Hegseth advisor faces scrutiny over Saudi, Israeli defense ties
Pentagon advisor Norm Coleman holds advisory and lobbying roles linked to the Pentagon, Saudi Arabia, and an Israeli weapons company, raising questions over conflict of interests in US defense policy.
-
Pete Hegseth, right, arrives with former Sen. Norm Coleman, left, before the Senate Armed Services Committee for his confirmation hearing, at the Capitol in Washington, Jan. 14, 2025. (AP)
Norm Coleman, a key advisor to US War Secretary Pete Hegseth, is facing questions over potential conflicts of interest stemming from his overlapping roles advising the Pentagon, lobbying for Saudi Arabia, and working with an Israeli weapons company.
The former Republican senator from Minnesota became an influential guide to Hegseth in December 2024, The Guardian reported, as the former Fox News host navigated his Senate confirmation hearings. Coleman was subsequently appointed to the Pentagon's Defense Policy Board in June, giving him a role in advising on defense policy and procurement decisions that could affect his private-sector clients.
The appointment comes as Hegseth faces mounting pressure following articles of impeachment filed by Republican Congressman Thomas Massie, accusing him of “high crimes and misdemeanors”, including waging war on Iran in violation of the War Powers Act.
During his four-hour-and-24-minute confirmation hearing before the Senate Armed Services Committee, Hegseth took time to “thank the former senator from Minnesota, Norm Coleman, for his mentorship and friendship in this process”.
Jeff Hauser, founder and executive director of the Revolving Door Project, which scrutinizes executive branch appointees, described the political benefits Coleman gained from supporting Hegseth.
“Serving as a sherpa to rich people seeking to climb Mount Everest is dangerous and thankless work that is often underappreciated by Westerners,” Hauser said. “But serving successfully as a sherpa to a controversial nominee tends to breed enormous goodwill.”
Coleman's roles span Republican politics, Saudi Arabia, and 'Israel'
Beyond his Pentagon position, Coleman chairs the Republican Jewish Coalition (RJC), an organization comprising prominent pro-"Israel" Republican donors, and leads the Congressional Leadership Fund, one of the largest Super PACs supporting Republican House candidates. He has also worked as a lobbyist for Saudi Arabia.
Last year, Coleman added another position to his portfolio as senior advisor to Kinetica, an Israeli weapons company seeking to benefit from closer integration between US and Israeli arms industries. The role has raised questions about potential conflicts of interest given his simultaneous access to Pentagon policy discussions and involvement in advising Republican candidates on defense budgets and weapons procurement.
Craig Holman, a government affairs lobbyist at Public Citizen, described Coleman as “a walking conflict of interest on the Pentagon Defense Policy Board”. He added that “Most other advisory boards will not allow the appointment of registered lobbyists.”
Kinetica eyes opportunities in deeper US-'Israel' arms integration
The questions surrounding Coleman have emerged amid efforts to deepen military and technological cooperation between Washington and "Israel". Section 219 of the House National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), introduced earlier this year, would expand bilateral research and development, weapons co-production, joint ventures, and licensing agreements.
Mark Dubowitz, CEO of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies (FDD), an organization whose mission includes “provid[ing] education to enhance Israel’s image in North America”, has argued that closer integration is necessary amid declining public support for "Israel" among Americans.
“Those figures should concern Israel and its friends because, ultimately, public opinion shapes policy,” Dubowitz wrote in Israel Hayom last month. He further argued: “Most importantly, Israel and the United States should deepen their military, technological, intelligence and economic integration to such an extent that inflicting financial harm on Israel would also carry a significant cost for Washington.”
FDD has endorsed congressional efforts to mandate closer US-"Israel" defense integration. Its board member Isaac Applbaum also chairs Kinetica, linking the organization directly to Coleman's Israeli client.
