Al Mayadeen English

  • Ar
  • Es
  • x
Al Mayadeen English

Slogan

  • News
    • Politics
    • Economy
    • Sports
    • Arts&Culture
    • Health
    • Miscellaneous
    • Technology
    • Environment
  • Articles
    • Opinion
    • Analysis
    • Blog
    • Features
  • Videos
    • NewsFeed
    • Video Features
    • Explainers
    • TV
    • Digital Series
  • Infographs
  • In Pictures
  • • LIVE
News
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Sports
  • Arts&Culture
  • Health
  • Miscellaneous
  • Technology
  • Environment
Articles
  • Opinion
  • Analysis
  • Blog
  • Features
Videos
  • NewsFeed
  • Video Features
  • Explainers
  • TV
  • Digital Series
Infographs
In Pictures
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Asia-Pacific
  • Europe
  • Latin America
  • MENA
  • Palestine
  • US & Canada
BREAKING
Putin approvesexperts for talks with Ukraine: Kremlin
Russian Deputy FM Galuzin, Head of General Staff Kostyukov, Deputy Defense Minister Fomin will participate in Istanbul talks: Kremlin
Russian presidential aide Medinsky will lead Russia delegatioon at Ukraine talks: Kremlin
Putin approves composition of Russian delegation for negotiations with Ukraine: Kremlin
Abu Obeida posts on X, commenting on the West Bank operation amid Israeli rumors that he was assassinated
Israeli media: An Israeli settler was killed and two others were injured in the shooting near Salfit
Israeli emergency service: The shooting near Salfit resulted in two injuries, one in extremely critical condition and the other in serious condition
Palestinian sources: Two Israelis were injured in a shooting operation near Nablus in the northern West Bank
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky: I am waiting to see who will arrive from Russia. Then I will decide what steps Ukraine should take
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky: Ukraine ready for any format of negotiations to end war with Russia

Declassified files expose UK cluster munition hypocrisy

  • Kit Klarenberg Kit Klarenberg
  • Source: Al Mayadeen English
  • 9 Aug 2023 15:45
  • 1 Shares
7 Min Read

The UK armed forces can do almost anything they like with cluster bombs - while evading legal consequences - as long as it’s someone or something else ultimately deploying them.

  • x
  • Declassified files expose UK cluster munition hypocrisy
    Declassified files expose UK cluster munition hypocrisy

Joe Biden’s decision to transfer cluster bombs to Kiev has sparked widespread public controversy, and strained previously indomitable NATO unity on responding to Russia’s invasion, with member state leaders lining up to criticize the move. UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak has been the most vocally condemnatory, discouraging both transfer and use of the widely-proscribed munition, and firmly declaring London will not follow Washington’s lead in supplying Ukraine.

The intensely public rift prompted Biden to make a brief layover in London on July 10th, ahead of NATO’s annual summit in Vilnius, to meet with Sunak personally. Following a 40-minute discussion in Downing Street, during which the pair reportedly affirmed the “rock solid” bond between their nations, the premier’s official spokesperson claimed he had robustly reiterated London would “stand by our obligations” under the 2008 Convention on Cluster Munitions (CMC), to his US counterpart.

The Guardian hailed Sunak’s position in a forceful editorial that same day. Arguing Russia’s use of cluster bombs “is not a reason to further drag down international norms”, it went on to boldly assert the US “should never have deployed them”, “should not have rejected the convention banning them”, and “should not be supplying them to Ukraine”. The outlet proudly noted that over 120 states have joined the CMC, of which the UK was a leading advocate, signatory, and ratifier.

Yet, entirely absent from the media and political fracas that has erupted over the past week was any acknowledgment the UK served as key driving force behind specific clauses in the Convention, allowing signatory countries to provide training in the use of cluster munitions to allied militaries that are not parties to the CMC, and logistically support their use. From London’s perspective, this would, of course, include Washington, and Kiev.

That omission may in part be attributable to the military directive covering UK armed forces assistance on cluster munition use being concertedly concealed by the Ministry of Defence. It was only disclosed in 2021, over a decade after the Convention came into force in London, and even then mistakenly, in response to Freedom of Information requests from an independent researcher. A lengthy ensuing battle to keep the information public domain was only successful due to the Information Commissioner’s Office intervention.

UnHerd can reveal the contents for the very first time. The directive starts by noting the Cluster Munitions (Prohibitions) Act 2010 “implements the Convention’s obligations in UK law,” and prohibits cluster bomb use “from taking place at all within the UK, and by all UK nationals anywhere.” 

However, it goes on to state that Article 21 of the CMC - which is reflected in the Act - “enables continued international military operations and international military cooperation between signatory and non-signatory States, which might engage in activities prohibited in the Convention.” The Act moreover provides “legal defences for UK personnel operating with [cluster munitions] alongside allies from non-signatory states,” such as the US.

These “interoperability provisions” do not authorise the UK to “develop, produce or otherwise acquire” cluster bombs, and UK military personnel may not be “part of a crew (within a cockpit) or individual weapons platform that dispenses” these munitions. However, they “ensure that NATO and other coalition operations can proceed without UK personnel being liable to prosecution for undertaking normal operational duties” if cluster munitions are used by non-signatories.

Related News

Cluster bombs and depleted uranium: A desperate and futile last breath

“Normal operational duties” described in the directive are extraordinarily broad. While the UK armed forces “must not be in a position where they expressly request, or direct” the use of cluster munitions “to achieve a task,” soldiers “engaged in international military operations or international military co-operation” are able to “call for fire support” from an allied military, even if they know that will come in the form of cluster munitions.

