Exclusive - Le Gall: Iran War illegal, EU must stop guarding 'Israel'
French MP Arnaud Le Gall tells Al Mayadeen the US war on Iran is illegal, and criticizes Paris for allowing US aircraft to use its airspace.
-
French MP Arnaud Le Gall, representative of La France Insoumise and head of the French-Lebanese Parliamentary Friendship Committee. (Illustrated by Zeinab al-Haj/ Al Mayadeen English)
Arnaud Le Gall, French National Assembly member representing La France Insoumise (LFI) and head of the French-Lebanese Parliamentary Friendship Committee, has called the war on Iran "illegal and illegitimate" in an interview with Al Mayadeen about the US war on Iran, Israeli attacks on Lebanon, and what he sees as Europe's wilful failure to act on its own stated principles.
Le Gall argued that France was wrong to allow US aircraft to use its airspace in attacks against Tehran, and that the European Union must suspend its trade agreements with "Israel," a move he believes Germany and France have so far failed to pursue with the seriousness the situation demands.
A war of Trump's own making
The war, Le Gall said, was launched by "aggressive regimes, the American and Israeli regimes, not in service of the Iranian people or the peoples of the region, but in pursuit of regime change in Iran."
He described Trump as having entered the war "without careful calculation," arguing that the aggression is also bound up with Washington's broader economic competition with China and its interest in controlling strategic trade routes, including, potentially, as a way of undermining Beijing.
But he was skeptical that the strategy had achieved its aims. "This strategy has not proven particularly successful," he said, pointing to the inflationary consequences of the Strait of Hormuz closure and the looming global economic crisis.
"Trump now finds himself trapped in a crisis of his own making," Le Gall told Al Mayadeen. "Iran is a very large country, comparable to France in terms of strategic capabilities and geographic depth. It is capable of enduring pressure."
Today, Donald Trump finds himself in a major predicament, one he has brought upon himself… Iran is a very large country, comparable to France in many respects. It possesses significant strategic capabilities as well as strategic depth… It is therefore capable of enduring and withstanding pressure. It appears that Iran may have been preparing for such a war over the past decades, given that it views it as an existential conflict. Trump, for his part, should have thought carefully before embarking on a war of this magnitude.
On the ongoing negotiations between Washington and Tehran via Islamabad, Le Gall said he could "only hope" they succeed, while making clear that the war's origins, not just its resolution, must be confronted honestly.
Europe's contradiction
For Le Gall, the position taken by France, Europe, Canada, and Australia exposes a contradiction that cannot be glossed over, whereby governments that say they oppose the war have nonetheless refused to call it illegal or condemn the aggression outright.
"These European and Western policies are fundamentally wrong," he said. "France should not align itself with Israel, a state that is destabilizing not only the region, but the entire world. This war is illegal and illegitimate."
France should not align itself with Israel, a state that is destabilizing not only the region, but the world as a whole. This war is illegal and illegitimate… We are not defending the Iranian regime; rather, we are speaking about the legality and legitimacy of this war.
He criticized the French government for its initial hesitation in defining its position and for remaining "trapped within the framework of its alliance with the United States and Israel." That hesitation had real consequences, as France did not prevent US aircraft from using its airspace to attack Iran, a position Le Gall said LFI explicitly opposed.
He singled out Spain and Ireland as having taken more serious steps, contrasting them with Germany, which he accused of placing itself "on the wrong side of history" by opposing suspension of the EU's partnership agreement with "Israel."
On the question of whether Trump's America can still be considered an ally, Le Gall explained that "the United States is neither a friend nor an enemy. It is a major power." He pointed to US pressure on Europe through trade conditions, Trump's interference in European politics through support for far-right parties, and Washington's increasingly transactional view of the continent.
The United States is neither a friendly state nor an enemy state. It is an extremely powerful country, the world's foremost military power, as well as a major financial and economic force. This is a reality that cannot simply be ignored or denied. The United States therefore carries significant weight on multiple levels internationally, but it cannot necessarily be regarded as a friend or ally.
