China warns of judicial overreach in Myanmar genocide ruling
Chinese judge Xue Hanqin cites an earlier ICJ case in disputing the finding of genocidal intent.
-
Foreign Ministry spokesman Guo Jiakun speaks during a press conference, undated (File photo/ AFP)
China questioned whether the International Court of Justice (ICJ) had overstepped its authority in ruling that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya, AFP reported Friday. Foreign Ministry spokesperson Guo Jiakun said Beijing would continue to support talks on the return of Rohingya refugees.
"China is concerned about issues such as jurisdiction overreach and expanded interpretation, and believes that such practices are not conducive to the settlement of disputes," Guo told reporters.
The court ruled 9-6 on Thursday that Myanmar's military committed genocide during its 2017 campaign in northern Rakhine state.
"The international community should make joint efforts in this direction to avoid complicating this issue," he added.
Xue invokes earlier ruling on forced displacement
One of the ICJ's judges is Chinese, and voted in Myanmar's favour on all but one count.
Asked whether Judge Xue Hanqin was acting on instructions from the Chinese government, Guo said the jurors "perform duties independently."
Xue "expressed views based on international law and the facts of the case while drawing on professional experience... which also demonstrates a commitment to fulfilling duties," he said.
Xue and five other dissenting judges argued that the evidence supported another explanation for the military's actions. They said troops may have used killings and other abuses in some villages to frighten Rohingya communities across the region into fleeing and to prevent their return.
The six judges drew on the ICJ's 2015 ruling in Croatia v. Serbia. In that case, the court found that forces had committed killings and other abuses to drive a population from its territory. The dissenters argued that the same legal test applied to Myanmar. To establish genocide from a pattern of violence, the intent to physically destroy the Rohingya, in whole or in substantial part, had to be the "only reasonable inference."
In her dissent, Xue cited witnesses who said soldiers let them pass as they fled their homes and, in some cases, pointed them toward the border.
The majority, however, found that troops attacked Rohingya civilians who were already fleeing toward Bangladesh. It concluded that an intent to drive the Rohingya from their homes could not fully explain those attacks or the widespread violence against young children.
Xue nevertheless voted to require Myanmar to investigate suspects and prosecute them where warranted. She also urged authorities to help displaced Rohingya return home and rebuild their lives.
Myanmar calls ruling 'unfair'
In Naypyidaw, Myanmar presidential spokeswoman Khaing Khaing Soe pointed to the split among the judges when asked about the ruling on Friday.
"So this was not a unanimous decision," she said. "I would say it is not fair."
Myanmar had argued that its military launched the 2017 operation in response to insurgent attacks that killed a dozen security personnel. The court rejected that claim, finding no evidence that troops distinguished between civilians and suspected fighters during the operation.
Beijing backs talks on refugee returns
China first outlined its diplomatic proposal in November 2017, after the military campaign drove hundreds of thousands of Rohingya into Bangladesh. Following visits to both countries, Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi called for a ceasefire and direct talks between Myanmar and Bangladesh on refugee returns. He also urged international investment in Rakhine, arguing that poverty had contributed to the conflict.
Thursday's judgment ordered Myanmar to allow displaced Rohingya to return safely and to compensate victims. The court will determine the amount in later proceedings.
Read more: 'It's full of messages for Israel': Myanmar ruling may shape Gaza case