US abduction of Maduro backed by flawed, politicized DOJ indictment
Legal experts and analysts question the credibility of Washington’s "narco-terror" case, pointing to weak jurisdiction, compromised witnesses, and political timing.
-
A woman holds a poster with the words "Freedom to Nicolas Maduro" and shouts slogans near the statue of South American independence leader Simon Bolivar, in Lisbon, Monday, Jan. 5, 2026, during a protest against the US meddling in Venezuela. (AP)
The US Department of Justice’s indictment of Venezuela’s abducted leader, Nicolas Maduro, reads less like a legal brief than a political screed. It relies heavily on testimony from compromised witnesses and, despite later edits, risks reopening scrutiny of the CIA’s own historical role in drug trafficking, The Grayzone reported.
The January 3 US military operation that abducted Maduro and First Lady Cilia Flores was swiftly followed by the DOJ’s release of a superseding indictment.
It names not only the abducted couple but also their son, Nicolas Maduro Guerra, along with two senior allies, former justice minister Ramon Chacín and former interior minister Diosdado Cabello. Prosecutors also added Héctor “Niño” Guerrero, the alleged leader of the Tren de Aragua (TDA) gang, placing him at the center of their narrative.
A sweeping indictment with thin foundations
Spanning 25 pages, the indictment accuses Maduro and Flores of conspiring to traffic “thousands of tons of cocaine to the United States," relying largely on coerced testimony concerning alleged shipments that mostly occurred beyond US jurisdiction. It alleges Maduro “partnered with narco-terrorists” such as Tren de Aragua, despite a recent US intelligence assessment concluding that he did not control the gang.
Prosecutors further padded the case by charging Maduro with “possession of machine guns," an offense rooted in a 1934 law that could, critics note, theoretically apply to countless Americans. At the same time, the DOJ avoids precise figures on Venezuelan cocaine exports, alternately citing “tons” and “thousands of tons”, an implausibly vast quantity that would imply revenues in the hundreds of billions of dollars.
Notably absent is any mention of fentanyl, the substance linked to nearly 50,000 overdose deaths in the US in 2024. The DEA’s own National Drug Threat Assessment, published during Trump’s presidency, scarcely mentions Venezuela at all.
Legal ambiguity and political language
By using broad, subjective terms such as “corrupt” and “terrorism”, the DOJ constructs a political narrative rather than a clearly defined criminal case. While repeatedly labeling Maduro the “de facto… illegitimate ruler of the country," the indictment does not demonstrate that he is de jure illegitimate under Venezuelan law, a critical omission given longstanding international legal precedents granting immunity to heads of state.
The case hinges on testimony from figures such as Hugo “El Pollo” Carvajal, a former Venezuelan general who entered a secret plea deal to reduce his own sentence by providing information on Maduro. Carvajal is portrayed as a central figure in the alleged “Cartel of the Suns," which the DOJ claims was run by Maduro. Yet his testimony could expose the uncomfortable fact that the so-called cartel was originally created by the CIA to traffic drugs into US cities, according to The Grayzone.
The ‘narco-terror’ frame
The indictment’s core allegation is that Maduro and his associates “engaged in… drug trafficking, including in partnership with narco-terrorist groups." Prosecutors claim Maduro worked with Tren de Aragua and Mexico’s Sinaloa and Los Zetas cartels between 2003 and 2011.
However, those groups were not designated as Foreign Terrorist Organizations until February 2025, a move critics see as retroactively justifying Maduro’s kidnapping and strengthening the indictment. The DOJ must also contend with an April 7, 2025, memo from the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, which concluded that Maduro did not control Tren de Aragua, having dismantled its base during a 2023 security operation at Tocorón prison.
A State Department-funded InSight Crime report further undermines the case, finding that “the few crimes attributed to alleged Tren de Aragua members in the United States appear to have no connection with the larger group or its leadership in Venezuela.”
Jurisdictional gaps and omitted facts
Many of the incidents cited in the indictment occurred outside the US jurisdiction. Prosecutors allege that in September 2013, “Venezuelan officials dispatched approximately 1.3 tons of cocaine on a commercial flight from the Maiquetia Airport to Paris Charles de Gaulle Airport.”
In 2018, five British nationals were convicted in France for orchestrating that shipment with help from Colombian and Italian criminals, not Venezuelans. Caracas acknowledged corruption by lower-level officials and ultimately arrested 25 people, including military personnel and an Air France manager. None of this appears in the DOJ’s account.
Instead, the indictment argues Maduro’s involvement is demonstrated by the fact that the shipment occurred “mere months after [Maduro] succeeded to the Venezuelan presidency."
Mexico, Honduras, and selective enforcement
The DOJ also alleges that Maduro enabled planes to operate “under diplomatic cover” and accuses Cabello of coordinating a 2006 shipment of 5.5 tons of cocaine to Mexico. Legal analysts argue such claims would struggle to survive judicial scrutiny.
As public defender Eliza Orlins explained, “Flights that occur wholly within Venezuela do not cross US airspace, do not implicate US customs territory, and do not, standing alone, violate US law… Intent does almost all the work here.”
By implicating activities that unfolded largely in Mexico, the indictment indirectly points to three pro-US administrations, those of Vicente Fox, Felipe Calderón, and Enrique Peña Nieto. Their former security chief, Genaro García Luna, was convicted in the US in 2023 for conspiring with the Sinaloa cartel. Former US ambassador Robert Jacobson later acknowledged Washington knew of García Luna’s ties, saying, “We had to work with him.”
A similar double standard appears in Honduras. Former president Juan Orlando Hernández was convicted in 2023 of trafficking more than 400 tons of drugs but received a presidential pardon from Donald Trump in December 2025. Trump later defended him as having been “persecuted very unfairly."
Justice Department revises 'Cartel de los Soles' claim
The Justice Department has backed off its earlier claim that Maduro led a drug cartel called "Cartel de los Soles," which the Trump administration used to justify its push to abduct him, thus removing him from power, The New York Times reported. The allegation dates back to a 2020 grand jury indictment and was echoed in Treasury and State Department designations in 2025. Experts note that “Cartel de los Soles” is slang from Venezuelan media in the 1990s for officials corrupted by drug money.
After Maduro’s abduction, the DOJ released a revised indictment, still accusing him of participating in drug trafficking but abandoning the claim that the "Cartel de los Soles" was an actual organization. Instead, the indictment describes it as a “patronage system” and a “culture of corruption” fueled by drug profits. Where the original indictment mentioned the cartel 32 times, the new one mentions it twice, claiming instead that Maduro, like Chavez, “participated in, perpetuated and protected this patronage system," according to NYT.
The retreat calls into question the legitimacy of Trump’s designation of the cartel as a "terrorist organization". Elizabeth Dickinson of the International Crisis Group said the new indictment’s portrayal was “exactly accurate to reality,” unlike the 2020 version. Still, Rubio continued to call it an actual cartel in a May 2025 interview, linking Maduro to transnational drug operations. The DEA and UNODC reports have never recognized "Cartel de los Soles" as a formal trafficking organization.
During his first brief court appearance, Maduro managed only a few words before being cut off, “I am innocent. I am a decent man. I am President…”
For critics, the episode underscores how a legally fragile case has been repurposed into a political instrument, one that allows Trump to frame an extraordinary act of international abduction as routine law enforcement, while signaling a willingness to target other leaders who stand in the way of US strategic and economic ambitions.
Read more: Trump says US to 'run' Venezuela, implicitly threatens Petro, Cuba