Israeli strategy shifts toward permanent control in Palestine | Excl.
Nevine Abou Rahmoun examines "Israel's" military strategy in Palestine, while Mohammad Marandi warns of escalating US-Iran tensions and possible attacks.
-
Iranian professor of English Literature and Orientalism at the University of Tehran, Professor Mohammad Marandi, and Palestinian politician and analyst Nevene Abou Rahmoun (Al Mayadeen)
"Israel" is shifting from managing the conflict in Palestine to a strategy of permanent military control and open confrontation, Palestinian politician and analyst Nevine Abou Rahmoun said, while University of Tehran professor Mohammad Marandi warned that US media narratives are being used to prepare public opinion for further attacks on Iran.
Speaking on Al Mayadeen's The Great Standoff: Iran and the World, Abou Rahmoun said "Israel's" actions across Gaza and the occupied West Bank reflected a coordinated political and security strategy rather than isolated military developments. She argued that the Israeli government was pursuing comprehensive settlement expansion while seeking to reshape the geography and demographics of historical Palestine.
In Gaza, this shift was evident in the combination of assassinations targeting commanders, systematic destruction of residential areas, and Israeli military movements near the so-called Yellow Line. Abou Rahmoun said these actions targeted both Palestinian leadership and the residential environment surrounding it, particularly after the extensive destruction inflicted during the war.
"Today we are not only talking about the management of the conflict, but also about the settlement of this conflict in the assumption of geographical and demographic events on the ground in every geography of historical Palestine," she said.
Startegy rooted in expanding illegal Israeli settlements
The broader strategy, she added, was rooted in an Israeli political and security consensus on expanding settlements, deepening the occupation and imposing control under different legal and administrative labels. Differences within the Israeli political and military establishment concerned the methods and timing of this project more than its underlying objectives.
Abou Rahmoun also pointed to divisions within the military establishment, which she linked to the pressures created by the war and the number of fronts facing "Israel", noting that these disagreements could reflect concerns about military readiness rather than opposition to the government's strategic direction.
Statements by Israeli War Minister Israel Katz on continuing military action and complete disarmament, alongside Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's repeated references to permanent war, reinforced her assessment that "Israel" was not seeking a political calm in Gaza.
Instead, she said, the current situation amounted to a tactical pause intended to preserve open-ended Israeli security control over the territory, adding that the Israeli public's attitudes toward Palestinians were also an important part of understanding the government's approach.
A shift from conflict management to permanent confrontation
Abou Rahmoun argued that "Israel's" security doctrine was undergoing a fundamental transformation, moving away from the longstanding approach of managing the conflict toward a decisive stage intended to impose a new reality on the ground.
"After decades of adopting the strategy of managing the conflict, or what is called the Israeli approach, which aims to weaken the capabilities of the factions without trying to radically change the political reality, today there is a trend within the Israeli governments that has been followed recently, adopting the approach of the decisive stage of the conflict," she explained.
Under the emerging approach, overwhelming military force, permanent control on the ground and intensified settlement expansion would prevent the emergence of a Palestinian political entity.
Abou Rahmoun pointed to the belief underpinning this strategy, stating that "The overwhelming military power, and the permanent field control, in parallel with the intensified occupational expansion that we see on a daily basis, are the only ways to end the so-called security threats and prevent the emergence of any Palestinian political entity that has power in the future."
She further maintained that this shift was intended to make the occupation less costly for "Israel", replacing containment with sustained confrontation. In her assessment, the rising cost of containment had pushed Israeli governments toward permanent open confrontation rather than efforts to manage tensions.
Attacks aim to reshape Palestinian society
Repeated attacks in Gaza and the West Bank were part of this effort to reshape not only the geography but also Palestinian society, Abou Rahmoun continued. She connected this strategy to assaults against Palestinian prisoners, which she viewed as a means of exerting psychological and social pressure on the wider population.
Discussing attacks against women, she emphasized that their bodies were treated as symbols of land, struggle, dignity, continuity and collective identity. Prisoners, meanwhile, remained particularly vulnerable to direct control inside detention facilities.
"The prisoners are the weakest link, the prisoners are the weakest link and the most vulnerable to direct control in these prisons," she stressed.
Abou Rahmoun characterized violence inside Israeli prisons as politically motivated, while criticizing official and media narratives that portray prisoners as absolute security threats and strip them of their humanity and rights. She challenged the moral basis of this treatment, declaring that "there is no moral basis for the colonizer."
The isolation of prisons from independent monitoring, she added, allowed abuses to continue without accountability before the international community or human rights advocates. She also highlighted assaults against women and the hijab, emphasizing their implications for individual and collective identity.
