‘Radical left’ steals headlines, but centrists own the Congress: FT
From Texas to Kansas, centre-left winners flipped Republican seats and gave Democrats big majorities. Here’s how the new Congress is likely to govern.
-
The Senate of the US Capitol is seen on November 3, 2020, in Washington. (AP)
Despite growing attention surrounding progressive candidates advocating sweeping political and economic reforms, moderate Democrats account for most of the lawmakers who secured victories in the party's gains during this week's US midterm elections.
Among the more outspoken newcomers are Michigan Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed, who supports taxing billionaire wealth, establishing universal healthcare and dismantling Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), and New York Congresswoman-elect Darializa Avila Chevalier, who previously backed proposals to abolish police forces, prisons and national borders.
Their political positions have attracted considerable attention, particularly after US President Donald Trump repeatedly attacked the "radical left", referring to El-Sayed as a "jihadist". However, these figures represent only a small segment of the incoming Democratic lawmakers.
Most of the party's electoral gains came from candidates with more centrist positions, particularly those who managed to secure victories in traditionally Republican states.
Moderate Democrats drive electoral gains
Roy Cooper, who became the first Democrat in 18 years to win a Senate seat in North Carolina, illustrates the approach adopted by many of the party's successful candidates.
The former two-term governor has built his political career around bipartisan cooperation and presented himself as a mainstream Democrat during his campaign.
Speaking to tobacco farmers last month, Cooper rejected identification with either socialism or right-wing Republicanism, emphasizing instead his willingness to work with political opponents to reduce living costs.
New lawmakers bring historic firsts and ideological diversity to Congress
The influx of lawmakers with different ideological positions is not necessarily expected to undermine Democratic unity. Former communications director to Chuck Schumer, Justin Goodman, argued that the party has historically accommodated a broad range of political views.
He suggested that a larger Democratic presence in Congress would naturally generate more internal disagreements, but maintained that lawmakers would eventually unite around their legislative priorities.
The incoming 120th Congress is also expected to mark a significant generational and political shift, with both chambers experiencing unusually high turnover after numerous incumbents chose not to seek re-election or lost their primary and general election contests.
New faces reshape Congress
The electoral results have brought several historic firsts to the Senate. El-Sayed is set to become its first Muslim member, while Minnesota's Peggy Flanagan will become its first Native American woman.
Democratic lawmakers are also expected to be younger, on average, than their Republican counterparts. Among the incoming members is Melat Kiros of the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), who was born in Ethiopia and will become the first Gen Z woman elected to Congress.
Kiros was among several progressive candidates campaigning across states including Minnesota, Michigan and Maine. Their platforms featured proposals such as Medicare for All, affordable housing initiatives, and ending US military assistance to "Israel".
However, many of these candidates competed in states where Democrats traditionally enjoy strong electoral support. The more consequential development was the success of moderate Democrats in Republican-leaning states that backed Trump in the 2024 presidential election.
Lucas Holtz, a senior political adviser at centrist Democratic think-tank Third Way, said approximately 34 moderate Democrats won House districts previously represented by Republicans.
He described these victories as central to the party's success, arguing that mainstream and centre-left candidates were particularly effective in flipping Republican and politically competitive districts.
The same pattern emerged in Senate races. Six of the seven Democrats who captured seats previously held by Republicans came from the party's centre-left wing.
Among them was Adam Hamilton, a prominent United Methodist pastor who won in traditionally Republican Kansas after campaigning as an independent-minded Democrat committed to centrist leadership.
Large congressional majorities give Democratic leaders greater flexibility
In Texas, James Talarico secured the state's first Democratic Senate victory since 1988. His campaign included commitments to border security, an energy policy supporting multiple sources of production, and opposition to transgender athletes competing in girls' sports.
Talarico also emphasized his intention to represent Texans across the political spectrum, arguing that the state's political identity should be purple rather than exclusively Republican or Democratic.
Holtz said the results demonstrated that candidates could achieve significant electoral gains by presenting themselves as authentic alternatives to the political establishment without adopting more left-wing positions.
Progressives fall short in traditional Democratic strongholds
While moderates made substantial gains in Republican-leaning districts, progressive candidates struggled to match the performance of more centrist Democrats in several traditionally Democratic states.
In Michigan, El-Sayed won his Senate race by seven percentage points but received approximately two percentage points fewer than Democratic gubernatorial candidate Jocelyn Benson.
Similar results were recorded in Maine and Minnesota, where progressive Senate candidates Troy Jackson and Peggy Flanagan failed to match the electoral performance of their parties' respective gubernatorial candidates.
Veteran Democratic strategist Keith Stern, who previously served as director of floor operations for former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, said the party's congressional groups would encompass a broad ideological spectrum, although their majorities would be driven primarily by centrist lawmakers.
He also predicted that some of the more progressive incoming members would adjust their positions after entering Congress, where legislative responsibilities require cooperation beyond the campaign trail.
According to Stern, newly elected representatives would have to operate as legislators and negotiate with colleagues across party lines rather than simply promote campaign positions.
Democratic leadership faces fewer internal constraints
The scale of the Democratic victory is also expected to give House Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries greater room to manage the party's legislative agenda.
Jeffries is positioned to become the first Black Speaker of the House in US history. A narrower majority could have left him more dependent on progressive lawmakers, including Chevalier and other DSA members, to advance legislation.
However, with Democrats projected to hold a 77-seat advantage in the House, the progressive wing is unlikely to have enough leverage to dictate the party's direction.
The Senate has also shifted in the Democrats' favor, with the party holding 54 of its 100 seats while two races remain undecided. This represents a substantial change from the first two years of former President Joe Biden's administration, when Democrats controlled an evenly divided chamber only through Vice President Kamala Harris's tie-breaking vote.
Party unity faces tests over Iran war and domestic policy priorities
Despite the ideological differences among incoming lawmakers, party strategists expect a considerable degree of unity around shared priorities.
Goodman acknowledged that progressive representatives could oppose legislation they consider too moderate, creating disagreements within the party. Nevertheless, he argued that Democrats broadly share several central objectives.
These include ending the US war on Iran, investigating alleged corruption involving Trump's associates, and reversing cuts to Medicaid, the federal health insurance programme for low-income Americans.
Goodman maintained that the incoming lawmakers share a belief in government's ability to improve people's lives and understand the political expectations that accompanied their election victories.