Al Mayadeen English

  • Ar
  • Es
  • x
Al Mayadeen English

Slogan

  • News
    • Politics
    • Economy
    • Sports
    • Arts&Culture
    • Health
    • Miscellaneous
    • Technology
    • Environment
  • Articles
    • Opinion
    • Analysis
    • Blog
    • Features
  • Videos
    • NewsFeed
    • Video Features
    • Explainers
    • TV
    • Digital Series
  • Infographs
  • In Pictures
  • • LIVE
News
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Sports
  • Arts&Culture
  • Health
  • Miscellaneous
  • Technology
  • Environment
Articles
  • Opinion
  • Analysis
  • Blog
  • Features
Videos
  • NewsFeed
  • Video Features
  • Explainers
  • TV
  • Digital Series
Infographs
In Pictures
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Asia-Pacific
  • Europe
  • Latin America
  • MENA
  • Palestine
  • US & Canada
BREAKING
Government Media Office in Gaza: So far, 7 bodies have been recovered, while two remain under the rubble, in a scene that epitomizes genocide.
Government Media Office in Gaza: 9 children from one family were killed in an Israeli massacre against the "Al-Najjar" family in Khan Yunis.
Gaza Government Media Office: Over 300 miscarriages have occurred among pregnant women due to the lack of essential nutrients.
Gaza Government Media Office: 26 kidney patients have lost their lives due to the absence of nutritional and medical care.
Gaza Government Media Office: 58 Palestinians have died due to malnutrition, and 242 due to lack of food and medicine.
Ranjbaran to Al Mayadeen: There is a difficult path full of challenges ahead for the indirect talks
Ranjbaran to Al Mayadeen: Defending the Resistance, the Palestinian cause, the Lebanese Resistance, and confronting Zionist crimes throughout the entire region are at the top of the Foreign Minister’s agenda
Ranjbaran to Al Mayadeen:Currently, both Tehran and Washington consider uranium enrichment a red line, but the Americans' red line exists only on paper, whereas our red line is inviolable under any circumstances, and the Americans fully understand this
Ranjbaran to Al Mayadeen: Iranian FM Abbas Araghchi will not back down in the face of US pressure or its media tactics aimed at influencing the other party. They know well that he is a seasoned diplomat who will not lose his way
Ranjbaran to Al Mayadeen: "Israel" has proven that it makes decisions on behalf of the Trump administration and is using all its capabilities to sabotage these talks

Palestine: The cowardly refuge in 'moral equivalence'

  • Tim Anderson Tim Anderson
  • Source: Tim Anderson
  • 20 Nov 2023 18:48
  • 6 Shares
5 Min Read

There is no 'moral high ground' in trying to blame Palestinian Resistance groups while sheltering the apartheid regime, the root of the problem.

  • x
  • Palestine: The cowardly refuge in 'moral equivalence'
    This resort to moral equivalence seems to allow the imperial voice to claim a moral high ground (Illustrated by Hady Dbouk; Al Mayadeen English)

When complete support for the openly genocidal Israeli regime is seen as no longer credible, imperial voices often resort to the 'plague on both your houses' argument, blaming both the racist regime and the Resistance. 

This resort to moral equivalence, or mutual disqualification, seems to allow the imperial voice to claim a moral high ground and present any sort of self-serving nonsense as judicious wisdom.

However, there is no moral equivalence between the violence of the coloniser and that of the colonised, neither in character nor in scale and proportionality. 

In the post-colonial era, illegal occupation is disqualified and struggles for national liberation, against colonialism and apartheid, are recognised as legitimate. 

This has been stated and restated, including, quite specifically, in relation to current and previous Israeli massacres in Gaza. 

An illegal occupier has no right to national 'self defence' under article 51 of the Charter of the United Nations.

Even the Israeli human rights group B'Tselem has condemned armed Israeli attacks on Palestinian civilians.

UN expert Francesca Albanese has confirmed the principle that the Israeli regime has no right to "self defence" against the occupied and besieged population of Gaza. Nor does it have any right to wage war on the people of Gaza.

Related News

We too are Hamas: Zimbabwean Friends of Palestine

Germany: Sacrificing academic freedom for the sake of 'Israel'

The claim that Palestinian Resistance groups carry out "indiscriminate" attacks which target civilians is a reversal of the facts and has always been false. Civilian casualties have always been higher from the Israeli attacks on Gaza than any rocket fire or retaliation from Gaza. 

Repeated ‘moral equivalence’ claims have come from supposedly independent sources and even alleged ‘friends’ of Palestine over the subject of alleged ‘indiscriminate rockets’ fired into Israeli territory from Gaza. When people from the occupied territories respond in self-defence, their responses are condemned, alongside calls for "Israel" to ‘show restraint’. For example, after the Zionist attacks on Gaza in 2014, Phillip Luther from Amnesty International said:

"Palestinian armed groups, including the armed wing of Hamas, repeatedly launched unlawful attacks during the conflict killing and injuring civilians … they displayed a flagrant disregard for international humanitarian law and for the consequences of their violations on civilians in both Israel and the Gaza Strip … All the rockets used by Palestinian armed groups are unguided projectiles which cannot be accurately aimed at specific targets and are inherently indiscriminate; using such weapons is prohibited under international law and their use constitutes a war crime" (Amnesty International 2015).

