Hegseth faces fury as Iran war deepens Pentagon readiness crisis
The US Secretary of War is facing mounting criticism as prolonged operations against Iran, extended deployments, and internal Pentagon disputes raise concerns over US military readiness.
-
US Secretary of War Pete Hegseth attends a forum of The Americas Counter Cartel Coalition in Panama City, Wednesday, Aug. 12, 2026 (AP)
US Secretary of War Pete Hegseth is facing mounting criticism from former military officials and Republican lawmakers over his management of the Pentagon, as prolonged war on Iran places growing strain on American forces and exposes divisions inside the Department of War, The Guardian reported.
Concerns surrounding Hegseth have intensified amid extended deployments in West Asia, disagreements among senior commanders, blocked military promotions, and the resignation of Army Secretary Dan Driscoll.
Critics interviewed by The Guardian argued that the ongoing war on Iran has highlighted broader questions over military readiness and whether the Trump administration has a coherent strategy for the conflict.
“The secretary of defense is a clear and present danger to the national security of the United States and the world,” retired Major General Randy Manner, a former member of the US National Guard and member of National Security Leaders for America, said.
“He has done more harm to the national security of the United States than any secretary of defense since the country was created.”
Republican Senator Thom Tillis, who is preparing to leave the Senate following disputes with US President Donald Trump, has also called for Hegseth's dismissal.
“I have never witnessed more inept management of the brave men and women who serve our country,” Tillis wrote on social media. “He is intimidated by competence and retreats to ginning up culture wars instead of soberly attending to the vital work of our national defense and the health and wellbeing of our fighting force.”
Extended deployments raise readiness concerns
The criticism comes as the United States continues military operations against Iran following the resumption of strikes near the Strait of Hormuz after a month-long pause.
Recent attacks targeted areas on mainland Iran, as well as Iranian islands in the Gulf, and resulted in civilian casualties.
Iranian media reported that five people, including a six-year-old child, were killed when a missile struck a wedding gathering in the southern city of Kuhestak.
The aggression follows the February 28 attack on an elementary school in Minab, where more than 160 people, including 120 children, were killed. Washington has not formally accepted responsibility for the strike, though US officials have said it remains under military investigation.
Hegseth has meanwhile ordered US forces deployed across West Asia to remain in the region into the middle of next year.
War on Iran strains US military readiness
Washington currently maintains approximately 50,000 troops and 19 warships in the region, partly in support of the naval blockade imposed on Iran.
According to classified material leaked from the Secretary of Defense Orders Book and reported by The Washington Post, several commanders formally objected to the extended deployments.
The officials reportedly warned that keeping large numbers of personnel and vessels concentrated in the Middle East could limit Washington's ability to respond to crises elsewhere while further burdening forces already subjected to lengthy deployments.
Manner said those concerns were also reflected in conversations he has had with serving officers.
“I have firsthand knowledge of people who are serving on active duty who echo the exact same concerns that we are headed to a situation where we can no longer defend Taiwan, that we are very unlikely to be able to defend even, quite frankly, South Korea,” he said.
He also argued that sustaining the Iran war was consuming resources intended for broader military readiness.
“These are for training the rest of the force,” Manner said of readiness accounts being used to fund the conflict. “So the rest of the force is losing training hours, equipment and money for maintenance and operations. The rest of the military is significantly degraded.”
Questions grow over US objectives in Iran
The military buildup has also revived questions over Washington's long-term objectives in the war.
Kevin Carroll, a former US Army colonel and military intelligence officer who previously worked with the offices of the war secretary and Joint Chiefs of Staff, questioned what Washington is now seeking to accomplish.
“I’m not sure what the strategy is here,” Carroll said. “What’s the enemy’s center of gravity that we’re going after?
“We tried decapitating their leadership. That didn’t work. We tried going after their missile program. We were not able to destroy it. Tried sinking the navy, but they still maintain a mining capability."
“We could easily take out their energy infrastructure. But that would drive the price of oil much, much higher, and lead to retaliatory attacks on the energy infrastructure of our Gulf allies. It’s not clear what this target set is intended to do.”
Nate Swanson, a senior fellow at the Atlantic Council and former White House and State Department advisor on Iran, said the decision to maintain forces in the region indicates Washington is settling into a longer-term strategy centered on economic pressure and blockade.
“It’s a recognition of the fact that the past six months has failed, but they don’t know what to do,” Swanson said.
Army secretary resignation exposes internal tensions
Pressure on Hegseth has also grown following the resignation of Army Secretary Dan Driscoll, an ally of Vice President JD Vance.
Driscoll had reportedly clashed repeatedly with Hegseth over officer promotions, military modernization, and the dismissal of senior commanders.
A source cited by CNN said Driscoll had raised concerns “surrounding Army transformation and readiness and Hegseth’s blocking those efforts specifically by firing the generals who were responsible."
Hegseth has made opposition to diversity, equity and inclusion policies a central part of his tenure at the Pentagon, while numerous senior officers have been removed or denied promotions.
Pentagon Culture Wars Fuel Readiness Concerns
The New York Times reported that Hegseth recently blocked seven officers from advancing to two-star general.
Tillis praised Driscoll following the resignation, writing, “Dan was the right man at the right moment to lead our Soldiers and Army civilians.”
The disputes have fueled criticism that ideological and cultural battles inside the Pentagon are taking precedence over military preparedness as US forces remain engaged in a prolonged regional conflict.
Critics draw comparisons with Rumsfeld
Some former military officials have compared Hegseth's leadership with previous defense secretaries who came under intense criticism during major US wars.
Retired Major General Paul Eaton, who trained Iraqi forces following the 2003 US invasion, argued that the situation under Hegseth is worse than that faced under former Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld.
“Rumsfeld had ‘next war-itis’, which was a contributing factor to Bush firing him after the shellacking that the Republican party had in the [2006] midterms,” Eaton said. “All this sounds faintly familiar with what we’re going through right now.
“But this is infinitely worse because we had a lot of other very smart people to corral the bad ideas coming out of Rumsfeld. [This time] we’ve had the whole removal of seasoned men and women who have learned things the hard way most of the time in combat."
“If you fail to plan, plan to fail, and what we’re seeing in the Iran war is just evidence. The frustration is, we’re better than this in the uniformed military but we got handed a terrible set of guidance from our civilian leadership.”
Hegseth's culture-war legacy questioned
Michael O’Hanlon of the Brookings Institution said the US military retained enough depth to withstand the removal of experienced personnel in the short term, but warned that some losses could be difficult to replace.
“We haven’t had a TV talkshow star with a strong partisan and cultural agenda wind up as secretary of defense,” O’Hanlon said. “There may be some echoes of previous secretaries, but the political and culture stuff is Pete Hegseth through and through.”
Hegseth, he predicted, “is going to wind up being known as the guy who fought Trump’s culture wars for him – and maybe failed to help Trump stay out of trouble in the Iran war, depending on how bad that gets.”
Read more: Pete Hegseth’s purge exposes turmoil in the US military