Marandi warns Iran won’t give in; Lawrence flags US war plans | Excl.
Mohammad Marandi says Iran will not yield to US pressure, while William Lawrence warns that Trump may be weighing more lethal military options as the risk of escalation grows ahead of the US midterm elections.
-
Tehran University Professor Mohammad Marandi and Political Science and International Affairs Professor William Lawrence on Al Mayadeen’s The Grand Standoff: Iran and the World (Al Mayadeen English)
Iran is prepared for a potential US aggression and will not compromise on its demands under the memorandum of understanding (MoU) with Washington, Tehran University Professor Mohammad Marandi said, while Political Science and International Affairs Professor William Lawrence warned that escalating military pressure could undermine efforts to end the war.
Speaking on Al Mayadeen’s The Grand Standoff: Iran and the World on Thursday, October 15, Marandi said the Iranian Armed Forces are on full alert and prepared for war, regardless of whether Washington acted before or after the November 3 US midterm elections.
Lawrence, meanwhile, said the likelihood of US military action before the elections appeared to have increased, citing a conversation with a State Department official who had knowledge of discussions within the administration.
The two guests offered contrasting assessments of the war and the legal and strategic implications of the fighting. While Marandi argued that Iran would respond decisively to any aggression on its infrastructure and insisted that Washington must implement the MoU, Lawrence warned that further escalation was unlikely to secure a better agreement and would deepen the consequences for civilians.
Iran insists on MoU as military tensions persist
The Iranian professor said Iran would not accept less than the terms outlined in the MoU, which he considered the minimum acceptable basis for resolving the war.
“The Iranians believe that the MoU is the minimum requirement,” he stressed, adding that there was little room for compromise over its principles or implementation.
According to Marandi, the agreement includes provisions aimed at ending the genocide in Gaza, ending the occupation of Lebanon, and lifting the siege on Yemen. He also identified the release of Iranian assets and the lifting of restrictions on Iranian oil exports as minimum requirements.
He said Iran had not yet delivered its final response to Washington’s latest message and remained dissatisfied with the US position. Tehran had also outlined seven conditions that it expects to be met, Marandi noted.
Marandi maintained that the Iranian political debate over the MoU centered largely on whether the agreement offered sufficient concessions to Washington. He said some Iranian politicians and parliamentarians have criticized the government and its negotiators for being too lenient toward the United States.
Trump eyes 'plans which would involve using greater lethality'
The US professor, on his part, described the MoU as an agreement to continue the talks, rather than a completed settlement, and said implementation would likely require multiple stages.
He argued that US President Donald Trump was attempting to combine military threats with efforts to secure a negotiated outcome, believing that greater pressure would produce better terms.
“I think he is looking at plans which would involve using greater lethality,” Lawrence argued.
Citing the State Department official he had spoken with, Lawrence said the possibility of military action before November 3 appeared more likely than previously anticipated. He added that Washington could pursue further military activity both before and after the elections in the hope of improving its negotiating position.
However, Lawrence questioned the effectiveness of that approach, arguing that increasingly aggressive tactics could instead lead to worse proposals and prolong the war.
Marandi warns of regional retaliation
Marandi said Iran's Armed Forces were prepared to respond decisively to any US aggression targeting Iranian infrastructure.
He warned, yet again, that regional countries hosting US forces or supporting American military operations would also face the consequences of a wider war, naming Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Jordan, Kuwait, Bahrain, Qatar and "Israel".
In Marandi's view, Iran considered these countries' support for Washington's military presence and operations a direct threat, noting that several regional governments supplied US aircraft with fuel during operations.
He argued that recent events involving Saudi Arabia have demonstrated the vulnerability of regional air defenses, asserting that systems facing Iran's missile and drone capabilities would be similarly ineffective.
Marandi's remarks reflected his assessment of Iran's military position and its willingness to expand its response if the United States launched another aggression.
Strait of Hormuz emerges as major point of contention
The two guests also disagreed over control of the Strait of Hormuz, a critical maritime passage for global energy shipments.
Marandi argued that the situation that existed before the war was over and that Iran would exercise permanent control over the waterway. He said Washington and regional governments that supported the war would have to accept the consequences of their decisions.
Defending Iran's actions against vessels that he said had violated Iranian military orders, he argued that the ships were linked to countries supporting the United States and carrying oil from states involved in the war.