Many others, including the European Union (Ceren 2014) and The New York Times (Barnard and Rudoren 2014), take a similar approach. Yet repression and self-defence in this conflict are distinct both in scale and in character.  

But have Palestinian retaliations really been "indiscriminate"? If we check from independent evidence, including Israeli sources, we find that the assumptions about ‘indiscriminate’ Palestinian retaliations are often unfounded. For example, during the 2014 assault on Gaza, the UN said that more than 75% of the 1,088 Palestinians killed by Israeli forces were civilians (AP 2014; Ma’an 2014). That is indeed indiscriminate. On the other side, only 6% of the 51 deaths from Palestinian attacks on "Israel" were of civilians; 48, or 94%, were IOF soldiers (UWI 2014: Anderson 2019). That is far from ‘indiscriminate’. There is no moral equivalence here; neither in character, nor in scale nor in discriminate focus. 

Moral equivalence seems to have become a type of ‘qualifying statement’ in Western public debate. It is thought necessary to allow the interlocutor to be able to speak. Condemn the opponents of a Western or Western-allied regime, before any criticism is allowed.  We see this argument from Australian ethics Professor Peter Singer. He said ‘I am critical of both [Hamas and "Israel"] ... and I think the situation is a tragic one … clearly there are extremists on both sides … both sides have gone to extremes … you have to say, as far as Hamas is concerned … they are a terrorist organisation, they are firing rockets into Israel, they are openly trying to kill Israelis where they can’.  This is a popular but cynical and self-serving ‘plague on both their houses’ argument. It just helps ‘qualify’ the discussant. Condemn Palestinian Resistance as ‘criminal’, after which some criticism of Israeli repression may be allowed. These ‘moral equivalence’ arguments, even if they point out the vast differences in scale, fail to represent the conflict in its true colors, and by that omission, aid the colonizer.

Such arguments were even more the case during the 2023 violence, where UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres called Gaza a "children's graveyard".

Most casualties from the Resistance attacks of 7 October, on the garrisons and colonies around Gaza, were military personnel. The same cannot be said of the Israeli assault in Gaza, which had openly-stated genocidal intentions. 

The legitimacy of any claims by the Israeli regime is further undermined by the six independent reports which have branded it an apartheid regime and, therefore, a crime against humanity. North American legal experts Richard Falk and Virginia Tilley observe that the international community has a responsibility to not aid or recognise this apartheid regime and indeed to cooperate so as to dismantle it.

There is no 'moral high ground' in trying to blame Palestinian Resistance groups while sheltering the apartheid regime, the root of the problem. Resort to 'moral equivalence' arguments simply evades this central fact.

The opinions mentioned in this article do not necessarily reflect the opinion of Al mayadeen, but rather express the opinion of its writer exclusively.
  • Palestine
  • Israel
  • Gaza genocide
  • Colonialism
  • Palestinian resistance
  • Gaza
Tim Anderson

Tim Anderson

Director of the Sydney-based Centre for Counter Hegemonic Studies.

War on Gaza

War on Gaza

Most Read

All
Although the background information does not indicate direct US involvement, considering the broader geopolitical context, it is plausible that the US would have an indirect impact. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Zeinab El-Hajj)

Did 'Israel', US fight a proxy war with China in South Asia during the India-Pakistan escalation?

  • Feature
  • 19 May 2025
It is clear that the Israeli project in Syria is not over and that Tel Aviv seeks to use what it sees as a historic opportunity to divide the country and achieve “Greater Israel”. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Zeinab El-Hajj)

The Israeli Syria Dilemma

  • Opinion
  • 15 May 2025
Starmer’s rapid, ruthless rise to power strongly suggests he was groomed and protected by Britain’s deep state every step of the way. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Batoul Chamas)

British intelligence: A law unto themselves

  • Opinion
  • 14 May 2025
The spirit of Bandung: 70 years on

The spirit of Bandung: 70 years on

  • Opinion
  • 18 May 2025

Coverage

All
The Ummah's Martyrs

More from this writer

All
The new wave of ‘fact checkers’ and AI machines are mostly extensions of existing media monopolies, which aim to reinforce key messages of the Western hegemonic cartel. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Batoul Chamas)

How Western fact checkers promote fake news

Cuba faces an urgent need for relief, and the second Trump administration is doing its best to sabotage recovery in all sectors as a means of punishing the Cuban people. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Zeinab El-Hajj)

Update March 2025: The Cuban economy and living conditions

The world sat back and watched Gaza in horror, but few did anything, except for the Yemeni people and the Hezbollah-led resistance in Lebanon. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Zeinab el-Hajj)

Moral imperative: Recognise Yemen and Palestine

Fanatical pro-‘Israel’ judge given the casting vote in intellectual freedom test case Tim Anderson

Fanatical pro-‘Israel’ judge given the casting vote in intellectual freedom test case

Al Mayadeen English

Al Mayadeen is an Arab Independent Media Satellite Channel.

All Rights Reserved

  • x
  • Privacy Policy
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Authors
Android
iOS