Audit opened into Justice Department handling of Epstein files release
The US Justice Department’s watchdog has launched an audit into compliance with the law requiring the release of Jeffrey Epstein documents under ongoing scrutiny over delays and redactions.
-
A sign reading Department of Justice is displayed at the FBI field office in Portland, Ore., Jan. 16, 2025 (AP, File)
The US Department of Justice’s Office of the Inspector General (OIG) has opened an audit into whether the department is complying with the federal law mandating the release of records related to convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, The Guardian reported.
In a statement released on Thursday, Deputy Inspector General William M. Blier, who is currently serving as the inspector general, said the review will evaluate how the Justice Department identifies, processes, and releases documents under the Epstein Files Transparency Act.
The audit will also examine internal procedures for gathering and producing relevant materials, as well as the department’s approach to redactions and withholding information in line with legal exemptions, including protections for victims, child sexual abuse material, active investigations, and national security concerns.
The inspector general’s office added that it will review how the department addresses issues raised after documents are released to the public and noted that additional matters may be included if they arise during the investigation.
The Justice Department did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Delays and partial releases
The Epstein Files Transparency Act, passed by Congress and signed into law in November last year, requires the Justice Department to release its files on Epstein, subject to specific legal safeguards.
However, the department has come under sustained criticism over its handling of the law. It missed a December deadline to publish the records, later releasing documents in January that it said represented the full set.
Since then, lawmakers and Epstein victims have raised concerns over the handling of sensitive information, including allegations that personal data may have been improperly disclosed and that redactions may have gone too far.
The Justice Department maintains that it has fully complied with its legal obligations.
Testimony dispute
The issue has also drawn increased attention in Congress, where the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee issued a subpoena to former Attorney General Pam Bondi over the department’s handling of the Epstein case and its compliance with the transparency law.
Bondi was expected to testify, but after being removed from office by President Donald Trump, the Justice Department informed lawmakers that she would not appear, arguing the subpoena no longer applied in her official capacity.
In a letter to committee chair James Comer, Assistant Attorney General Patrick Davis stated that Bondi could not testify as attorney general because she no longer holds the position and asked the committee to confirm whether the subpoena would be withdrawn.
As of early April, according to a person familiar with the matter, the subpoena had not been formally withdrawn.
The audit adds further oversight pressure on the Justice Department as questions persist over its handling of Epstein-related records and compliance with the transparency law.
Previous context
This scrutiny builds on earlier controversies surrounding the department’s conduct during congressional reviews of the same materials.
In early February, members of Congress were demanding investigations into the Department of Justice after photographs revealed that the agency created records of lawmakers’ research activity while they reviewed files linked to Epstein.
Images captured by Reuters during a congressional hearing on Wednesday showed then-US Attorney General Pam Bondi holding a document labeled “Jayapal Pramila Search History.” The document appeared to list files accessed by Democratic Representative Pramila Jayapal as she examined materials connected to Epstein.
Lawmakers were granted access to the unredacted files earlier under the Epstein Files Transparency Act. Several members of Congress have since accused the Justice Department of violating the separation of powers by monitoring their investigative activity and are calling for the tracking to be halted immediately.
“It is an outrage that [the justice department] is tracking members’ investigative steps,” Representative Jamie Raskin, the ranking Democrat on the House Judiciary Committee, told The Guardian. Raskin announced he would request that the department’s inspector general launch an inquiry into what he described as an “outrageous abuse of power.”
Read more: Majority of Americans link Trump’s Iran war to Epstein cover‑up