Why MAGA won’t defend Second Amendment in Minnesota shooting
The killing of lawful gun owner Alex Pretti raises questions about MAGA’s shifting stance on the Second Amendment and police use of force when protestors are involved.
-
Federal agents try to clear demonstrators near a hotel, using tear gas during a noise demonstration protest in response to federal immigration enforcement operations in the city, Sunday, January 25, 2026, in Minneapolis. (AP)
The death of Alex Pretti, a 37-year-old ICU nurse and lawful gun owner, has triggered debate over the Second Amendment, police use of force, and political inconsistency in the United States, according to the Newsweek editorial team.
Pretti, a licensed concealed-carry holder, was shot and killed by federal agents in Minneapolis. Despite longstanding MAGA support for gun rights, many of its leading figures have remained silent or even justified the shooting.
Shortly after the incident, both the National Rifle Association and Gun Owners of America called for a full investigation. This came as officials from the Trump administration publicly defended the agents involved. A Trump-appointed US attorney claimed officers are "legally justified" in shooting anyone who "approach[es] law enforcement with a gun." An NRA spokesperson pushed back, calling the statement "dangerous and wrong."
Minnesota Police Chief Brian O’Hara confirmed that Pretti was “a lawful gun owner with a permit to carry.” In Minnesota, carrying a permitted pistol in public is legal, and even failing to display a permit on demand results in a petty misdemeanor punishable by a fine of no more than $25.
Despite this, officials framed Pretti’s actions as threatening. Video footage reportedly shows agents removing a handgun from his waistband moments before firing, challenging claims that he was armed when shot.
Read more: US Supreme Court rejects appeals on assault rifle restrictions
Right-wing reactions show double standard on gun rights
Some of the MAGA movement’s most vocal figures deflected attention from Pretti’s rights. Kash Patel, the FBI director, told Fox, “You cannot bring a firearm, loaded, with multiple magazines, to any sort of protest or rally in any state. You don’t have that right.” Gregory Bovino, a senior Border Patrol official, asked, “Why would you bring a semi-automatic weapon to a riot?”
US President Donald Trump also defended the agents, attacking “corrupt Minnesota politicians” and shifting focus to unrelated state issues. Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem labeled the event “an act of domestic terrorism.”
The MAGA movement has consistently positioned itself as a defender of the Second Amendment, at least when the gun owner aligns with its views. In 2022, days after the Uvalde school shooting, Trump told NRA attendees, “The only way to stop a bad guy with a gun is a good guy with a gun.”
That stance didn’t hold in the Minnesota shooting. Trump previously defended figures like Kyle Rittenhouse, the McCloskeys in St. Louis, and even January 6 participants who carried weapons or attacked police officers. Some of those cases involved loaded firearms, yet drew MAGA praise or even pardons.
Public opinion and political polarization on Second Amendment
The contradiction reveals deep divisions in public opinion. In a 2023 Pew Research poll, 79% of Republicans and Republican-leaning independents said gun ownership increases safety. At the same time, GOP voters overwhelmingly supported federal troop deployment during left-leaning protests, according to a 2025 Washington Post/Schar School poll.
Surveys by Johns Hopkins show that most gun owners, even in recent years, oppose strict limits on carrying at demonstrations. Only 39% supported banning open carry at protests in 2021, a figure that has remained relatively unchanged.
Critics argue that the MAGA movement applies the Second Amendment selectively—defending it when politically convenient and dismissing it when not. “Carrying a firearm is not a death sentence, it’s a constitutionally protected God-given right,” wrote Republican Representative Thomas Massie.
Minnesota Governor Tim Walz reminded the public, “You know what you saw,” while Attorney General Keith Ellison emphasized the legality of Pretti’s actions under state law.
While a full investigation into the Minnesota shooting is still required, the incident exposes a broader issue: for some, gun rights appear conditional on political affiliation. When the “right” person is armed, it's self-defense. When the “wrong” person is armed, it becomes justification for deadly force. That shift signals a troubling divergence between stated principles and practiced politics in America's ongoing debate over the Second Amendment.