US judge declines to halt DHS notice rule for detention inspections
A federal judge declined to block a policy requiring lawmakers to give advance notice before visiting ICE facilities, prompting renewed legal and political debate.
-
ICE agents make use of the facilities at a gas station, Monday, Jan. 19, 2026, in St. Paul, Minn. (AP)
A federal judge in Washington on Monday declined to immediately block a Department of Homeland Security policy requiring members of Congress to give seven days’ notice before visiting or inspecting immigration detention facilities.
US District Judge Jia M. Cobb ruled that the lawmakers challenging the policy would need to revise their lawsuit to directly address the Trump administration’s latest legal justification. While she did not rule on the policy’s legality, Cobb said the procedural changes required further scrutiny.
Judge Cobb had previously blocked an essentially identical policy in December, citing provisions in the appropriations law funding the Department of Homeland Security that require immigration detention facilities to remain open to congressional oversight.
The Department of Homeland Security reinstated the policy earlier this month, arguing that detention facilities were now funded through allocations in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, President Donald Trump’s signature domestic policy law, rather than through the appropriations legislation cited in Cobb’s earlier ruling.
Lawmakers barred from facility visits
The ruling followed an emergency hearing last week, after Democratic lawmakers argued that the funding shift amounted to a legal maneuver designed to circumvent the court’s previous order.
The policy had already been used to deny Representatives Angie Craig, Ilhan Omar, and Kelly Morrison, all Democrats from Minnesota, access to a detention center in Minneapolis on January 10.
In a brief four-page order, Judge Cobb said the lawmakers would need to amend their complaint, emphasizing that her decision was based on technical changes made by the administration when reinstating the policy.
Immigration crackdown intensifies in Minnesota
The decision comes amid growing opposition to federal immigration operations in Minnesota, where clashes between residents and more than 3,000 federal officers have drawn national attention.
Last week, Trump suggested invoking the Insurrection Act to deploy the military for domestic law enforcement in Minneapolis, though he later retreated from the idea. The White House has also defended an ICE agent who shot and killed an unarmed woman in the city, while increasingly backing the use of deadly force despite internal ICE guidance urging restraint.
During Wednesday’s hearing, Justice Department lawyer Amber Richer told the court that Immigration and Customs Enforcement had freed itself from oversight requirements tied to the annual appropriations law.
She cited a sworn statement from a senior DHS financial officer asserting that a surge of funding under the president’s bill allowed the agency to cover detention center operations without relying on appropriated funds. As a result, she argued, restrictions in the appropriations law, which prohibit denying lawmakers access to facilities for oversight, no longer applied.
Judge questions funding shift
Judge Cobb expressed skepticism, saying that without clear evidence showing a complete change in funding sources, the reinstated policy appeared to violate her earlier order.
“I think taking steps to exclude members of Congress from facilities is the subject of my order,” she said.
The lawsuit was brought by a group of Democratic lawmakers who had previously been turned away while attempting to inspect detention facilities.
Christine Coogle, a lawyer with the advocacy group Democracy Forward representing the lawmakers, argued that the administration had revived “the same exact policy” while avoiding detailed questions about its funding sources.
She said the government was “trying to make a game” out of using new funds “to paper over” a violation of the judge’s order.
“I just think that defendants cannot win that game, because appropriations are not a game — they are the law,” Coogle said.
Evidence suggests continued use of appropriated funds
Coogle pointed to several examples she said undermined the government’s claim that it had abandoned appropriated funding, including salaries for senior department officials and Microsoft software licenses used at ICE facilities that were already paid for with congressional funds.
She also cited media reports documenting overcrowding in detention centers and a surge in detentions that has contributed to the deaths of at least four people so far in 2026, arguing that unannounced inspections by lawmakers were essential under the circumstances.