US pushes ahead with deep-sea mining off Samoa despite court ruling
The Trump administration auctions two deep-sea mining leases off American Samoa for $6 million, despite a federal judge ruling against the regulatory approval.
-
A spearfisherman wades through the water at Fatumafuti Beach near Pago Pago, American Samoa, Tuesday, Nov. 3, 2026. (AP)
The Trump administration has proceeded with the first US auction of deep-sea mining leases, offering two areas off American Samoa for commercial exploration despite a federal court ruling earlier this week that found the regulatory approval for the sale had breached the Endangered Species Act.
The two lease blocks span approximately 31 million acres (12.5 million hectares) in the Pacific waters off the US archipelago. Each attracted a bid of $3 million, bringing the total sale value to $6 million. The administration has not disclosed the identities of the successful bidders.
Interior Secretary Doug Burgum described the auction as a milestone for US access to offshore mineral resources, saying it marked the country's first Pacific lease sale for critical minerals.
"Today's sale opens a path to learn more about the resources off the coast of American Samoa and assess whether they could contribute to a more reliable domestic supply," he added.
Trump admin advances offshore mining plans
The auction stems from an executive order Trump signed in April 2025, which identified US leadership in deep-sea science and technology as "a core national security and economic interest." The process also followed a request from US-based company Impossible Metals to make areas off American Samoa available for leasing.
Mining firms are seeking to recover polymetallic nodules scattered across the ocean floor. The deposits contain nickel, copper, and cobalt, materials used in battery production and electric vehicle systems.
The prospect of extracting these minerals from deep waters has prompted warnings from environmental organizations and local communities. Critics say mining could inflict lasting damage on marine ecosystems, as sediment and waste plumes may bury marine organisms while industrial machinery could disrupt wildlife and migration routes.
Oceana Defense Campaign Manager Julia Singer warned that moving ahead with extraction before scientists fully understand the deep sea could have consequences lasting for generations.
"This premature push to exploit the deep sea before we even fully understand how vital it is will have catastrophic consequences that reverberate for generations," she said.
American Samoa residents, officials oppose mining
American Samoa prohibited deep-sea mining within its territorial waters in 2024. The newly auctioned areas, however, fall beyond that boundary on the federally controlled Outer Continental Shelf, meaning they are not covered by the local ban.
The governor has also voiced opposition to commercial extraction. In a public comment submitted in September, Governor Pulaali'i Nikolao Pula said he "does not support commercial deep-sea mineral extraction at this time."
Environmental concerns are heightened by the proximity of the lease areas to the Rose Atoll marine sanctuary, which provides a habitat for threatened and endangered wildlife, including whales, turtles, sharks, and corals.
Court finds fisheries agency violated endangered species law
The auction went ahead despite a ruling issued Monday by a federal judge in Hawaii in a case brought by community and conservation groups. Judge Jill Otake found that the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) had violated the Endangered Species Act when it approved the sale without properly assessing the potential impact on protected wildlife.
"NMFS failed to even attempt to consider the potential effects on ESA-listed species," Otake wrote.
The administration's decision to proceed with the auction prompted further objections from the groups challenging the sale. Earthjustice attorney Chris Eaton described the move as unlawful and said the organization would seek to have the leases invalidated.
"In deciding to move forward with today's scheduled sale, the Trump administration has performed a renegade, unlawful act," Eaton said. "We will use the full extent of the law to vigorously push for the leases to be voided."
Read more: US Pacific territories push back against Trump’s deep-sea mining plan