According to The Guardian, Kinetica has presented itself as particularly well positioned to benefit from closer integration with the US arms sector. In February, the company reported that Coleman, speaking as its advisor at a conference in Tel Aviv, “shared his perspective from his deep proximity to the U.S. defense establishment”.
The company said Coleman had highlighted growing Pentagon interest in incorporating emerging technologies into its systems, adding: “For Israel, as a strategic U.S. ally, this represents a significant opportunity to scale into the American defense ecosystem.”
In June, Kinetica founding partner Aaron Applbaum, son of Isaac Applbaum, described rising military expenditure in the US, NATO, Japan, and West Asia as a major commercial opportunity. “It’s a generational opportunity to start a new platform,” he told Defense Brief.
Kinetica later celebrated Coleman's appointment as vice-chairman of the Defense Policy Board, describing his position as confirmation of its business strategy.
“Congratulations to Kinetica’s Senior Advisor, Senator Norm Coleman, on his appointment as Vice Chair of the Defense Policy Board, which advises the U.S. Secretary of Defense and senior Pentagon officials on strategic and national security issues... As an advisor to Kinetica, Senator Coleman brings a rare combination of policy, leadership, foreign affairs experience and a deep understanding of the U.S.-Israel strategic relationship.”
Saudi lobbying, defense contracts raise further questions
Although Coleman's precise responsibilities at Kinetica remain unclear, his previous work for arms manufacturers and contractors reveals a broader pattern of lobbying involving Pentagon interests.
Hauser questioned whether Coleman could separate his responsibilities to the US government from his private-sector clients, including Saudi Arabia and arms companies.
“Human beings cannot actually firewall parts of their brain from each other, which means that it is impossible for one’s work for the United States to fail to influence one’s work for Saudi Arabia or defense companies - and vice versa,” Hauser said.
“The difference is that Saudi Arabia and defense contractors want their paid agents to have multiple loyalties so that they can be more effective in return for cash, whereas the US government ought to reasonably expect for the undivided loyalty of those who serve it.”
Through his position as senior counsel at Hogan Lovells Cadwalader, Coleman also worked on lobbying accounts for companies with weapons and government interests.
These included Hidden Level Inc, a drone detection systems producer whose lobbying efforts involved outreach to the Departments of Defense and Homeland Security and the White House on “drone airspace management and security capabilities”.
Coleman also helped raise the profile of semiconductor manufacturer SkyWater Technology and worked on behalf of Coretsu, an artificial intelligence and technology company seeking to promote “technology applications for legal and regulatory analysis”.
Following his appointment to the Defense Policy Board, Coleman continued to appear in the firm's lobbying disclosures. He was listed on an account for Bear SVTP Development LLC, which retained him and two other lobbyists for work involving “[l]and development with respect to AI Data Centers and federal regulation”.
Holman criticized the overlap between Coleman's advisory responsibilities and his work for private contractors. “It’s a very suspect situation that Norm Coleman is manipulating: he’s advising the Pentagon on what policies to do while he’s also advising contractors on what to do,” Holman said. “But it doesn’t seem to be illegal, just self-serving and unethical.”
He explained that the Federal Advisory Committee Act restricts individual lobbyists from serving on certain advisory committees but does not necessarily bar those working as lobbyists through another firm.
Defense Policy Board's history of contractor ties
Conflicts of interest involving Defense Policy Board members are not unprecedented. A 2003 Center for Public Integrity investigation found that nine of the board's 30 members had ties to contractors holding more than $76 billion in Pentagon contracts. Four were registered lobbyists, including then-chairman Richard Perle, who had recently resigned.
Perle faced scrutiny over business relationships with Global Crossing Ltd and satellite manufacturer Loral Space & Communications Ltd. However, a heavily redacted Pentagon inspector general report concluded that he had not violated ethics laws.
Lobbyists are facing increased scrutiny following the Republicans' poor performance in the midterm elections. Stephen Miller, Trump's new chief of staff, has issued a memo requiring White House staff to obtain approval before meeting with lobbyists.