EU delay on 'Israel' settlement ban draws accusations of complicity
More than 100 legal scholars say international law requires the EU to prevent trade that supports"Israel's" settlements in the occupied Palestinian territories.
-
A Palestinian shepherd herds his flock in front of an Israeli settlement in occupied al-Quds, February 4, 2025 (AP)
The European Union has come under criticism for moving too slowly to uphold international law ahead of a long-awaited discussion on whether to prohibit trade with illegal Israeli settlements, The Guardian reported.
EU foreign ministers meeting in Brussels on Monday are set to consider a potential ban on imports from the settlements as the humanitarian crisis in Gaza continues, where a UN inquiry found "Israel" to be committing genocide, amid intensifying entity-backed violence in the occupied West Bank, killing at least 235 children.
However, the 27 foreign ministers are not expected to make any decisions on trade measures because of continuing disagreements over how to respond to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his government.
Commission outlines three possible trade measures
A full or partial ban on imports from Israeli settlements is one of three options outlined by the European Commission in a document reviewed by The Guardian. The remaining proposals include imposing tariffs high enough to make trade commercially unfeasible or introducing an import licensing system. Euronews first reported on the leaked document.
Written in cautious bureaucratic language, the paper states that the proposed measures “can have a substantive impact on the EU-Israel relationship, also in view of the upcoming election," indicating that the Commission is taking "Israel’s" general election later this year into account.
ICJ ruling increases pressure on the EU
Israelis are expected to vote by Oct. 27 in the first election since the beginning of the Israeli genocide in Gaza on Oct. 7, 2023. Under the EU-"Israel" Association Agreement, products originating from the occupied Palestinian territories, including the Golan Heights, Gaza, and the West Bank, including the eastern part of al-Quds, do not qualify for the preferential trade benefits granted to Israeli goods.
At least 10 EU member states, including Belgium, the Netherlands, and Spain, argue that the bloc is obligated to halt trade with occupied territories following a 2024 ruling by the International Court of Justice (ICJ), which called on "Israel" to end its occupation of the Palestinian territories “as rapidly as possible.” The court also found that "Israel" had committed multiple violations of international law, including activities that amounted to apartheid.
The ruling further stated that countries must “take steps to prevent trade or investment relations that assists in the maintenance of the illegal situation created by Israel in the occupied Palestinian territory."
Legal experts call for a settlement trade ban
More than 100 legal scholars have endorsed ending trade with Israeli settlements, writing this month to the European Commission’s top trade and foreign policy officials to affirm what they described as the EU’s “international legal obligation."
Ignacio García Bercero, a former senior European Commission trade official who signed the letter, said, “The only way to ensure compliance with the opinion of the ICJ is a ban on trade with the illegal settlements. Any other option will not be effective in view of Israeli policy to compensate settlement producers from tariffs paid on their exports to the EU.”
Investigation raises concerns over settlement exports
A recent investigation by the NGO Global Echo found that Israeli exporters benefit from illegal tax exemptions on products grown in settlements, while Israeli tax authorities allow misleading product labeling.
According to the investigation, one in every six shipments examined contained agricultural goods originating from settlements in the occupied Palestinian territories and the Syrian Golan Heights. At least 42% of those shipments were reportedly mislabeled as products grown in "Israel".
Political divisions continue to delay action
Despite mounting pressure, the EU is not expected to move quickly because member states remain divided over whether a ban on trade with illegal settlements can be approved through a qualified majority vote or requires unanimous support.
Following Monday’s meeting, EU foreign ministers are not scheduled to convene again in a decision-making format until October. Sources indicated that the strongest possible outcome from Monday’s talks would be a simple majority of member states calling on the Commission to produce a legal proposal to end trade with illegal settlements.
Alberto Alemanno, a law professor at HEC Paris Business School, said, “Each month of delay doesn’t just postpone compliance, it deepens the EU’s own legal liability for sustaining trade with an unlawful occupation.”
One senior EU diplomat described efforts to secure the Commission’s options paper as “a tough battle," adding that there had not been “joyful cooperation” from the Commission, which is responsible for drafting EU legislation.
Claudio Francavilla, associate director at Human Rights Watch, told The Guardian that “it is astonishing a ban is still presented as an ‘option’, when it’s the only measure that complies with international law.”