Behind closed doors, US pitches NATO path for Ukraine, at a price: WSJ
US negotiators have raised a land-for-NATO deal with Kiev and Europe, a once-taboo idea, as peace talks continue in Berlin, Dublin, and Abu Dhabi.
-
German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, French President Emmanuel Macron, British Prime Minister Andy Burnham, and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky during talks on security guarantees for Ukraine (Social Media / @jaredkushner)
Washington’s negotiators have been quietly testing a proposal that was long considered a non-starter: offering Ukraine a place in NATO if it hands over territory to Russia, The Wall Street Journal reported, citing people familiar with the matter.
Jared Kushner, President Trump’s son-in-law and special envoy, has raised the concept repeatedly during private peace discussions over recent months.
Keeping Ukraine out of the 32-nation alliance has been one of Moscow’s central aims for years, and Trump himself dismissed Ukrainian membership early last year as something Russia could not accept.
Even so, people who took part in the talks say Kushner and fellow envoy Steve Witkoff have brought the subject up with European officials several times lately. One European leader said it first surfaced in a phone call as far back as August.
The most recent airing came last week at a military airfield in Dublin, where the two Americans sat down with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, his advisor Rustem Umerov, and a handful of European national security advisors. It also arose in at least one session in the United Arab Emirates, where the envoys held a string of meetings with Ukrainian, European, and Russian representatives in an effort to broker an end to the war.
Two options on the table
People involved in the negotiations described to the WSJ two scenarios the US has put forward:
Land for membership: Ukraine would withdraw from the part of the eastern Donbass region it still holds, the area where both armies have fought for much of the war, and would receive full NATO membership in return.
Freeze plus guarantees: The fighting would stop along the current frontline, leaving Kiev in control of some of the Donbass. Ukraine would instead be protected by security guarantees, set out in an international treaty with the US and possibly European partners, against any future Russian attack.
A US official said many ideas are under discussion and that any final agreement would require sign-off from both Kiev and Moscow.
Why it matters
The mere mention of membership suggests how far Washington may be prepared to go to unlock the stalemate. Trump and earlier administrations have held back from offering Ukraine a seat, worried that doing so could pull the West into a direct clash with Moscow, a concern some European leaders share.
It remains unclear how seriously the American mediators are weighing the idea, or whether Trump has revised his own thinking. Backing it could open rifts inside NATO, where countries such as Germany have long opposed Kiev’s entry and where new members can only be admitted by consensus.
Berlin talks and a call from Air Force One
On Thursday, Kushner told reporters that Russia had become “comfortable” with NATO-like security guarantees for Ukraine. He and Witkoff were in Berlin that day, meeting nations that back Kiev to discuss future funding and protection for the country.
“There will be huge deterrence and massive consequences if it’s ever violated,” Kushner said, noting that Trump is willing to offer such guarantees. “You make it so good that hopefully you don’t have to use it because the deterrence is so strong.”
Trump, flying back from a summit with Russian President Vladimir Putin and China’s Xi Jinping, phoned Kushner from Air Force One, the WSJ reported, citing two people in the room. He said Putin was weary of the war and ready to reach a settlement. On speakerphone to the European leaders assembled around Kushner, Zelensky among them, Trump said a deal with Putin would spare them considerable sums they would otherwise spend backing Ukraine.
Afterward, French President Emmanuel Macron said the time had come to talk about NATO membership for Ukraine. Attendees said the subject did come up in Berlin, but the German hosts refused to pursue it. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz reportedly told his aides that Ukraine would not join NATO within his lifetime.
Kiev’s position
Zelensky said last week that talks with the US and Europe on security guarantees were continuing and that the Ukrainian people would have to approve any agreement. According to him, American negotiators have characterized the guarantees as bilateral arrangements “similar to what Israel has.”
He also confirmed that the NATO idea had been floated by the Americans. “The Americans raised a question, What if Ukraine joins NATO? Would Ukraine withdraw from Donbas?” Zelensky told journalists.
“I have said repeatedly: Ukraine is not retreating and is not giving up its land to terrorists,” Zelensky said.
Moscow’s demands
At last week’s talks in Abu Dhabi, Russian negotiators explicitly insisted that Ukraine renounce any ambition of joining NATO, the WSJ reported, citing people familiar with the discussions. A paper circulated among negotiators, which The Wall Street Journal has seen, called for Ukraine to strike its NATO aspirations from its constitution. It also demanded that the alliance pledge not to deploy troops or military hardware on Ukrainian soil and that Western weapons shipments to Kiev end.
The document, a so-called non-paper because it sets out unofficial positions for negotiating purposes, went considerably further. It urged NATO to pull its military infrastructure in Eastern Europe back to 1997 levels, the year the alliance and Russia created a cooperation forum. It also called for the removal of missiles able to hit Russia from sites across Europe and the Caucasus and for France and Britain to withdraw their offers to extend nuclear protection to other European countries.
European negotiators dismissed the list as maximalist opening bids rather than a blueprint for a final settlement.
For context, NATO has largely honored its agreements with Russia by avoiding major military buildups in its eastern member states. The exceptions are radar installations in Poland and Romania and a base in Lithuania for a German unit that will be stationed there permanently, a move prompted by the war in Ukraine.
Read next: Kushner: Ukraine guarantees would follow NATO’s Article 5 model