Lebanon: 'Israel is attempting to turn Lebanon into another Gaza'
On the ongoing Israeli aggression against Lebanon, Le Gall was categorical in rejecting the narrative that frames the assault as a limited operation against Hezbollah.
"I do not believe it," he said, dismissing the framing as one "widely promoted in Europe." The scale of the attacks, their geographic spread, and their social and economic toll tell a different story, he argued. He pointed to the use of internationally banned white phosphorus, the systematic destruction of economic and social life in the south, and Israeli expansion into southern Syria as evidence that "this is a war against the Lebanese people, not merely against Hezbollah."
The scale of these strikes and attacks, their geographic spread, and their social and territorial impact all demonstrate otherwise. Added to this are the threats issued by the Israeli side, particularly by the more radical Israeli leaders. All of these actions and consequences affect Lebanon in its entirety. Israel is seeking to turn Lebanon into another Gaza; this is therefore a war against the Lebanese people, not merely against Hezbollah.
He also addressed the November 2024 agreement, which he said "Israel" has failed to honor. "There are rules that must be respected," he said, calling on the EU to suspend trade relations with "Israel" as the most effective lever available. "That would significantly affect the Israeli economy."
Le Gall also pushed back against the argument that the Lebanese Army should disarm what some call "illegal militias." "How can a country enduring war fully impose its authority over all its territory?" he asked. "That only happens in times of peace, stability, and prosperity."
On France's role, he acknowledged the constraints, namely US marginalization and Israeli rejection of meaningful French participation, but argued that Paris must act beyond the limits set by Washington and Tel Aviv. He stressed the importance of maintaining and expanding UNIFIL's presence in southern Lebanon, describing it as a critical force for both confronting Israeli destruction and documenting war crimes.
"France should go beyond Washington and Tel Aviv and reject the unacceptable pressure coming from the United States," he said.
NATO, debt, and the presidential race
On NATO, Le Gall argued that "we need to stop overanalyzing Trump's threats," explaining that the alliance serves US economic interests at least as much as European security ones, particularly through European dependence on US weapons purchases. "We would rather dedicate these resources to our own independent defense policy instead of deepening dependence on the United States."
As far as we are concerned, we believe NATO has become, to some extent, a burden. The conditions imposed by Trump focus on requiring every member state to allocate five percent of its budget to funding NATO. Where would that money go if we accepted such terms and dedicated those resources accordingly? Those funds would ultimately be spent on weapons and ammunition purchased from the United States. We want instead to devote these budgets to our own independent defense policy, not to serving American interests or increasing our dependence on Washington.
The domestic consequences of the war are already reshaping French politics, he warned. The closure of the Strait of Hormuz and the broader disruption to global supply chains are feeding into rising prices and declining purchasing power, grievances he traces back further, to the accumulated anger that produced the Yellow Vest movement. France is simultaneously facing a deepening debt crisis, compounding the inflationary pressures.
LFI, he said, is "the only political party in France proposing concrete economic and financial measures to reduce prices," and has built that platform into the centre of its presidential campaign.
That campaign is now formally underway, with Jean-Luc Mélenchon having announced his candidacy for the next presidential election. Le Gall outlined the key pillars of what a Mélenchon presidency would mean: the establishment of a Sixth Republic to dismantle what he called France's "democratic monarchy"; increased taxation of the wealthy in place of the indirect tax burden expanded under Macron; and a reduction of racism and anti-Muslim discrimination.
"We seek to reverse Macron-era policies under a Mélenchon presidency," Le Gall said, describing LFI as the only party to have entered the race with a coherent platform.
Whether that platform finds purchase with a French public increasingly stretched by war-driven inflation and institutional distrust may well determine the shape of French, and by extension, European, politics in the year ahead.