According to Marandi, Iran had eased strikes on vessels for several weeks around President Masoud Pezeshkian's trip to New York, allowing oil shipments through the strait to approach 11 million barrels a day. However, after Pezeshkian returned to Iran, strikes increased, according to Marandi, partly in response to the volume of oil that had passed through during that period and partly to pressure Washington over its economic measures against Tehran.
The Iranian academic also stated that the United States was waging economic warfare against Iran and cited Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent's stated objective of crushing the Iranian people.
Exerting pressure, not control
Lawrence, however, rejected the idea that either Washington or Tehran had the right to exercise permanent control over the waterway.
“The Strait of Hormuz, to get back to the first part of your question, is an international waterway,” he said, arguing that ships should be able to pass freely rather than face restrictions imposed by either side.
He said US efforts to reduce Iranian oil exports and Iran's restrictions on shipping have demonstrated the capacity of both countries to exert pressure, but not necessarily to establish control over the strait. Lawrence added that the economic consequences were spreading beyond the immediate war, with higher energy costs affecting consumers and economies globally.
He argued that neither side appeared ready to abandon its position because of economic pressure, raising the prospect of a prolonged confrontation despite the efforts of mediators to negotiate an agreement.
Yemen, Saudi Arabia, and regional escalation
The discussion also addressed Yemen's response to the Saudi aggression and blockade and the wider consequences of the war.
Marandi defended Yemeni actions against Saudi airspace and airports as a response to the prolonged siege imposed on Yemen. He said Yemen has previously declared Saudi airspace and airports closed and argued that Riyadh has ignored those warnings.
The Tehran University professor stated that Yemeni forces initially targeted oil depots and aircraft before striking the airport itself. He blamed Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman for this, arguing that Saudi Arabia has refused to comply with Yemen's declared restrictions.
Hundreds of thousands of killings during Saudi aggression on Yemen
Marandi also criticized the lack of comparable condemnation from Western governments and media over attacks on Yemeni airports during the Saudi-led war. He cited estimates of hundreds of thousands of killings during the war, while acknowledging that some estimates were considerably higher.
Lawrence, while criticizing the broader war and its civilian toll, maintained that international law did not grant "Yemen the right to control Saudi airspace."
The exchange highlighted a fundamental disagreement over the legality and justification of military actions, even as both guests emphasized the risks of further escalation and the need for a negotiated end to the war.
Iran presses Turkey over energy supplies to 'Israel'
Marandi also called on Turkey to halt the flow of oil from Azerbaijan to "Israel", arguing that Ankara's criticism of Israeli actions had not been matched by changes in its energy policy.
He said Iran had repeatedly raised the issue with Turkish officials over more than three years, arguing that oil shipments from Baku continued to supply "Israel" despite the war on Gaza.
Marandi criticized Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev's close relationship with the Israeli government and said Tehran expected Turkey to take stronger action to restrict energy supplies.
Lawrence agreed that Turkish rhetoric against "Israel" had not always been matched by policy, calling for broader international consensus over Gaza and less emphasis on commercial interests in international energy trade.
He argued that governments continued to sell oil and gas to one another regardless of the political circumstances, limiting the impact of diplomatic criticism.
Lawrence points to divisions within Trump administration
The US professor said competing approaches within the Trump administration could help explain the combination of diplomatic exchanges, economic pressure, and threats of further military action.
He described one faction as favoring economic pressure over direct military confrontation, while another supported intensified attacks to force Iran into an agreement.
According to Lawrence, the competing approaches risked obscuring the role of mediators in trying to negotiate an end to the war.
He also predicted that a Republican loss in the House of Representatives in the November midterm elections could trigger congressional investigations into the war and US policy. Such inquiries, he argued, could increase scrutiny of Washington's military actions and its support for regional allies.
'The real victims here are the civilians on all sides'
Ultimately, Lawrence said, the war's civilian consequences should remain central to efforts to end the fighting.
“The real victims here are the civilians on all sides,” he stressed, warning that political calculations and the survival of governments and military institutions were receiving too much attention at the expense of those affected by the war.
Both guests pointed to the MoU as central to the prospects for a settlement, although they differed over its implications and the conduct of the parties involved.
Marandi insisted that Iran would not compromise on its stated requirements, while Lawrence argued that ending the war on negotiated terms offered a more viable alternative to continued escalation.