Rights groups sue US over unjustified strikes in Caribbean
In their cases, three US rights groups cite the lack of legal justification and raise concerns over civilian casualties and Venezuela tensions.
-
Work continues on the construction of the ballroom at the White House, Tuesday, December 9, 2025, in Washington, where the East Wing once stood (AP)
Three major US rights organizations have filed a lawsuit against the administration of US President Donald Trump over the lack of legal justification for ongoing US strikes in the Caribbean, which they describe as unlawful and lacking transparency.
In a joint statement, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), the Center for Constitutional Rights, and the New York Civil Liberties Union said they were seeking the immediate release of a legal opinion from the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel (OLC). The lawsuit was filed in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York.
The legal opinion in question allegedly authorizes the Trump administration’s lethal strikes against what the Pentagon has labeled drug-smuggling boats operating in international waters.
Read more: Rights groups demand access to migrants transferred to Guantanamo
Lawsuit targets Justice Department’s legal opinion
“The groups are suing to force the disclosure of a legal opinion authored by OLC — a part of the Justice Department whose opinions are generally treated as binding within the executive branch — that apparently blesses the ongoing strikes as lawful acts in an alleged ‘armed conflict’ with unspecified ‘drug cartels,’” the ACLU said in its statement.
The rights groups argue that the notion of an “armed conflict” with Latin American drug cartels is legally implausible, as such groups do not meet the standard of an organized, disciplined military force.
Civilian casualties at the center of legal dispute
The lawsuit claims that the strikes, which began on September 2, have led to civilian casualties, contradicting Pentagon claims that the targets were drug smugglers. According to US military reports, 22 strikes have been carried out, resulting in 87 deaths.
The rights organizations described the campaign as “illegal and immoral,” calling for immediate accountability for officials who authorized the attacks.
Read more: Maduro hails UN Rights chief's rebuke of US violations in Caribbean
Trump administration and Pentagon actions under scrutiny
While Pete Hegseth and the Pentagon defended the strikes as necessary operations against “narco-terrorism", some members of Congress have voiced concern over the lack of a clear legal rationale.
Lawmakers have demanded greater transparency from the Trump administration, questioning whether proper legal review occurred before military force was authorized.
The military actions have heightened Venezuela tensions, as most of the strikes have occurred near or along the country’s coastline. The United States has deployed naval, air, and ground assets throughout the Caribbean, including the USS Gerald Ford aircraft carrier, under the stated goal of combating narcotics trafficking.
However, critics argue that the operation has little oversight and risks further destabilizing the region.