Shin Bet chief sought to surveil Arab lawmakers before election
Haaretz reports that Shin Bet chief David Zini sought surveillance of Arab lawmakers before the election, prompting legal objections over the lack of evidence for such a step.
-
Arab member of Knesset Ayman Odeh is removed from the hall after raising a sign reading 'genocide' while President Donald Trump addressed the Knesset Monday, October 13, 2025, in occupied al-Quds, occupied Palestine (AP)
Shin Bet chief David Zini sought authorization to surveil Joint List lawmakers for three days surrounding the Israeli election, including Ahmad Tibi and former lawmaker Ayman Odeh, Israeli newspaper Haaretz reported Sunday, citing a source within law enforcement agencies.
During discussions with legal officials, Zini reportedly explained that he intended to monitor the two lawmakers on the day before the election, election day itself, and the following day.
Legal officials asked Zini to submit a formal and properly structured request, but he did not.
The day after the election, Zini persuaded Election Committee head and Supreme Court Deputy President Noam Sohlberg that the Shin Bet needed to open an investigation based on the information it had accumulated. Sohlberg subsequently sent a letter that led to a joint investigation by the Shin Bet and police.
On the same day, Zini briefed Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on the information in his possession.
'A basis that rests on nothing'
Three days after the election, on Friday, Zini asked the government's legal advisor to authorize surveillance of three additional lawmakers from Ra'am (the United Arab List) and the Joint List, as well as their interrogation under caution.
A source told Haaretz: "The information presented by the Shin Bet was extremely scant, without anything concrete; merely a basis that rests on nothing."
During meetings held after the election to discuss the matter, law enforcement sources told the newspaper that Zini acted with considerable anger toward representatives of the government's legal advisor and other attendees who demanded to know how the suspicions under discussion were connected to a threat to the security of the "state."
According to the sources, Zini asked: "How can you not see that this harms the security of the state? This is an extremely serious event, and it could lead to the cancellation of the election results. How can you even ask what something like this has to do with the security of the state?"
No basic understanding of how things work
The sources added that during one discussion, as Zini listed the five lawmakers he wanted to investigate, he said: "If you allow me to wiretap the members of Knesset and investigate them, I will bring you the evidence and present you with reasonable suspicion. I will bring you what you want."
At one point, according to the sources, the Shin Bet chief forgot the name of Ra'am leader Mansour Abbas, saying: "Come on, come on, what's the name of that Arab? Mansour."
A senior law enforcement official told Haaretz that Zini "does not have a basic understanding of how things work. He does not understand that investigating people in a democratic country requires reasonable suspicion. It does not occur to him that there is an Arab who does not support terrorism."
The official added: "He connects things in a way that embarrasses everyone sitting in the room, except for his deputy 'N'."
Netanyahu aide linked to vote-buying allegations
Separately, Israeli Channel 12 reported Sunday evening that Ido Norden, Netanyahu's chief of staff, had submitted a complaint to the police chief on the eve of the Israeli election, on October 27, concerning supporters of the United Arab List.
Norden directed investigators to a purported source of information who was, in fact, a former employee of Netanyahu's office, according to Channel 12.
Based on information provided by that source, three United Arab List activists were arrested on election day on accusations of attempting to buy votes. Netanyahu's team subsequently used the incident to accuse Arab parties of electoral fraud.
The three detainees were released after police concluded that the information against them was baseless.
Calls for accountability
Netanyahu's office described Channel 12's report as a "lie", insisting that Norden had "fulfilled his duty as a citizen" by connecting the source of the information with the police.
Netanyahu has intensified his attacks on Arab parties, which could play a decisive role in forming a government under an initiative led by Gadi Eisenkot that would exclude him from power. The Arab parties secured a historic result, winning 19 seats in the Knesset.
His opponents accuse him of manufacturing schemes to remain in power.
The Joint List, for its part, called for "an immediate investigation against Netanyahu and everyone who participated in the attempt to steal the election."
In its statement, the alliance said: "Netanyahu tried to steal our vote, but our vote will be the one to bring him down. His place is not in the Prime Minister's Office, but in the interrogation room and before the court."