GOP voters split over 'Israel', MAGA leads support: Politico poll
The Republican Party is showing internal divisions over 'Israel', with younger and non-MAGA voters expressing greater skepticism.
-
Supporters of Donald Trump sign a bus before a campaign rally at the Butler Farm Show, Oct. 5, 2024, in Butler, Pa. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson, File)
Divisions over US support for "Israel" are widening within the Republican Party, a new poll reported by Politico suggests, with voters aligned with President Donald Trump’s MAGA movement showing significantly stronger backing for the Israeli government than other Republican voters.
According to the Politico poll, nearly half of self-identified MAGA Trump voters said they support "Israel" and approve of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government, compared with 29% of Trump voters who do not identify with the MAGA movement.
The survey also found that 41% of MAGA voters believe "Israel" is justified in its genocide on Gaza, while 31% of non-MAGA Trump voters share that view. Another 24% of MAGA voters said the war was initially justified but has since gone too far, compared with 31% among non-MAGA Republican voters.
The findings point to emerging fractures within the Republican coalition over US policy toward "Israel" and broader foreign policy priorities, particularly as Trump seeks to maintain unity ahead of future elections.
Generational split emerges among Republican voters
The Politico poll, conducted by Public First from April 11 to 14, surveying 2,035 US adults, found notable generational differences among Republican voters regarding ties with "Israel."
Among Trump voters under the age of 35, 32% said the US is too closely aligned with the Israeli government, compared with just 11% of Trump voters over 55.
Younger Republican voters were also far more likely to support distancing Washington from "Israel" even when both countries face common threats. Nearly half of Trump voters between the ages of 18 and 34 favored greater separation between the two allies, while only 13% of older Republican voters supported such a move.
The survey also showed growing skepticism among non-MAGA Republicans over Israeli influence on US foreign policy. Non-MAGA Trump voters were 10 percentage points more likely than MAGA supporters to believe the Israeli government exerts excessive influence over Washington’s foreign policy decisions.
The issue has increasingly surfaced in public disagreements among prominent conservative figures. Former Fox News host Tucker Carlson, former Republican Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene, and political strategist Steve Bannon have all criticized the close US relationship with "Israel," particularly amid escalating tensions after the US attacked Iran.
At the same time, many Republican lawmakers and conservative commentators, including Ben Shapiro and Laura Loomer, have continued defending strong US-Israeli ties and backing Trump’s approach.
AIPAC role sparks debate inside GOP
The poll also highlighted divisions over the role of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), a powerful pro-"Israel" lobbying group active in both Democratic and Republican primaries.
MAGA Trump voters were found to be more supportive of AIPAC’s political involvement than non-MAGA Republicans, while other Republican voters expressed greater opposition to the organization’s influence in elections.
AIPAC has recently backed several Republican incumbents facing competitive races, including Senators John Cornyn and Bill Cassidy. The group and allied organizations have also invested heavily in efforts to unseat Representative Thomas Massie, partly over his opposition to military aid for "Israel" and attempts to limit Trump’s war powers.
Politico reported that the poll reflects broader tensions within the Republican Party over foreign intervention, US military involvement abroad, and the future of Washington’s alliance with "Israel" as younger conservative voters increasingly question longstanding policy positions.