Al Mayadeen English

  • Ar
  • Es
  • x
Al Mayadeen English

Slogan

  • News
    • Politics
    • Economy
    • Sports
    • Arts&Culture
    • Health
    • Miscellaneous
    • Technology
    • Environment
  • Articles
    • Opinion
    • Analysis
    • Blog
    • Features
  • Videos
    • NewsFeed
    • Video Features
    • Explainers
    • TV
    • Digital Series
  • Infographs
  • In Pictures
  • • LIVE
News
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Sports
  • Arts&Culture
  • Health
  • Miscellaneous
  • Technology
  • Environment
Articles
  • Opinion
  • Analysis
  • Blog
  • Features
Videos
  • NewsFeed
  • Video Features
  • Explainers
  • TV
  • Digital Series
Infographs
In Pictures
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Asia-Pacific
  • Europe
  • Latin America
  • MENA
  • Palestine
  • US & Canada
BREAKING
Military source to Fars: We foiled CENTCOM's scenarios to breach the Strait's control and management system through continuous monitoring and effective strikes
Military source to Fars: Last night witnessed one of the most intense levels of Iranian military confrontation in the heart of the Strait of Hormuz
Military source to Fars: In the past 24 hours, Iran conducted one of its fiercest and most diverse offensive and defensive operations against violating ships and US aircraft
Brigadier General Majid Mousavi, receiving the IRGC Commander-in-Chief: Our combat system today possesses astonishing, effective, terrifying, and destructive equipment
IRGC Aerospace Force Commander: We are fully prepared to carry out the orders of the Supreme Leader and IRGC leadership across all operational theaters
Iran's IRGC Commander Major General Ahmad Vahidi tours new missile city: What the enemy is facing is only the beginning
Al-Moussawi: Sovereignty cannot be restored or safeguarded by undermining the nation's strength or threatening civil peace
Al-Moussawi: Those seeking to put the resistance on trial today are either unaware or deliberately ignoring that they are offending a people's memory, while challenging a cause written in blood
Hezbollah's Ammar al-Moussawi at the 35th Arab National Congress in Beirut: Resistance in Lebanon would not have emerged had it not been for aggression and occupation
Al-Hayya: The Israeli enemy has moved into the implementation phase of its 'Greater Israel' project

The monopoly of arms: Why the doctrine is enforced only where resistance exists

  • Sondoss Al Asaad Sondoss Al Asaad
  • Source: Al Mayadeen English
  • 15 Jul 2026 14:40
  • 1 Shares
6 Min Read

Examining the selective application of the "state monopoly on arms" doctrine through Lebanon, international law, sovereignty, and the politics of resistance.

Listen
  • x
  • The monopoly of arms: Why the doctrine is enforced only where resistance exists
    A closer geopolitical examination reveals that the principle of restricting arms to the state is enforced selectively. (Illustrated by: Al Mayadeen English/Ali al-Hadi Chmeiss)

For decades, the slogan of “restricting arms to the state” has been presented as a universal principle of sovereignty and state-building. Yet a closer geopolitical examination reveals a striking inconsistency: the doctrine is aggressively promoted in countries like Lebanon and Iraq, while it is largely absent from discussions in surrounding countries such as Syria, Libya, or other fragmented states where multiple armed actors continue to exist.

This selective application raises an uncomfortable question: Is the objective truly the consolidation of state authority, or is the slogan primarily employed where armed movements challenge Israeli military superiority and American hegemony?

Political philosopher Carl Schmitt argues that sovereignty ultimately belongs to whoever decides the exception. 

Modern geopolitical practice appears to confirm his observation. The international order invokes legal principles selectively, depending on whether they reinforce or undermine prevailing strategic interests. The debate over arms, therefore, is not merely legal; it is profoundly political.

The Lebanese case illustrates this contradiction with exceptional clarity.

Following the November 2024 ceasefire, "Hezbollah withdrew from the north of the Litani River and ‘accepted’ that decisions regarding war and peace would rest exclusively with the Lebanese state and its armed forces". The expectation promoted by Western capitals was that this would allegedly strengthen Lebanese sovereignty and reduce tensions.

The reality unfolded differently; the Israeli enemy, unable to establish a lasting foothold inside southern Lebanese villages during sixty-six days of warfare, achieved after the ceasefire what military operations had failed to accomplish. It maintained positions inside Lebanese territory, continued near-daily airstrikes across Lebanon, and expanded targeted assassinations while facing little meaningful deterrence.

The sequence of events inevitably fuelled a renewed domestic debate. If sovereignty means that only the state possesses weapons, what happens when the state itself lacks the capacity to prevent violations of its own borders?

This dilemma reflects what Thomas Hobbes identified centuries ago as the fundamental purpose of political authority: providing security. 

The legitimacy of the state rests not merely on possessing legal authority but on its ability to protect those living under its jurisdiction. When that capacity weakens, alternative security arrangements inevitably emerge.

The issue extends beyond Lebanon; In Iraq, international pressure consistently emphasizes integrating or dismantling armed resistance groups under the banner of state monopoly over force. Yet comparable urgency is rarely directed toward states where numerous militias continue to operate without challenging Israeli strategic dominance.

Syria offers another revealing comparison. Multiple foreign militaries, including American, Turkish, and Israeli forces, remain active on Syrian territory alongside various local armed factions.

Libya remains fragmented among competing military authorities and militias. Yet the international discourse seldom revolves around an immediate imperative to monopolize arms before broader political settlements are achieved.

Such inconsistencies have led many observers to conclude that the slogan itself is not universally applied but strategically deployed.

