Washington deal risks impunity for Israeli war crimes in Lebanon
The agreement includes provisions that legal experts say could restrict victims’ access to international courts and limit accountability efforts in Lebanon.
-
Children hold signs during a vigil for people killed in Lebanon during the Israeli aggression on Lebanon, April 10, 2026, in Dearborn, Mich. (AP)
Legal experts have warned that Friday's trilateral framework, signed in Washington under US sponsorship, could prevent victims of Israeli war crimes in Lebanon from pursuing legal accountability and complicate future efforts to extend the International Criminal Court's jurisdiction to the country, The Guardian reported.
The Lebanese state and "Israel" signed a 14-point framework agreement in Washington on Friday, allegedly aimed at "advancing efforts" to end the Israeli aggression on Lebanon.
Under Article 13 of the agreement, both sides pledge to “cease all hostile or negative actions in international political or legal forums” as a means of fostering good faith between the two sides.
Legal analysts told The Guardian that the broadly worded provision could restrict victims of Israeli war crimes committed during the war that began on Oct. 8, 2023, from seeking justice through either international or domestic courts.
ICC jurisdiction fears
Experts have also interpreted the provision as preventing Lebanon from granting the International Criminal Court jurisdiction over crimes committed on its territory, a move advocates have long promoted to enable prosecutions of "Israel" and its figures over reported war crimes.
“This will kill any hope of granting the ICC jurisdiction, even any hope of a UN fact-finding mission,” said Farouk al-Moghrabi, a former advisor to the Ministry of Human Rights who helped draft legislation that would have granted the ICC jurisdiction in Lebanon. He told The Guardian that the agreement would also undermine domestic efforts to investigate and document Israeli crimes.
Nizar Saghieh, a lawyer and head of Legal Agenda, a Lebanese NGO, said, “The government is normalising the crime and waiving its rights to ensure any investigation or the prosecution of these crimes, or even to assist the victim in their search for justice.”
A spokesperson for the Lebanese presidency did not respond to a request for comment, as per the report.
Hezbollah rejects Washington agreement
Hezbollah Secretary-General Sheikh Naim Qassem slammed on Saturday the recent Israeli-Lebanese agreement as a submission to US-Israeli dictates and an erosion of sovereignty, while vowing continued resistance until liberation.
"The Framework Agreement in Washington is one of humiliation, disgrace, and surrender of sovereignty. This agreement is null and void," Sheikh Qassim said in firm rejection, adding that the Iran-US MoU must be implemented.
The Lebanese resistance has consistently urged the Lebanese government to avoid direct talks with "Israel".
"Israel" has killed more than 8,000 people in Lebanon, mostly women and children, since October 2023. Since March 2, the Israeli occupation has killed 4,247 people and injured 12,195 others across Lebanon, as its brutal aggression continues to exact a devastating human toll.
War crimes and accountability efforts
During its aggression on Lebanon, "Israel" has killed more than a dozen journalists, over 300 emergency responders, and hundreds of women and children.
Seven journalists and media workers martyred during the Israeli aggression on Lebanon were from the Al Mayadeen family. They were Farah Omar and Rabih Me’mari, killed in Tayr Harfa in November 2023; Ghassan Najjar and Mohammad Reda, killed in Hasbaya in October 2024; Fatima Ftouni and cameraman Mohammad Ftouni, whose vehicle was targeted and burned; and Hadi al-Sayyed, martyred in Burj Rahhal.
Human rights experts have said "Israel" may have committed multiple war crimes in Lebanon, including the targeting of journalists on Oct. 13, 2023, the mass forced displacement of hundreds of thousands of people, and attacks that deliberately targeted civilians.
One route available to victims seeking accountability has been urging the Lebanese government to grant the ICC limited jurisdiction to investigate and prosecute crimes committed within Lebanese territory.
The ICC has issued arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Security Minister Yoav Gallant over war crimes and crimes against humanity committed in Gaza. In response, "Israel" and the United States have mounted an aggressive campaign against the court, including US sanctions targeting ICC judges.
Rights commission raises concerns
The Lebanese government has so far declined to grant the ICC jurisdiction, citing concerns over potential US sanctions. Legal experts say Friday's framework agreement introduces another significant barrier to accountability.
Lebanon’s National Human Rights Commission issued a statement on the framework agreement, stressing that no agreement should prevent victims from pursuing justice.
“The commission emphasises that prosecuting perpetrators of war crimes, crimes against humanity and torture does not constitute an act of hostility or a political stance, but rather a legitimate exercise of the rights to justice,” the statement stressed.
The commission also said the broad and ambiguous language of the agreement leaves uncertainty over what actions could be interpreted as “hostile or negative.”
Meanwhile, the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights recently arrived in Lebanon to conduct a fact-finding mission into possible war crimes committed during the latest war. It remains unclear whether those activities could be affected by the new agreement.
“The fact that this is happening after all of these crimes, this is normalisation of the crimes and ensuring some kind of impunity to Israel,” Saghieh stressed.