Excl. Marandi, Kwiatkowski: War on Yemen leaves Riyadh more vulnerable
Professors Mohammad Marandi and Karen Kwiatkowski discuss Yemen’s expanding battlefield position, Washington’s role in the war, and the potential regional consequences of further Saudi-US escalation.
-
University of Tehran professor Mohammad Marandi and US activist and commentator Karen Kwiatkowski. (Al Mayadeen English)
Yemen's growing battlefield strength and Saudi Arabia's mounting vulnerabilities have exposed the risks of Riyadh's continued war, University of Tehran professor Mohammad Marandi and US activist Karen Kwiatkowski agreed, warning that the kingdom's dependence on oil, its reliance on US backing and the lack of clear objectives in Yemen could leave it increasingly exposed as the war continues.
Speaking on Al Mayadeen's Iran and the World, The Grand Standoff on Monday night, the two commentators also cautioned that deeper US meddling could widen the regional war while intensifying pressure on Saudi Arabia and its allies.
Saudi aggression on Yemen and the role of "deceptive and dishonest" media
The Iranian academic dismissed reports from Saudi- and US-aligned media about developments on the ground in Yemen, arguing that such outlets have portrayed the situation inaccurately.
"These are outlets that are aligned to the United States and to the West. And during the war which these regimes helped the United States impose upon Iran, their media was just as deceptive and dishonest," he stressed.
Marandi maintained that the Yemeni Armed Forces had advanced on several fronts and were consolidating its position in different areas of Yemen. He cited information from a well-informed source.
“Ansar Allah has advanced on multiple fronts. Now they are clearing out areas in different areas and there will be more good news in the days ahead as I've heard on multiple fronts,” he stated.
Marandi: Saudi Arabia is more vulnerable than Yemen
Marandi contended that Saudi Arabia is in a weaker position than Yemen despite its military and economic resources, arguing that the kingdom has been weakened by its regional involvement and remains heavily dependent on oil exports.
"Saudi Arabia only has one thing that is of great value, and that is its oil industry. Without the ability to export oil or other products, Saudi Arabia collapses. It is completely dependent on oil," he went on to say.
Furthermore, he pointed to the vulnerability of Saudi Arabia's economy, particularly its reliance on oil and the difficulties surrounding energy exports amid tensions affecting the Strait of Hormuz and the Red Sea.
"And today, its exports have declined, contrary to the propaganda that they try to put out. And those exports come at a very high cost, because of the circumstances in the Strait of Hormuz and in the Red Sea," Marandi emphasized.
Saudi Arabia is much more vulnerable than Yemen
He argued that Riyadh has exhausted significant financial resources while pursuing policies under Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman that, in his assessment, have damaged the kingdom's position.
He cited extensive spending and declining exports, while arguing that Saudi Arabia faces greater risks than Yemen in any prolonged confrontation.
“Saudi Arabia is not doing well at all. And yes, they bombed Yemen, and we've seen them murder innocent people in Yemen. But ultimately, they are much more vulnerable than Yemen,” Marandi said.
He maintained that the longer the confrontation continues, the greater the pressure on Riyadh will become.
“They have much more to lose. And I think that it's very clear that this is not a war that they can win. This is a war which, the longer it lasts, the worse it is for the Saudi regime,” Marandi added.
Marandi links Riyadh's position to Yemen's support for Palestine
Marandi also argued that Saudi-backed forces have struggled because, in his assessment, they lack the motivation to fight against a movement that has positioned itself in support of Palestinians in Gaza.
Moreover, he said that the Yemeni Armed Forces have retained significant popular support and that this has undermined the effectiveness of Saudi-backed forces.
“And they don't want to fight and die fighting against a force that stood up for the Palestinian people in Gaza. Of course, the Saudis have already lost the war. And Yemen is going to become united completely,” he stated.
Marandi revealed that the Yemeni Armed Forces already control key parts of the country, including the capital, and that expanding control would leave Saudi Arabia with limited options.
“Ansar Allah and the Yemeni armed forces, the Yemeni government, already controlled the most important parts of the country, including, of course, the capital. And now the expansion of this control is something that the Saudis are going to have to live with. It's far too late for them to do much about it,” he unmasked.