"There are no prohibitions, and there are clear guidelines in dealing with Israel," she remarked, questioning the absence of effective international protection and demanding to know where Arab governments and official and Islamic institutions stood in response to the treatment of Palestinian prisoners and women.
Settlement expansion and political divisions in 'Israel'
Settlement expansion in the West Bank was part of a broader effort to establish geographic and economic realities before the balance of power within "Israel's" political system was settled after the elections, Abou Rahmoun argued.
She pointed to a new settlement in the Areeha area, emphasizing that the move was part of a wider strategy rather than an isolated development.
The strategy also involved changing the nature of settlement activity itself. Abou Rahmoun warned of "the transformation of the settlement from an ideological project, capable of political negotiation and equalization, to an economic and industrial environment, that is solid, that stands on the ground."
She added that industrial and economic settlement in the northern West Bank was "more dangerous, more aggressive" than traditional residential expansion.
Knesset divide over positions, maintaining occupation
Turning to the Knesset, Abou Rahmoun identified two main parliamentary camps, beginning with "the right camp, the religious people, this movement, the religious Zionist movement, and its allies." This camp sought to retain positions within the transitional authorities or use its parliamentary influence to preserve control over occupied Palestinian land through settlement expansion.
Its strategy, she explained, relied on "paying for the projects of the targeted laws, to the settlers, and also to the random shepherds, that were placed in the West Bank," as well as "linking the settlements to the infrastructure networks, to the government services, in a direct way." The aim was to secure continued funding for settlement activity through the Knesset budget, even if other parliamentary forces opposed those measures.
The opposing camp, which Abou Rahmoun referred to as the "middle-right alliance", was itself divided. It included figures who support settlement and reject a Palestinian state, alongside others who regard settler violence and expansion as security threats that could destabilize the West Bank. Their opposition, however, stemmed from concerns about the consequences for "Israel", including international sanctions, rather than rejection of settlement as a project.
"This is why it is likely that this camp, and this scenario, will be approached to manage the conflict and to cool the fronts, if you will, in order to destroy the settler camps, and not to dismantle them," Abou Rahmoun explained. She pointed to powers Smotrich granted to the Civil Administration, which she linked to maintaining organized expansion in major settlement blocs while avoiding an open confrontation with settlers.
The struggle over the Knesset speakership presented another test of the balance between political forces following the elections. Abou Rahmoun characterized the vote as "a test of the first institutional force for the balance after the results of the elections," with the position carrying influence over legislative initiatives, parliamentary priorities and the agenda of the Knesset.
The change alliance, led in this effort by Eisenkot, backed Kahana for the speakership. Likud and Netanyahu, meanwhile, supported Ophir Katz and sought to retain the position or delay its replacement. Abou Rahmoun explained that the contest was about more than the appointment itself: "this is a defense of the existing balance, an attempt to preserve the negotiating pressure on the path of forming the next coalition."
US support and the future of Israeli policy
The United States remained "Israel's" strategic partner and political backer, Abou Rahmoun said, arguing that Washington's decisions continued to support Israeli objectives across the region regardless of changes in its domestic political landscape.
She said the implications of the recent parliamentary elections in the United States, including changes involving AIPAC and the emergence of figures of Arab and Muslim backgrounds in political roles, remained uncertain. Their impact on Washington's policy toward "Israel" would become clearer in 2027, she added.
Abou Rahmoun stressed the need to distinguish between electoral shifts and the continuity of the US political establishment's regional strategy. In her assessment, the vote against Trump did not necessarily represent opposition to the broader policies that had sustained US support for "Israel" under previous administrations.
"The vote was against Trump, not against the policies of this regime at all," she said.
She also warned that "Israel" could seek another confrontation with Iran, arguing that Netanyahu's political doctrine included resolving what he considered the Iranian threat. The beginning of the new year could provide Trump with an opportunity to pursue projects postponed during the previous period, including military confrontation and further support for Israeli settlement expansion.
A potential new ceasefire in Gaza could also serve broader demographic and strategic objectives, she added. Abou Rahmoun said the direction of US policy would depend not only on electoral outcomes but also on the influence of the established political and security apparatus.
Marandi warns of campaign to prepare US public opinion for attacks on Iran
Marandi, meanwhile, said a series of allegations about Iran circulating in US political and media circles was intended to create fear among Americans and prepare public opinion for attacks on Iranian infrastructure.
He cited claims that Iran was preparing to use chemical weapons, that it could launch nuclear attacks against Los Angeles and San Diego, and that it was planning to assassinate senior US officials. He also pointed to a New York Times article linking Iranian dams to military infrastructure and a CNN program that framed Iran's nuclear activities around the assumption that Tehran had sought nuclear weapons.
