EU backs deportation powers likened to ICE practices
The EU has approved a new ICE-like deportation law allowing home raids, longer detention periods, and offshore return hubs as part of a broader migration overhaul.
-
Members of a group of some 30 migrants seeking asylum are seen in Bialowieza, Poland, on May 28, 2023. (AP)
The European Union has approved a new deportation law that is eerily similar to ICE-style immigration enforcement in the United States, granting authorities expanded powers to conduct home raids, extend detention periods, and transfer undocumented migrants to offshore return hubs.
The regulation, agreed during negotiations between the European Council, the European Parliament, and the European Commission, forms a central part of the bloc’s broader overhaul of its asylum and migration system. EU officials say the changes are intended to improve enforcement against individuals who have been denied asylum, overstayed visas, or otherwise lack legal residency rights.
Under the new rules, national authorities will gain wider powers to enforce deportation orders, including the ability to search homes and other premises and seize personal belongings where necessary to ensure compliance.
People subject to deportation orders who are considered uncooperative or at risk of absconding may be detained for up to two years, with the possibility of extending detention to 30 months, marking a significant increase from the current 18 months.
Authorities will also be able to reduce certain benefits or allowances for individuals who refuse to comply with return decisions.
Longer detention and expanded enforcement powers
The regulation permits the detention of unaccompanied minors and families with children under specific circumstances. According to the European Parliament, such measures should only be used as a last resort and for the shortest appropriate period while taking into account the best interests of the child.
Individuals classified as security risks could also face lifetime bans from entering the EU, replacing the current maximum prohibition period of 10 years.
EU officials argue the changes are necessary to address shortcomings in the bloc’s migration system. Currently, only around 20% of people ordered to leave the EU are successfully returned to their countries of origin, a figure policymakers have repeatedly cited as evidence of weak enforcement.
Magnus Brunner, the European Commissioner for Migration, described the legislation as an important step in strengthening migration management across the bloc.
“With the new rules, we have more control over who can come to the EU, who can stay and who needs to leave,” Brunner said.
Offshore return hubs included in new rules
A key element of the deportation law is the authorization of offshore return hubs, facilities located outside the European Union, where undocumented migrants could be held before being deported to their home countries.
Several EU member states are already engaged in discussions with countries, primarily in Africa, regarding the establishment of such centers, although no formal agreements have yet been announced.
Supporters argue the measure could improve the efficiency of deportation procedures and reduce pressure on national migration systems. However, critics have questioned how the facilities would operate and what safeguards would be in place for those transferred to them.
ICE-like measures
Human rights advocates and several lawmakers have sharply criticized the legislation, arguing that it mirrors aspects of recent US immigration enforcement policies.
Mélissa Camara, a Green member of the European Parliament, said the regulation weakens procedural safeguards, lengthens detention periods, and authorizes practices similar to those used by US immigration authorities, including home raids.
The agreement followed a vote in March in which the center-right European People’s Party joined far-right groups in the European Parliament to support tougher return measures.
Defending the legislation, Irish lawmaker Regina Doherty said the measures target individuals who have exhausted legal procedures and no longer have a right to remain in the EU. She argued that public debate on migration has often been distorted by misinformation and oversimplified narratives.
Read more: Public fury after ICE defies release order, seizes, flies two-year-old
Rights organizations sound the alarm
Rights organizations warned that the regulation could expose large numbers of migrants to prolonged detention and family separation.
Silvia Carta, an advocacy officer at the Platform for Cooperation on Undocumented Migrants, said the law would increase the risk of harm for undocumented people through extended detention periods and transfers to third countries.
The new deportation law is expected to receive final approval from both the EU Council and the European Parliament, completing a years-long effort to reform the bloc’s asylum system.
The broader migration overhaul was launched in 2020 after European policymakers sought to prevent a repeat of the 2015 migration crisis, when approximately 1.3 million people, many fleeing conflicts in Syria and Afghanistan, sought refuge across Europe. EU leaders hope the new framework will strengthen the bloc’s ability to manage migration flows and increase the number of successful deportations.
For decades, Western powers have played significant roles in shaping developments in many of these regions through military interventions, foreign policy decisions, sanctions, and economic influence. As
European governments move to expand detention powers and accelerate deportations, the new framework is likely to intensify debate over the responsibility of wealthy nations toward populations displaced by crises that have often unfolded within the orbit of Western geopolitical interests.