Mamdani plans overhaul of controversial NYPD protest unit: NYT
An unarmed civilian team would engage with demonstrators under a proposed restructuring that separates protest response from counterterrorism while retaining other police functions.
-
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani looks on as NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch speaks to the press to give an update about the ICE shooting in the Bronx borough of New York, Oct. 8, 2026 (AFP)
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani plans to introduce an unarmed civilian team to engage with demonstrators as part of a broader reorganization of the Police Department's controversial Strategic Response Group (SRG), The New York Times reported.
The changes, expected to be announced Monday, would separate the group's protest-related responsibilities from its counterterrorism work, according to people familiar with the proposal cited by the newspaper.
The initiative comes amid growing demands from Mamdani's supporters to deliver on his campaign commitment to eliminate the SRG, which has faced sustained criticism over its treatment of protesters. While the proposal would redistribute its responsibilities, some of its operations would continue under a renamed police unit.
Civilian team to engage with demonstrators
A new Civilian Dialogue Unit is expected to take shape next year within the mayor's Office for Community Safety. Its staff would be unarmed and would work alongside the NYPD's armed First Amendment team, according to people briefed on the plans.
The civilian team would focus on communication and easing tensions. It is not expected to make arrests, while a conventional police team would intervene if a demonstration escalated.
The approach follows a visit to Columbus, Ohio, in April by senior officials from City Hall and the NYPD to examine that city's Dialogue Unit.
In Columbus, officers contact organizers before and after demonstrations and remain visible during events in identifiable vests. Their role centers on explaining expectations, mediating disagreements, and facilitating the exercise of constitutional protest rights.
Unlike the proposed New York team, Columbus' dialogue officers carry weapons. They rarely make arrests, however, and none has discharged a weapon, according to the report. Other police officers take over when authorities consider a situation to be deteriorating.
Counterterrorism duties would move to another bureau
Under Mamdani's proposal, the SRG's counterterrorism responsibilities would pass to the NYPD's Counterterrorism Bureau, four people familiar with the plan told the newspaper.
Other duties, including missing-person searches, deployments at major public events, and responses to large crime scenes, would remain with a police unit operating under a different name, two sources said.
Asked about the issue at a separate news conference Friday, Mamdani said, "I do not believe that the responsibilities of counterterrorism and enforcement and First Amendment response are one and the same. We will have more information to share soon."
A mayoral spokesman declined to discuss the proposal. Some elements were previously reported by Politico.
Campaign pledge faces renewed scrutiny
During his campaign, Mamdani pledged to abolish the SRG, writing that it had "cost taxpayers millions in lawsuit settlements + brutalized countless New Yorkers exercising their first amendment rights."
Since taking office, he has increasingly emphasized separating protest response from counterterrorism operations. That shift, alongside the pace of the changes, has frustrated supporters seeking the unit's dissolution.
His decision to retain Jessica S. Tisch as police commissioner has also drawn criticism from the left. Tisch worked with the mayor on the planned restructuring, according to the report.
Pressure intensified after federal immigration officers shot Oscar Belgal, an undocumented resident, in front of his five-year-old son in October.
NYPD officers took Belgal to the hospital, but their subsequent deployment outside the facility angered demonstrators as immigration officers waited to return him to custody. During the confrontation, an officer pushed Darializa Avila Chevalier, then a Democratic congressional nominee and now a representative-elect, to the ground.
"The NYPD's Strategic Response Group must be disbanded as quickly as possible, and Commissioner Tisch must step down," Avila Chevalier wrote on social media the following day.
Whether the SRG participated in policing those demonstrations remains disputed. Avila Chevalier said it was involved, while police officials denied that the group responded.
Earlier settlement imposed limits on protest policing
The proposed overhaul follows years of legal challenges over the NYPD's handling of demonstrations.
A city oversight agency found that police used excessive enforcement during protests following George Floyd's killing in 2020, violating demonstrators' First Amendment rights. It identified the SRG as a central participant in the response.
A 2023 agreement with the state attorney general's office subsequently required changes, including an end to surrounding protesters to conduct mass arrests and the introduction of four response levels based on assessments of danger and unlawful conduct.
For the lowest-level demonstrations, the agreement allowed specialist police liaisons to communicate with participants and patrol officers to direct traffic, while excluding SRG personnel from those traffic assignments. Dispersal at more disorderly demonstrations required supervisory authorization.
The agreement is expected to expire in 2029, according to the New York Civil Liberties Union.
Police officials maintain that the SRG has already undergone substantial changes and now has a limited protest role. The department said it deployed to 22 of the 2,730 demonstrations recorded between January 1 and October 19 this year, making 18 arrests.
Read more: NY county bans masks used to hide identities in Pro-Palestine protests