'Israel' faces a costly reckoning as Washington pulls back aid: FP
Foreign Policy examines how the end of US military aid could deepen "Israel's" military and economic challenges and reshape its relationship with Washington.
-
US President Donald Trump listens during a news conference with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in the State Dining Room of the White House, Sept. 29, 2025, in Washington. (AP/Evan Vucci, File)
Washington's decision to end military assistance to "Israel" marks a significant deterioration in bilateral relations, removing a longstanding pillar of the alliance as the occupation becomes increasingly reliant on US political and military backing.
The development comes at a time when "Israel" faces mounting military expenditure, declining political support in the United States, and growing difficulties sustaining its regional military ambitions, according to an analysis published by Foreign Policy.
The magazine stressed that the decision originated in Washington rather than resulting from a mutually agreed arrangement, contrary to how US President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu presented it. The move therefore signals a major shift in a relationship that has been central to "Israel's" security since the October 1973 war.
Support for 'Israel' erodes across US political parties
"Israel" is increasingly losing its traditional bipartisan backing in Washington, with opposition extending beyond Democrats to sections of the Republican Party. The $3.8 billion in annual US military assistance has become a focal point of criticism from both sides: progressives argue that taxpayers are financing the genocide in Gaza, while Republicans associated with the "America First" movement oppose subsidizing an ally they believe should provide for its own arms.
The erosion of public sympathy has accelerated since Operation Al-Aqsa Flood on October 7, 2023, as the genocide in Gaza, settler violence in the occupied West Bank, and "Israel's" role in persuading Trump to attack Iran have further damaged its standing among Americans. Its relationship with younger Republicans has also come under increasing pressure.
Before October 7, US assistance represented roughly 20% of the so-called "Israeli defense budget." That proportion has since dropped to 10% or less, not because military requirements have diminished, but because Israeli military expenditure has tripled.
The economic burden is expected to grow as Netanyahu seeks to sustain higher military spending throughout the coming decade. His plans involve expanding military personnel and launching an extensive weapons buildup, reflecting the heightened sense of vulnerability following Operation Al-Aqsa Flood and the absence of a "decisive victory" in "Israel's" aggression against Iran, Lebanon, and Palestine.
Foreign Policy warned that maintaining this military posture would leave the Israeli economy carrying one of the world's heaviest arms burdens for years. Without US assistance, taxpayers will also have to cover a larger portion of military costs than the government had initially expected.
Netanyahu's military ambitions exceed 'Israel's' industrial capacity
Netanyahu has responded to the prospect of losing US assistance by promoting a "more independent" military strategy. However, reducing reliance on Washington would require a substantial expansion of domestic weapons production, placing additional pressure on an economy already facing rising defense expenditure.
The magazine noted that "Israel's" industrial infrastructure cannot independently satisfy all its military requirements. Although it manufactures advanced weapons, its production capacity is insufficient to supply everything from complete fighter jets to the thousands of specialized components needed to build them.
The loss of American financial assistance and ammunition supplies is particularly consequential given their importance in sustaining "Israel's" prolonged military campaigns. Rather than achieving greater independence, Netanyahu's pursuit of regional dominance has deepened the occupation's reliance on external support, as his ambitions to reshape the region exceed what "Israel" can accomplish alone.
Nor does "Israel" have alternative international partnerships capable of filling the gap. Its relations with European countries have deteriorated under Netanyahu, further narrowing its diplomatic and military options.
End of US aid changes nature of bilateral relations
The termination of military assistance is expected to transform Washington's relationship with "Israel" from one sustained by broad domestic political support into a more "transactional" arrangement based on mutual interests and strategic benefits.
Although the United States will remain essential to "Israel", the magazine argued that Washington may increasingly expect the occupation to demonstrate what it contributes in return for the partnership. The question is no longer simply what assistance "Israel" needs, but "What will Israel offer the United States?"
A central complication is the diminishing value of "Israel" as a "force for regional stability." Developments in Syria, Lebanon, and the Gaza Strip have undermined that role, with the magazine pointing to "Israel's" continued military presence and attacks in these territories, alongside its rejection of proposed security arrangements with Syria and Lebanon and its obstruction of Trump's Gaza reconstruction efforts.
The report also raised the possibility that Washington could eventually reduce its presence in West Asia, particularly following the consequences of the war on Iran and the US midterm election results. Under such circumstances, Foreign Policy stated that "Israel" risks becoming a secondary regional power with diminishing influence over American policy.
Trump announced his intention to terminate military assistance by the end of the year on November 3, coinciding with the US midterm elections. Netanyahu subsequently confirmed the announcement publicly on X.
The political implications became clearer the following day when US Vice President JD Vance cited demands for a change in Washington's relationship with "Israel" among four reasons Republican voters had turned away from the party. Trump also identified widespread "hatred" toward "Israel" as one factor behind the Republicans' electoral defeat, underscoring the growing domestic political costs of the alliance.
Read more: Bannon: CIA, ‘Israel First’ camp dragged US back into Iran war