X accused of shielding racist abuse despite UK reporting rules
Researchers accuse X of allowing racist abuse against British public figures to remain online, raising concerns over platform moderation and enforcement of UK safety regulations.
-
Sign of X social atop the company headquarters in downtown San Francisco, on Friday, July 28, 2023. (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
Social media platform X is facing criticism after researchers alleged that dozens of reports concerning racist abuse directed at British public figures were left unaddressed despite being flagged through the platform's moderation system, The Guardian reports.
According to findings released by the social cohesion think tank British Future, numerous posts containing racial slurs targeting politicians and public figures remained visible after being reported under X's "hate, abuse or harassment" category.
Researchers said the platform declined to act in most cases, prompting concerns that racist content can continue circulating even after users alert moderators.
The allegations have intensified scrutiny of X's content moderation policies under owner Elon Musk, whose approach to online speech has been repeatedly criticized by civil society organizations and digital rights groups.
Read more: Musk attacks French judiciary over investigation into X platform
Reporting system draws criticism
British Future researchers argue that X's reporting framework effectively distinguishes between content reported as hateful and content reported as potentially illegal under UK law.
According to correspondence cited in the report, X informed researchers that reports submitted through standard moderation channels are handled separately from reports filed under the United Kingdom's Online Safety Act procedures.
Researchers contend that this distinction creates a significant barrier for users attempting to report racist abuse.
“Many people will intuitively report racist posts as ‘hate, abuse or harassment’ – but it seems X doesn’t consider it as hate,” Avaes Mohammad, British Future's British South Asian Bridgers project, told The Guardian.
The organization argued that content was more likely to receive action only when reported through the platform's dedicated illegal-content mechanism.
Public figures targeted by racist abuse
The reported incidents involved racist abuse directed at several British political figures from across the political spectrum.
Among those cited were Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch, Reform UK politician Zia Yusuf, Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood, former Scottish National Party leader Humza Yousaf, political activist Ben Habib, Reform UK London mayoral candidate Laila Cunningham, and politician Zarah Sultana.
British Future said numerous posts containing racial slurs remained online for extended periods despite being reported.
The organization also said that some accounts responsible for repeated racist abuse continued operating without suspension, even after multiple reports.
Researchers linked the increase in racist content to broader political tensions and the growing visibility of far-right narratives on social media platforms.
Scrutiny grows over X's moderation policies
The controversy comes amid ongoing debate over X's moderation practices since Musk acquired the platform in 2022.
Critics have accused the company of reducing safeguards against hate speech and extremist content, while supporters argue that the platform has expanded protections for freedom of expression.
British Prime Minister Keir Starmer recently accused Musk of helping fuel social divisions through his online interventions regarding high-profile events in Britain.
The latest allegations are likely to increase pressure on regulators to assess whether major technology platforms are meeting obligations designed to combat harmful online content.
Read more: xAI under scrutiny over Grok’s role in child safety violations