Apple faces French trial over iPhone planned obsolescence case
Apple will face trial in Paris in June 2027 over allegations that software restrictions prevented independent iPhone repairs and encouraged replacement purchases.
-
The iPhone 17 is displayed during an announcement of new products at Apple Park on Tuesday, Sept. 9, 2025, in Cupertino, Calif. (AP Photo/Godofredo A. Vásquez)
Apple is set to face a trial in Paris in June 2027 over allegations that it restricted independent repairs of its iPhones through software controls, potentially forcing consumers to rely on authorized service providers or replace their devices.
The case, brought by French prosecutors against the US technology company, centers on accusations of "obstructing repair and refurbishment." Apple Distribution International and its parent company, Apple Inc., are scheduled to appear in court for a four-day hearing beginning June 17, according to a source close to the case cited by AFP on Tuesday.
The prosecution concerns alleged restrictions imposed on several iPhone models between November 2021 and July 2024.
Read more: Apple seeks US approval to buy chips from blacklisted Chinese company
Apple accused of restricting independent iPhone repairs
According to the source, Apple allegedly configured its smartphone software to "make it impossible to repair or refurbish" devices outside its authorized service network.
Prosecutors are examining whether these practices deliberately limited consumers' access to independent repair services, making it more difficult to extend the lifespan of their devices.
The allegations fall under the broader concept of planned obsolescence, which refers to manufacturing or commercial practices designed to shorten a product's useful lifespan and encourage consumers to purchase replacements more frequently.
Apple rejected the accusations when contacted by AFP.
"We strongly contest these unfounded allegations," the company said.
Consumer rights campaign welcomes prosecution
The case follows a complaint filed on December 7, 2022, by French campaign group Stop Planned Obsolescence, which welcomed the decision to bring the case to trial.
The organization described the prosecution as a first in France, highlighting the significance of the legal challenge against a major technology manufacturer.
At the center of the dispute is whether restricting repairs outside a company's authorized network can undermine consumers' ability to maintain and refurbish products they already own.
For manufacturers, controlling repair procedures can preserve oversight of components and servicing standards. However, critics argue that restrictive repair systems can limit consumer choice, increase repair costs, and encourage premature replacement of functioning devices.
The Paris proceedings will examine Apple's alleged practices and whether they violated French rules governing repair and refurbishment.
Read more: Apple flags threats as Intellexa leak exposes Israeli spyware reach