AI casts doubt on Jan van Eyck authorship of two paintings
Artificial intelligence analysis of brushwork and technique indicates the disputed works may not be by Van Eyck himself, raising questions about authorship and lost originals.
-
A man views the panels of the Ghent Altarpiece, by Flemish painter Jan Van Eyck, at Saint Bavo Cathedral in Ghent, Belgium, on Monday, March 22, 2021 (AP)
Two paintings long attributed to 15th-century Flemish master Jan van Eyck may not be by the artist himself, The Guardian reported, citing a new artificial intelligence analysis.
Saint Francis of Assisi Receiving the Stigmata is the name given to two unsigned paintings completed around 1428–1432 that art historians usually attribute to the Flemish artist Jan van Eyck.
The works are nearly identical, unsigned paintings housed in the Philadelphia Museum of Art and the Royal Museums of Turin. Both were examined by Swiss company Art Recognition, which collaborates with Tilburg University in the Netherlands, using AI-based brushstroke analysis. The study found the Philadelphia painting was “91% negative” and the Turin version “86% negative” for Van Eyck authorship.
Till-Holger Borchert, director of the Suermondt-Ludwig-Museum and a Van Eyck scholar, said the findings support longstanding theories that the paintings were likely studio works, created in Van Eyck’s workshop but not directly by his hand.
Art Recognition CEO Dr. Carina Popovici described the results as “particularly dramatic", noting that another Van Eyck analysis, of The Arnolfini Portrait in London, was 89% likely to be authentic.
Wider context
Dr. Noah Charney, an art historian, said the findings suggest both paintings may be workshop copies, raising the possibility that a lost original by Van Eyck exists. He emphasized that in Van Eyck’s era, masters often oversaw studios where apprentices executed much of the painting.
Van Eyck, celebrated for perfecting oil painting and rendering minute details with unprecedented realism, has fewer than 20 universally accepted works attributed to him. The National Gallery in London plans a Van Eyck portrait exhibition in November.
Previous Art Recognition studies have flagged potentially spurious works, including Rubens’ Samson and Delilah, reinforcing its reputation for highly accurate AI-based art authentication.
Read next: AI can already do the work of 12% of US workforce: MIT