Yemen could escalate strikes on Saudi Arabia
In Marandi's view, Yemen retains the ability to intensify attacks against Saudi targets, while stressing that the Yemeni Armed Forces are calibrating their military response rather than seeking to destroy the kingdom.
He argued that a further escalation by Riyadh could prompt a stronger Yemeni response, with potentially severe consequences for Saudi oil exports.
“Yemen does not want to destroy Saudi Arabia. It wants to bring Mohammed bin Salman to his senses so that he will bring an end to the war,” Marandi said.
He then warned that a further Saudi escalation could trigger an intensified response from Yemen.
“But if Saudi Arabia intensifies, then Yemen will intensify. And then Saudi oil exports will go down to zero. And that will create many internal problems for the Saudi regime,” the top Iranian figure added.
Kwiatkowski: US policy is already part of war on Yemen
On her part, US activist and commentator Karen Kwiatkowski argued that Washington is already directly involved in the war on Yemen, while questioning whether the Trump administration has a coherent strategy for its expanding regional military commitments.
She described the US approach as part of a broader regional confrontation involving Iran, Yemen and other actors, and argued that Washington lacks clearly defined objectives that its military can realistically achieve.
“We are at war with them. Our war front is global. And in Trump's worldview, he is conducting war against a great number of his enemies,” Kwiatkowski said.
Kwiatkowski further argued that the consequences of US policy were extending beyond Yemen and Iran, placing additional pressure on Washington's military and regional partners.
She agreed with Marandi's view that Saudi Arabia is particularly vulnerable because of its weak government, unpopular policies and ineffective military, arguing that its involvement in Yemen lacked achievable objectives.
“So really, the truth is the very opposite of it's going well,” she went on to say.
Trump may seek to broaden regional war
Kwiatkowski also assessed that Trump could attempt to portray the wars involving Yemen, Iran and other regional actors as a single broader confrontation rather than separate wars.
She argued that pressure on Washington could increase as energy supplies face greater disruption and as US and European reserves come under strain.
“I think he wants to lump Yemen, Iran, and other countries that, even Iraq, even some parts of Iraq, is a single war,” she emphasized.
According to Kwiatkowski, such an approach would allow the administration to frame the expansion of military operations as part of an existing war rather than the opening of another war.
“It's easier for Trump to just say, yeah, the Yemenis are helping Iran achieve Iran's goals, and we're going to expand the battlefront,” she added.
Kwiatkowski raises concerns over Saudi-US coordination
The US activist and commentator also expressed concern over signs of potentially deeper US-Saudi military coordination, arguing that Washington could seek greater Saudi assistance as part of its broader confrontation with Iran.
She maintained that such cooperation could involve Saudi territory and facilities, while warning that increased US meddling would risk widening the regional war.
“I would be concerned about it,” Kwiatkowski said, after describing a potential shift in Washington's approach.
'And they only have oil'
Marandi, meanwhile, reiterated that Saudi Arabia's dependence on oil and its exposure to attacks on energy infrastructure leave Riyadh with significant vulnerabilities in any prolonged confrontation.
"But if Saudi Arabia intensifies, then Yemen will intensify. And then Saudi oil exports will go down to zero. And that will create many internal problems for the Saudi regime. And we have to keep in mind one other point. And that is that Saudi assets in the United States, its bonds, its stocks, the Americans are not going to let them just withdraw that," he detailed.
Marandi pointed to the United States' own economic difficulties, particularly those surrounding the bond market, as another factor affecting the financial position of its Gulf allies. He questioned whether Trump would permit Saudi Arabia, Qatar or the UAE to freely withdraw their funds held in the United States, stating, “Does anyone think that Trump is going to allow Mohammed bin Salman or the dictators in Qatar or the Emirates just to withdraw what money they have in the United States? That's not going to happen.”
He added that the kingdom faces mounting pressure if the war continues, particularly given its dependence on energy exports.
“The Saudis have lost a lot already. And if this war continues, they will lose everything. And they only have oil,” Marandi asserted.
Read next: Saudi war on Yemen backfires as Riyadh scrambles for foreign rescue