UN warns of security law abuse as Palestine Action ban faces top court
Rights experts say “terrorism” rhetoric is used to silence activists, but the Home Office claims the ban does not affect "lawful protest" in support of Palestinians.
-
Demonstrators hold up a banner during a protest by the Palestine Action group in London on June 23, 2025 (AP)
The UN human rights committee has cautioned governments against using counter-terrorism and national security laws to suppress groups, just as the UK Supreme Court weighs whether the ban on Palestine Action was lawful.
Published on Thursday, the committee’s first full guidance on freedom of association is sharply critical of loosely drafted laws aimed at “extremism” or “undesirable” organizations. It never names Palestine Action. However, the committee’s vice-chair, Hélène Tigroudja, said the UK and "Israel" were among the sides whose actions prompted the guidance.
Tigroudja acknowledged that national security and counter-terrorism are recognized grounds for limiting freedom of association.
'Heightened caution' urged
She argued, though, that authorities abuse them in practice: “These legitimate purposes are too often so vaguely defined by domestic legislation, and more importantly, so extensively misused by authorities to silence by way of criminalising associations such as climate activists, children and young-led movements, human rights defenders, journalists, trade unionists, that these aims must be used with a heightened caution."
“In this regard, what is observable at a global level, is the abuse of the ‘terrorism’ rhetoric to target associations and/or their members and to expose them not only to public opinion’s criticism but also to sanctions, including criminal punishment such as heavy fines or arrest and detention for the individuals,” Tigroudja stressed.
The guidance also says, “The right to defend human rights, the reporting of human rights violations, or the advocacy for accountability, for instance, cannot as such be labelled as a threat or breach of public order.”
The Palestine Action case
Palestine Action was proscribed last year, making it the first direct action group banned under the Terrorism Act and putting it on the same legal footing as organizations such as al-Qaeda and Boko Haram. Civil liberties groups, politicians from across the spectrum, a former director of public prosecutions, and a former head of the security services have all criticized the decision.
The Supreme Court heard a challenge earlier this month arguing that the ban disproportionately interferes with rights to free speech and protest. A ruling is still pending.
The group’s lawyer told the court its purpose was “disruption of the supply of weapons from the United Kingdom to Israel at a time when the International Court of Justice (“ICJ”) had found ‘a real and imminent risk [of] irreparable prejudice’ to the rights of Palestinians in Gaza not to be subjected to acts of genocide."
Co-founder says report 'goes to the heart' of the case
Huda Ammori, a Palestine Action co-founder who brought the challenge, said the committee’s report was directly relevant, “This goes to the heart of the Palestine Action case. The government cannot simply label a movement ‘terrorist’ and use that designation to suppress political dissent by extinguishing the fundamental rights of its members and supporters."
“I urge the Supreme Court to heed this clear warning and overturn this unjust, dangerous and disproportionate ban. If the courts fail to uphold these fundamental freedoms, we will take our case to the European court of human rights. The criminalisation of direct action protest has no place in a democracy, and we will not stop fighting until this Orwellian proscription is overturned,” Ammori added.
A Home Office spokesperson defended the ban, “As the court of appeal found, Palestine Action is not a civil disobedience protest group but one that carried out acts of terrorism, celebrated those who took part in them and promoted the use of violence. Its proscription followed a rigorous and evidence-based decision-making process, endorsed by parliament."
“Free speech is a fundamental democratic right; the proscription of Palestine Action does not affect lawful protest in support of the Palestinian cause," the spokesperson claimed.