and compassion they deserve."
The spokesperson added that officials were coordinating with the National Police Chiefs’ Council to examine existing guidance and “to look at the guidance in place to ensure that cases are correctly referred to the Crown Prosecution Service for advice."
The Foreign Office has also sought explanations from Washington, saying it had “been engaging with the US on this matter."
Other cases raise jurisdiction concerns
The Wulfson prosecution was not an isolated incident.
A number of other US Air Force personnel accused of committing offenses while off duty in Britain were prosecuted through the American military system after British police transferred their investigations.
Hannes Marschalek was accused of exposing himself to a 16-year-old girl and four young women in Cambridgeshire. He admitted indecent conduct through a court-martial plea agreement, although the conviction was later overturned because of a technical issue.
Tyrion Davis was accused of raping two British women in Suffolk. A military court convicted him on one sexual assault charge but acquitted him on 10 additional counts involving sexual assault and abusive sexual contact.
Drug and rape, still court-martialed
Another airman, James Loubeau, faced accusations from several women who alleged that he carried out a series of rapes and sexual attacks in East Anglia, including drugging women and entering their homes.
Loubeau was tried by court-martial in relation to allegations made by only one of six women and was acquitted.
He was later convicted in Miami over allegations involving another woman after the FBI investigated his suspected attacks in England.
Suffolk police had transferred the Loubeau investigation to US military prosecutors only 11 days after two British women reported that he and another airman had drugged and raped them following an encounter at a nightclub.
The cases have prompted questions over whether British police sought sufficient legal advice before surrendering jurisdiction and whether US officials pressed local forces to hand over investigations.
Police forces examine past decisions
National Police Chiefs’ Council Chair Gavin Stephens has written to chief constables across England and Wales, reminding them of their legal responsibilities when investigating personnel belonging to visiting US forces.
Ministers were reportedly alarmed by indications that police may have handed cases to the US military without first consulting the Crown Prosecution Service.
Legislation introduced in the 1950s allows the US military to prosecute its personnel in Britain when an alleged offense is connected to official duties or is committed against another service member, military property, or a military dependent.
For other alleged crimes, particularly those involving British civilians and off-duty personnel, UK authorities normally have the first right to investigate and prosecute.
US takes control despite absence of jurisdiction
The cases under review, however, suggest that US officials were allowed to take control even where Washington did not hold primary jurisdiction.
Cambridgeshire and Suffolk police have now opened internal examinations into their handling of such investigations.
Cambridgeshire police said, “We are conducting a policy review being led by our investigation standards department.”
The review will consider cases dating back to 2018, although the force has not yet determined how many investigations may be involved.
Suffolk police said, “We are in the process of reviewing the decision-making surrounding the transfer of primacy to the US air force and around case transfer practices more generally.”
MPs demand accountability under British law
More than 12,000 American military personnel are stationed across at least 15 bases and installations in the UK.
RAF Lakenheath and RAF Mildenhall in Suffolk host the largest concentrations, with many US personnel also living in surrounding communities in Suffolk, Norfolk, and Cambridgeshire.
Lawmakers from several political parties have argued that foreign military status should not shield suspects from British law.
Conservative justice spokesperson Nick Timothy said Wulfson “should have been fully investigated by the English police and prosecuted in our courts."
Liberal Democrat justice spokesperson Jess Brown-Fuller said, “The British public expect crimes committed in England to be prosecuted in the English courts under English law. That expectation should not change simply because the accused is a member of the foreign military.”
Justice Minister Sarah Sackman also addressed the matter in Parliament earlier this month.
“Our thoughts are with the victim, and with the other victims whose experiences have subsequently come to light,” she said.
Read more: Japan warns sex crimes committed by US forces ‘cannot be tolerated'