French philosopher Michel Foucault argued that power operates through discourse by defining what becomes accepted as common sense. 

The phrase “arms outside the state” has increasingly become one such discourse. It transforms a complex security equation into a simplified legal formula while avoiding a more difficult question: Can sovereignty exist when a state cannot defend its territory?

Related News

The journey to the second liberation of South Lebanon

The fake Gaza ceasefire is beginning to fall apart

International law offers an additional dimension often overlooked in contemporary debates.

Article 51 of the United Nations Charter explicitly recognizes the inherent right of self-defense. Moreover, international legal development has long acknowledged the legitimacy of people resisting foreign occupation and exercising the right to self-determination. 

Throughout the twentieth century, numerous UN General Assembly resolutions affirmed that people under colonial domination or foreign occupation possess the right to resist.

History reinforces this principle. European resistance movements during the Second World War relied heavily on external military assistance supplied by Allied powers. 

The Algerian National Liberation Front received support from neighbouring states during its struggle against French colonial rule. Anti-apartheid forces in South Africa likewise benefited from foreign assistance. None of these historical experiences suggested that receiving external weapons automatically delegitimized the right of resistance.

From this perspective, the recurring accusation that any resistance movement backed by Iran, or by any external actor, is inherently illegitimate becomes difficult to reconcile with broader historical precedent. 

The decisive legal question is not who supplies the weapons, but whether the people concerned retain the internationally recognized right to resist occupation. This distinction frequently disappears within contemporary political discourse.

Geopolitical theorist Antonio Gramsci has further observed that dominant powers seek hegemony not only through military superiority but by shaping the language through which political reality is understood. 

In today’s West Asia, the concept of “state monopoly on arms” increasingly functions as such a hegemonic narrative. It frames disarmament as an unquestionable prerequisite for sovereignty while rarely addressing whether sovereignty can survive under continuous foreign military pressure.

Lebanon’s post-ceasefire experience illustrates this paradox; The government formally became the exclusive authority over decisions of war and peace. Yet Israeli military operations continued largely uninterrupted. 

Diplomatic complaints multiplied. International mediation produced few tangible results. UNIFIL proved unable to halt violations, while the Lebanese Armed Forces, despite their professionalism, continued to face longstanding structural limitations in confronting one of the region’s most powerful militaries.

The contradiction is therefore evident. Legal monopoly over force did not automatically produce effective sovereignty. Instead, sovereignty remained constrained by an unfavourable regional balance of power.

This reality explains why the debate surrounding Hezbollah’s weapons remains fundamentally different from ordinary discussions of state-building. It is not simply an internal constitutional issue but a reflection of competing strategic visions for West Asia itself.

One vision argues that sovereignty begins with disarmament and exclusive state control over force. The opposing perspective maintains that sovereignty cannot exist where occupation, repeated violations, and military coercion persist unchecked.

Under such conditions, resistance becomes not the negation of statehood but a response to the state’s inability to fulfil its primary obligation of national defence.

Ultimately, the controversy surrounding “arms in the hands of the state” reveals less about constitutional theory than about geopolitical priorities. 

If the principle were genuinely universal, it would be applied consistently across all fractured states regardless of political alignment. Its selective enforcement suggests that the issue is not simply weapons themselves, but which weapons threaten the existing regional balance.

As long as military occupation, cross-border violations, and unequal deterrence remain defining features of the regional order, debates over disarmament will continue to be viewed not merely as questions of domestic governance but as part of a broader struggle over who possesses the right, and the power, to shape the political future of West Asia.

The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect Al Mayadeen’s editorial stance.
  • South Lebanon
  • Hezbollah
  • Resistance
  • Lebanon
Sondoss Al Asaad

Sondoss Al Asaad

Lebanese journalist

Most Read

All
Why Washington may attack Iran again

Why Washington may attack Iran again

  • Analysis
  • 15 Nov 2026
The unit’s April reorganisation reinforces how its founding raison d’etre was laying the foundations, and shaping the online theatre, for future conflict with Moscow. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Zeinab el-Hajj)

Psywar no more? 77th Brigade’s sudden death

  • Analysis
  • 10 Nov 2026
Glasgow’s students stand with Palestine. Why doesn’t the university’s leadership?

Glasgow’s students stand with Palestine. Why doesn’t the university’s leadership?

  • Politics
  • 13 Nov 2026
This Gate will be defended by those who understand that sovereignty is not a gift from above, but a covenant: a covenant of the head laid low at the threshold…(Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Batoul Chamas)

The gate to a global mosaic

  • Opinion
  • 16 Nov 2026

Coverage

All
Israeli Elections 2026: The Politics of Evil

More from this writer

All
Selective sisterhood: How imperial feminism chooses which women deserve a voice

Selective sisterhood: How imperial feminism chooses which women deserve a voice

Graham’s Middle East vs. reality on the ground: Hezbollah, the undefeatable Resistance

Graham’s Middle East vs. reality on the ground: Hezbollah, the undefeatable Resistance

13 years after 'Bahrain Forgotten Uprising': Bahrainis are resisting to their best

13 years after 'Bahrain Forgotten Uprising': Bahrainis are resisting to their best

Worried Bahrain becomes a home for the Zionists: Sheikh Ali Salman, from behind bars

Worried Bahrain becomes a home for the Zionists: Sheikh Ali Salman, from behind bars

Al Mayadeen English

Al Mayadeen is an Arab Independent Media Satellite Channel.

All Rights Reserved

  • x
  • Privacy Policy
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Authors
Android
iOS