COP31 talks set to fall apart due to divisions over fossil fuel duties
COP31 ends without consensus as oil-producing countries resist explicit fossil fuel commitments, exposing divisions over climate action and the future of global energy policy.
-
COP31 President Murat Kurum, center, leaves a closing plenary session at the COP31 U.N. Climate Summit, Sunday, Nov. 22, 2026, in Antalya, Turkey (AP/Khalil Hamra)
The United Nations climate negotiations in Antalya, Türkiye, ended without consensus on Sunday after the European Union (EU), Panama, and other countries rejected the final draft presented by the Turkish and Australian COP31 presidencies, arguing that it failed to address the urgency of the climate crisis, Reuters reported.
The breakdown followed more than two weeks of negotiations that extended two days beyond the scheduled conclusion. Turkish COP31 President Murat Kurum acknowledged during the closing plenary that the parties had failed to reach an agreement, confirming that no further draft would be presented.
"There is nothing to do, we did all that we could. Since there are 196 countries, they will make the decision and we will respect their decision," Kurum said. "There will be no new text from now on."
He subsequently left the stage while representatives of participating countries were still delivering their statements.
The failure to secure consensus represents a significant setback for international climate diplomacy, particularly as global temperatures continue to approach and exceed internationally agreed limits.
The last time UN climate negotiations failed to produce an agreement adopted by all participating countries was at the 2009 Copenhagen summit.
Read more: Thunberg at COP31: Turkey must stop oil flowing to 'Israel'
Fossil fuels emerge as central point of contention
The absence of an explicit reference to fossil fuels became one of the principal obstacles to reaching an agreement.
Ireland's Environment Minister Darragh O'Brien said the EU could not support the proposed text because it failed to acknowledge the role of fossil fuels in driving global warming or establish a commitment to transition away from them.
"It is unconscionable that we would have a climate act that makes no reference to fossil fuel, no reference to transitioning away from fossil fuels," O'Brien noted.
Panama also rejected the draft, arguing that its provisions did not reflect the scale or urgency of the climate crisis.
The disagreement exposes a deeper division within international climate negotiations: whether governments should commit to reducing dependence on fossil fuel production and consumption or prioritize technological approaches that allow existing energy systems to continue operating.
The dispute is particularly significant given that this year's summit follows a United Nations environmental assessment warning that global temperatures are on course to exceed the 1.5-degree Celsius threshold established under the 2015 Paris Agreement.
Beyond that threshold, the risks associated with extreme weather events and other climate impacts intensify.
Oil-producing countries defend carbon-removal technologies
Saudi Arabia and other major oil-producing countries reportedly pushed during negotiations for an agreement that excluded explicit references to fossil fuels while giving greater prominence to carbon-removal technologies.
The proposed text acknowledged that global warming was expected to exceed the 1.5-degree Celsius threshold but emphasized accelerating the development of technologies designed to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and potentially reverse the overshoot.
Carbon removal has a recognized role in climate mitigation, particularly when combined with substantial reductions in greenhouse gas emissions. However, its prominence in the proposed agreement generated criticism among countries and climate advocates concerned that technological solutions could be used to justify continued fossil fuel production.
Under this approach, investment in carbon capture and removal could become a substitute for reducing emissions at their source rather than a complementary measure.
Saudi Arabia challenges opposition to carbon-removal technologies
A representative of the Saudi delegation challenged opposition to the proposed technological approach, defending its inclusion in the agreement.
"If indeed the climate challenge, as some have mentioned today, is so important, it makes no sense that solutions, concrete solutions... will be taken off the table," he stated.
The disagreement highlights the competing economic and strategic interests shaping climate negotiations, particularly the position of countries whose energy revenues and economic structures remain closely tied to oil and gas production.
Climate diplomacy faces mounting geopolitical pressures
The failure in Antalya also reflects the increasingly difficult international environment in which climate negotiations are taking place.
Wars, economic instability, rising living costs, and competing geopolitical priorities have diverted political attention and resources from climate commitments. These pressures have further complicated negotiations between industrialized countries, developing economies, and major energy producers.
The dispute also raises questions about the effectiveness of a multilateral process that requires broad consensus among countries with fundamentally different economic interests and development priorities.
For developing countries, the consequences of climate change are particularly significant, while access to financing, technology, and adaptation resources remains a central concern. The failure to reach a political declaration therefore represents more than a disagreement over terminology: it exposes persistent divisions over who should bear the economic costs of the global energy transition.
Nevertheless, the collapse of negotiations does not invalidate commitments adopted at previous climate summits or dismantle the existing legal and technical frameworks governing international climate cooperation.
Read more: Turkey did not invite 'Israel' to COP31 in Antalya: Cumhuriyet