Marandi rejected the allegations, saying US intelligence and the International Atomic Energy Agency had rejected claims that Iran was pursuing nuclear weapons. He also disputed the suggestion that Iranian dams were connected to military facilities, arguing that the reporting was intended to justify attacks on civilian infrastructure.
"The New York Times put out an article stating that the Iranian dams, the dams that the Iranians have built for water supplies, that these may be used, they may have been built for helping the Iranian military program," he said. "What is the New York Times trying to do? It's trying to prepare the grounds for the bombing of Iranian critical infrastructure."
Claims of attacks on US, France, aim to influence public opinion
He also cited claims about a possible dirty bomb in Washington and alleged Iranian cyberattacks on freezers in France, dismissing the latter as unrelated to Iran, arguing that the accumulation of such reports was intended to influence public opinion despite opposition to the war.
"71% of Americans said that this war must come to an end," he said, adding that US voters had opposed the war rather than simply voting for the Democratic Party.
Marandi argued that there was little substantive difference between Democrats and Republicans on US foreign policy toward Iran and "Israel". He said mainstream media outlets and the wider political establishment remained aligned with the same interests, despite their disagreements over domestic issues and their differing attitudes toward Trump.
He pointed to CNN and The New York Times as examples, accusing both outlets of promoting narratives that supported Israeli actions and US military policy. Their differences with Trump, he argued, did not extend to "their positions on empire and Zionism".
Iran threatens retaliation against US regional assets
Marandi said Iran would respond to any attack on its infrastructure by targeting US infrastructure and facilities belonging to countries assisting Washington, specifically naming Qatar, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Kuwait and Bahrain, accusing them of supporting US military activity against Iran.
He said aircraft involved in strikes on Iran relied on refueling operations conducted through regional airspace, while drones launched from these countries entered Iranian territory or probed Iranian defenses.
"These regimes that are assisting the United States today, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, the Emirates, Kuwait, and Bahrain, they should be aware," Marandi said. "They have been put on notice. We will not tolerate this situation."
The Iranian response was also extending to shipping in the Strait of Hormuz, where Marandi said Iranian forces were intensifying attacks on tankers that disobeyed instructions from the Iranian armed forces. He said the number of vessels being struck had increased compared with two months earlier and that the damage was more extensive.
US aircraft and helicopters were operating over the strait in an effort to escort ships through the area, he added. Marandi argued that Washington could not prevent Iran from carrying out its response and that the escalation was creating a growing problem for the United States.
He also said Iran had struck US assets in Bahrain following violations of Iranian airspace by American drones, including instances in which Tehran retaliated without a US strike taking place on the same day.
"Iran is sending a very strong message to the Americans that you either end this war or escalate," Marandi said, emphasizing that Iran "will not allow this status quo to remain."
He added that Iran would continue its actions until Washington implemented the memorandum of understanding signed publicly by Trump. Marandi also predicted mounting pressure on the US economy, arguing that the stock market and broader economic conditions were already deteriorating.
Marandi questions Vance's opposition to the war
Marandi questioned Vice President JD Vance's opposition to the war, pointing to his earlier skepticism about US military involvement in Yemen and the war against Iran.
"Ultimately, he went along with it. And he tried to justify it, even though he was openly skeptical, or at least he was skeptical behind closed doors," Marandi said.
Vance's public criticism of the war and his attribution of electoral losses to the conflict, Palestine and US support for "Israel" did not convince Marandi that he was acting on principle.
He argued that Vance was concerned about his own political future and the prospect of succeeding Trump. "It wasn't really out of principle. It was because he's deeply worried about his own political future," Marandi said, adding that Trump had subsequently removed Vance from the Iran file.
Russia and China limit Washington's options
Marandi argued that Russia and China would not support Trump's efforts to weaken their positions or drive a wedge between them. He pointed to Washington's trade measures against China and its support for Ukraine's long-range strikes inside Russia as evidence of Trump's confrontational approach toward both countries.
"Russia and China are not friends of Trump. They don't trust Trump," he said. Marandi maintained that their close relationship would prevent Washington from dividing them, adding that Trump had exhausted his options for exerting pressure on the two powers.
He noted that Russia retained the upper hand in Ukraine and had substantial resources and oil exports, while China was advancing in technology and industry. "They are winning. They are ahead in almost all fields," he said, pointing to Shenzhen and the Huawei center as examples of China's technological development.
Marandi also highlighted the concentration of industrial and technological activity in southern China, arguing that the region had become a global center for high-tech production, citing a cluster of three cities employing around 50 million people, contrasting its industrial scale with Silicon Valley in the United States.