They can furthermore refuel and service allied “aircraft, vessels and vehicles,” and “perform logistical planning, handling, storage, maintenance and transport services” for associated materiel, which “may” include cluster bombs. They can also train allied soldiers in their use.

In other words, the UK armed forces can do almost anything they like with cluster bombs - while evading legal consequences - as long as it’s someone or something else ultimately deploying them. The secret directive provides a very clear framework for London assisting Saudi Arabia’s use of UK-made cluster munitions, during its grinding, almost decade-long air war against Yemen.

During that conflict, every day UK-supplied aircraft flown by UK-trained pilots pounded Yemen with UK-made bombs and missiles, which were then repaired and serviced in Riyadh by UK contractors, including Royal Air Force engineers. Frequently, the targets were civilians and civilian infrastructure, including refugee camps, funerals, hospitals, schools, and weddings. The Saudi-led coalition also purposefully targeted crops, farmland, and fishing vessels, in order to starve the population.

When Riyadh’s deployment of UK-made cluster munitions was publicly exposed in mid-2016, Amnesty International warned that if any of London’s “several hundred specialist support staff working closely with the Royal Saudi Air Force” were implicated in their use, this “would constitute a clear breach of the UK’s legal responsibility” under the CMC. Except, it absolutely wouldn’t, according to then-secret Ministry of Defence doctrine.

There is another covert corollary to London’s ratification of the CMC. US diplomatic cables released by WikiLeaks show that in May 2009, then-Foreign Secretary David Miliband approved a loophole that would allow cluster munitions to be stored on British territory, contrary to the Convention’s obligations. Officials in Whitehall moreover maneuvered to ensure the ruse was concealed from parliament, in case it “complicated or muddied” debate around the CMC.

This loophole allows Washington to store cluster weapons as “temporary exceptions,” and on a “case-by-case” basis for specific military operations. A cited case was cluster munitions sited on ships off the coast of Diego Garcia, a British Indian Ocean territory, which has been occupied by the US military since its indigenous inhabitants were forcibly expelled in the 1960s.

It could well be that US cluster munitions based on British territory will soon make their way to the frontline in Ukraine, for a “specific military operation.” Upon arrival, it’s conceivable the profusion of UK special forces there will rely on “fire support” from jets bearing cluster loads. They may also teach their counterparts in Kiev how to use this weaponry, which could extend to targeting assistance, as London provided to Riyadh during the Yemen conflict.

As such, Rishi Sunak’s lofty critical pronouncements over Washington’s transfer of cluster munitions to Ukraine, and his country’s steadfast commitment to adhering to its CMC obligations, ring entirely hollow, and give every appearance of posturing for the purposes of political capital. According to Ministry of Defence doctrine, and UK law, London can facilitate, enable, and effectively encourage Kiev’s use of cluster munitions - and the realities on-the-ground dictate it is likely, if not certain, that will happen. 

The opinions mentioned in this article do not necessarily reflect the opinion of Al mayadeen, but rather express the opinion of its writer exclusively.
  • Cluster Bombs
  • UK
  • Ukraine
Kit Klarenberg

Kit Klarenberg

Investigative journalist.

Russia & NATO

Russia & NATO

As the Draconian Western-led sanctions on Russia exacerbate the economic crisis worldwide, and as Russian troops gain more ground despite the influx of military aid into Ukraine, exposing US direct involvement in bio-labs spread across Eastern Europe and the insurgence of neo-Nazi groups… How will things unfold?

Most Read

All
Throughout Operation Prosperity Guardian, current and former US military and intelligence officials expressed disquiet at the enormous “cost offset” involved in battling Ansar Allah. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Zeinab El-Hajj)

Ansar Allah triumphant: US facing Red Sea defeat again

  • Opinion
  • 3 May 2025
"Israel" appears to be the only place in the world where there are actual demonstrations defending rapists as national heroes precisely because of their crimes. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Batoul Chamas)

'Israeli pride' - Celebrating rape in the Zionist entity

  • Opinion
  • 4 May 2025
Why the Israelis cannot win in Gaza or Yemen

Why the Israelis cannot win in Gaza or Yemen

  • Opinion
  • 7 May 2025
The hero who overthrows tyranny: The path of Izz ad-Din al-Qassam

The hero who overthrows tyranny: The path of Izz ad-Din al-Qassam

  • Blog
  • 2 May 2025

Coverage

All
The Ummah's Martyrs

More from this writer

All
Starmer’s rapid, ruthless rise to power strongly suggests he was groomed and protected by Britain’s deep state every step of the way. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Batoul Chamas)

British intelligence: A law unto themselves

Throughout Operation Prosperity Guardian, current and former US military and intelligence officials expressed disquiet at the enormous “cost offset” involved in battling Ansar Allah. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Zeinab El-Hajj)

Ansar Allah triumphant: US facing Red Sea defeat again

Did Ukrainian Intel Attempt Trump Assassination?

Did Ukrainian Intel Attempt Trump Assassination?

With the UN now having overtly accused Tel Aviv of genocide, the international freedom of movement hitherto enjoyed by Israeli officials may have constricted further. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Batoul Chamas)

It’s Offical: UN Accuses 'Israel' of Genocide in Gaza

Al Mayadeen English

Al Mayadeen is an Arab Independent Media Satellite Channel.

All Rights Reserved

  • x
  • Privacy Policy
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Authors
Android
iOS